01Facts
The plaintiff, a daughter, sued for partition and separate possession of the suit schedule properties, alleging they were ancestral and joint family properties of a Hindu Undivided Family comprising herself and defendants 1 to 6, the children of Basanna and Bhimabai (defendant no. 5).
¶ 3Basanna died in 1999.
¶ 3Defendants 1 to 5 admitted that certain properties were ancestral, identified additional ancestral properties not included in the suit, claimed that certain properties (Sl. Nos. 8, 10 and 11) were their self-acquired properties, and filed a counter-claim for partition of the ancestral properties.
¶ 4–6The plaintiff contended that the counter-claim lands were Government lands nominally allotted to her.
¶ 7The Trial Court decreed the suit, declaring the plaintiff entitled to a 7/49th share in all suit properties (Sl. Nos. 1–13), and dismissed the counter-claim.
¶ 11, 29On appeal in R.A. No. 15 of 2014, the First Appellate Court held that the propositus died before the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, so the daughters were not coparceners in 1999 and were not entitled to equal shares. It modified the decree, granting defendants 1–4 a 1/5th + 1/7th share and the plaintiff a 1/7th share in Basanna's share, and defendants 5 and 6 a 1/7th share in Basanna's share.
¶ 13–14, 30The plaintiff filed the present second appeal.
¶ 15Counsel for the plaintiff stated that defendant no. 5 is deceased.
¶ 18, 20Respondents were served but unrepresented.
¶ 1602Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court was justified in denying the plaintiff/daughter a share in the father's property on the ground that the father died in 1999, before the 2005 amendment to Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act.
¶ 21(i) · see also paras. 30–32ii.2. Whether the judgment of the First Appellate Court warrants interference in light of the amended Section 6 of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and the decision in Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, (2020) 9 SCC 1.
¶ 21(ii) · see also paras. 31–3203Law Applied
The Court applied Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, under which a second appeal lies only on a substantial question of law.
¶ 1 · ¶ 21Section 6 of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 confers coparcenary status on daughters as coparceners by birth with rights equal to sons.
¶ 18, 32Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, (2020) 9 SCC 1, as summarised by the Court: a daughter's coparcenary right under the amended Section 6 does not depend on whether the father was alive on the date of amendment, so daughters born after 1956 are treated as coparceners as on 9 September 2005.
¶ 19, 31Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The First Appellate Court denied the daughter an equal share because the propositus died in 1999, before the amendment.
¶ 30–31The High Court held that this reasoning conflicts with Vineeta Sharma, under which the father's survival on the date of amendment is immaterial.
¶ 31The First Appellate Court's finding was therefore a misapplication of Section 6 and was held to violate the statutory provision.
¶ 32The Court accepted the plaintiff's submission that defendant no. 5 is deceased, which is the basis for the revised share.
¶ 20, 35(iv)The judgment does not expressly show the arithmetic by which the 1/6th share was derived, nor does it expressly address the counter-claim findings, which were set aside only to the extent of the modification of shares.
¶ 33, 3505Holding
The Court answered Substantial Question No. 1 in the negative and Substantial Question No. 2 in the affirmative.
¶ 34The Second Appeal is allowed. The First Appellate Court's judgment dated 25.07.2016 in R.A. No. 15 of 2014 is set aside. The Trial Court's judgment and preliminary decree dated 30.04.2014 in O.S. No. 37 of 2010 is modified, and the plaintiff is held entitled to a 1/6th share in all suit schedule properties, Sl. Nos. 1–13. The Registry is directed to draw the preliminary decree accordingly.
¶ 35(ii)–(iv), 35(vi)Original Court PDF
SMT.PARWATI W/O PARTAPPAvsSHIVANNA S/O BASANNA AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
