01Facts
The suit properties, R.S. Nos. 63 and 75/2 and house property VPC Nos. 239A and 239B, Neeralakeri, were claimed to be ancestral.
¶ 2Holiyappa, the propositus, died in 1948 leaving five children, including Butappa (Defendant No. 1), Ramappa, and three daughters.
¶ 4The plaintiffs, wife and daughter of Ramappa, sued for partition in O.S. No. 130/1995 without joining Holiyappa's daughters, contending they had no surviving rights.
¶ 4The defendants pleaded non-joinder; the trial court rejected this, and the appellate courts affirmed it in R.A. No. 8/2006 and R.S.A. No. 5124/2010.
¶ 4The trial court decreed a half share to Plaintiff No. 2 on 19.07.2005.
¶ 2(iii)Plaintiff No. 2 initiated FDP No. 5/2011, and the final decree was ordered on 26.02.2021 (the body of the judgment at para. 2(v) states 26.02.2020).
¶ 2(iv)–(v)Defendant No. 2's appeal, R.A. No. 9/2021, was dismissed on 15.12.2023.
¶ 2(vi)RSA No. 100001/2024 by Defendant No. 2 was dismissed on 08.01.2024, with the Court holding that the daughters' entitlement under Vineeta Sharma did not assist him.
¶ 8The present appellants, not parties to earlier proceedings, filed IA No. V in R.A. No. 9/2021 seeking impleadment; it was rejected on 18.11.2023 for want of proof of relationship.
¶ 2(viii) · ¶ 7Their writ petition (W.P. No. 107013/2023) was dismissed as infructuous on 04.03.2024.
¶ 13The present RSA was filed on 16.01.2024 and admitted on 22.02.2024.
¶ 2(ix) · ¶ 3 · ¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the appellants, as grandchildren of the propositus' daughters, are entitled to a share in the suit properties in view of Vineeta Sharma.
¶ 3ii.2. Whether, if so, the judgments and decrees in FDP No. 5/2011 and R.A. No. 9/2021 require reconsideration.
¶ 303Law Applied
The Court relied on substituted Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, under which daughters become coparceners by birth with rights equal to sons.
¶ 9Per Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma & Ors., (2020) 9 SCC 1 (AIR 2020 SC 3717), this applies even where a preliminary decree has been passed, and daughters must be given coparcenary shares in pending final decree proceedings or appeals.
¶ 5 · ¶ 9The principle is not applied mechanically: it presupposes that the properties are coparcenary in nature, and the claimant must show a prima facie basis for that character and for their own status as legal representatives.
¶ 10 · ¶ 12Impleadment in a pending proceeding requires a sufficient affidavit and documentary proof, such as a family tree, showing relationship and the date and manner of succession, and the Court may refuse impleadment where the application is filed to delay proceedings.
¶ 11 · ¶ 12 · ¶ 13The earlier decisions in R.A. No. 8/2006 and R.S.A. No. 5124/2010, which upheld the preliminary decree, bind the parties on the scope of the decree.
¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 6
04Reasoning
The Court held that Vineeta Sharma could not be applied "straight away" because the record did not establish that the suit properties were coparcenary.
¶ 10The pleadings and the affidavit in IA No. V both described Holiyappa as the original owner, and the defendants' case rested on Ramappa's registered Will.
¶ 10The appellants were not parties to any earlier proceeding, and no document was produced to show they were legal heirs of Holiyappa's daughters.
¶ 11 · ¶ 12The affidavit supporting IA No. V did not disclose when the appellants succeeded to the properties or why they had not approached the Court earlier.
¶ 12The Court noted the delay of roughly 28 years in enforcing the decree, the earlier non-joinder challenge that had already failed, and the irregularity in the affidavit, which was prepared in one person's name but sworn by another.
¶ 2(viii) · ¶ 7 · ¶ 13Relying on these facts, the Court concluded that the impleadment application was filed to prolong the matter rather than to assert genuine rights.
¶ 11 · ¶ 13Since the first appellate court's rejection of IA No. V was justified, the Court found no basis to reopen the final decree.
¶ 13The Court did not separately record a finding on the second limb of the framed question, as its answer to the first limb disposed of the appeal.
¶ 13 · ¶ 1405Holding
The substantial question of law is answered in the negative: the appellants, having failed to establish that the properties were coparcenary or that they are legal representatives of Holiyappa's daughters, are not entitled to impleadment or to reopening the final decree on the basis of Vineeta Sharma.
¶ 13The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, and pending applications, if any, are disposed of.
¶ 14The judgment and decree in R.A. No. 9/2021 and the final decree in FDP No. 5/2011 stand confirmed.
¶ 13 · ¶ 14Original Court PDF
SMT. TIPPAVVA W/O SIDDAPPA ADAPATTIvsSMT. SHIDDAVVA W/O DYAMAPPA KAMBALI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
