Punjab and Haryana High CourtTax LawAdministrative and Public Law

Deemed show cause notice under Section 148A(b) cannot be enlarged by adding new income to invoke extended limitation.

Tanu Jainv.Union Of India And Others

Deemed show cause notice under Section 148A(b) cannot be enlarged by adding new income to invoke extended limitation.. Tanu Jain vs Union Of India And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, upon the notice dated 30.03.2021 being treated as a show cause notice under s. 148A(b), the AO could introduce an item of escaped income (Rs. 36,05,000) that did not form the basis of that notice

The court held

The court answered issues (i), (ii) and (iii) in the negative, issue (ii) in the affirmative, and rejected the alternative-remedy objection

It also directed

A deemed s. 148A(b) notice remains confined to its original grounds, the Rs. 36,05,000 item is time-barred, and Rs. 26,40,000 alone cannot sustain reassessment under s. 149(1)(b)

The writ petition was allowed. The notice dated 08.05.2026 under s. 148A(b), the order dated 25.06.2026 under s. 148A(d), and the notice dated 25.06.2026 under s. 148 were quashed, together with all consequential proceedings for AY 2013-14

No order as to costs

01Facts

The petitioner's return for AY 2013-14 was processed under s. 143(1) without scrutiny assessment

¶ 4

A notice dated 30.03.2021 under the pre-amendment s. 148 was issued, alleging escaped income of Rs. 26,40,000

¶ 2, 5

Because it was dispatched on or after 01.04.2021, it was treated as a show cause notice under s. 148A(b) in accordance with Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal and the order in CWP No. 2710 of 2022 dated 30.04.2026

¶ 2, 8–9

The reasons supplied on 23.12.2021 identified only Rs. 26,40,000

¶ 6

Proceedings were held in abeyance from 14.02.2022

¶ 7

On 08.05.2026, the AO enclosed Insight Portal material for two items: Rs. 26,40,000 (marked "Information already sent to AO") and Rs. 36,05,000 (a separate source, first put to the petitioner on that date)

¶ 10

The petitioner filed no reply

¶ 10

On 25.06.2026 the AO aggregated the items to Rs. 62,45,000, invoked the ten-year period under s. 149(1)(b), and issued a s. 148 notice of the same date

¶ 11

The petitioner filed the writ on 03.07.2026

¶ 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether, upon the notice dated 30.03.2021 being treated as a show cause notice under s. 148A(b), the AO could introduce an item of escaped income (Rs. 36,05,000) that did not form the basis of that notice

¶ 16(i)

ii.2. Whether the proceeding in respect of Rs. 36,05,000 is barred by limitation under s. 149

¶ 16(ii)

iii.3. Whether the proceeding can survive on Rs. 26,40,000 alone

¶ 16(iii)

iv.4. Whether the petitioner ought to be relegated to the alternative remedy

¶ 16(iv)

03Law Applied

Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal (2023) 1 SCC 617 deems pre-amendment notices to be s. 148A(b) show cause notices and requires disclosure of the "information and material relied upon"

¶ 8, 17

A legal fiction is confined to its purpose and must not be extended beyond it

¶ 19

Reasons for reopening cannot be supplemented later

¶ 20

Section 149(1) as it stood applies, including the first proviso, the ten-year period under s. 149(1)(b) (available only where escaped income is Rs. 50 lakh or more), and the third proviso excluding time for s. 148A proceedings

¶ 29–30, 32

Union of India v. Rajeev Bansal (2024) 469 ITR 46 (SC) provides that a deemed notice for an earlier assessment year must satisfy both the unamended and substituted s. 149(1) limits

¶ 28, 32, 38(iii)

Section 147 operates only after a valid s. 148 notice

¶ 26

The existence of an alternative remedy is no bar where the authority acts wholly without jurisdiction, per Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks (1998) 8 SCC 1

¶ 37

Provisions in the judgment · 7

Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 10Section 142Section 143Section 147Section 148Section 148ASection 149

04Reasoning

The court held that the deemed notice of 30.03.2021 was founded only on the Rs. 26,40,000 item, as shown by the contemporaneous reasons

¶ 20, 22

Presence of the second item on the Insight Portal on 07.03.2021 did not amount to reliance on it, and the two items were separate pieces of information despite their similar subject matter

¶ 22–23

The residual "other income" language in the reasons could not widen the foundation of the notice

¶ 21

The disclosure obligation under Ashish Agarwal could not be converted into a power to enlarge the notice

¶ 24

The court treated the 08.05.2026 introduction of the Rs. 36,05,000 item as a fresh show cause notice, with limitation measured from that date

¶ 28

On that basis, the three-year period expired on 31.03.2017 and the ten-year period on 31.03.2024; the first proviso's six-year period expired on 30.06.2021 even with the Relaxation Act extension

¶ 29

The third proviso did not help the Revenue, since the stay and time exclusions related only to the proceeding founded on Rs. 26,40,000

¶ 30

Because the aggregate was the sole basis for invoking s. 149(1)(b), and Rs. 26,40,000 alone is below Rs. 50 lakh, the extended period was unavailable

¶ 32–33

The petitioner's replication statement on the unamended provision was not a binding concession on jurisdiction

¶ 34

Remand for a fresh s. 148A(d) order confined to Rs. 26,40,000 was held futile, since it would be time-barred on its face

¶ 35

The alternative-remedy objection failed because the limitation bar goes to jurisdiction and the dispute turns on undisputed documents and pure law

¶ 37

05Holding

The court answered issues (i), (ii) and (iii) in the negative, issue (ii) in the affirmative, and rejected the alternative-remedy objection

¶ 27, 31, 36–37

A deemed s. 148A(b) notice remains confined to its original grounds, the Rs. 36,05,000 item is time-barred, and Rs. 26,40,000 alone cannot sustain reassessment under s. 149(1)(b)

¶ 38(i)–(iii)

The writ petition was allowed. The notice dated 08.05.2026 under s. 148A(b), the order dated 25.06.2026 under s. 148A(d), and the notice dated 25.06.2026 under s. 148 were quashed, together with all consequential proceedings for AY 2013-14

¶ 39

No order as to costs

¶ 41
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Tanu JainvsUnion Of India And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment