Punjab and Haryana High CourtTax LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Vague, unsubstantiated explanation lacking diligence does not constitute sufficient cause for condonation of delay.

Ms Rana Sugars Ltdv.Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh

Vague, unsubstantiated explanation lacking diligence does not constitute sufficient cause for condonation of delay.. Ms Rana Sugars Ltd vs Deputy  Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the ITAT erred in law in dismissing the appellant's appeals for inordinate delay of 1862 days, where the appellant contended that the delay was bona fide, caused by genuine oversight and reliance on professional employees who resigned without informing management

The court held

The court answered Issue 1 against the appellant: the explanation for the 1862-day delay does not constitute sufficient cause under s. 253(5), and no question of law arises from the ITAT's refusal to condone delay

It also directed

On Issue 2, the court held that the merits questions need not be answered

Both appeals (ITA Nos. 104 and 106 of 2026) are dismissed, and the ITAT's order dated 04.08.2025 is upheld

01Facts

The appellant company, engaged in sugar, alcohol, spirit manufacturing and power generation, faced scrutiny assessments for AY 2010-11 and 2011-12 under s. 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961

¶ 2, 3

The CIT(A) partly allowed the appellant's appeal by order dated 08.05.2018

¶ 2, 3

The limitation for appealing to the ITAT expired on 07.07.2018

¶ 6

The appellant filed its ITAT appeals (ITA Nos. 512 and 513/Chandi/2023) on 12.08.2023, a delay of 1862 days

¶ 2, 3, 6

The condonation application was moved only on 17.07.2024

¶ 2, 7, 10

The appellant explained the delay by stating that (a) a search or survey took place on 16.02.2018; (b) its CFO and General Manager resigned in 2019 without handing over charge or informing management; (c) three tax consultants were changed between 2018 and 2022; and (d) the present counsel discovered the partial disallowance only on a later review

¶ 7

The Revenue had separately filed appeals against the same CIT(A) order in 2018, which were pending before the ITAT

¶ 7, 11

The ITAT dismissed the appellant's appeals for want of condonation of delay and dismissed the Revenue's appeals on merits by common order dated 04.08.2025

¶ 1, 3

The appellant then filed the present appeals, raising Question (i) on condonation and further merits questions

¶ 2, 3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the ITAT erred in law in dismissing the appellant's appeals for inordinate delay of 1862 days, where the appellant contended that the delay was bona fide, caused by genuine oversight and reliance on professional employees who resigned without informing management

¶ 2 (Q.i) · ¶ 5, 13

ii.2. Whether the merits questions (Q.ii–iii in ITA-104/2026 and Q.ii–iv in ITA-106/2026) require adjudication once Question (i) is decided

¶ 5, 14

03Law Applied

The court applied s. 253(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which requires an appeal to the ITAT within sixty days of communication of the impugned order

¶ 6

The court relied on s. 253(5), which empowers the ITAT to condone delay in its discretion, and held that the discretion must be exercised on a consideration of the explanation offered, which must constitute "sufficient cause"

¶ 13

The judgment cites no precedent on the "sufficient cause" standard

The court treats the explanation as requiring specificity and evidentiary support, including affidavits, resignation documents, and identified dates

¶ 8, 9, 10

Provisions in the judgment · 8

Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 142Section 143Section 40Section 201Section 36Section 253Section 132Section 133A

04Reasoning

The court found the appellant's explanation vague and unsupported. The resignation dates of the CFO and General Manager were not established, no resignation letters or acceptance records were produced, and the application was unsworn, being a letter without affidavit

¶ 8

The resignations occurred in 2019, after the limitation period had expired on 07.07.2018, so they could not explain the original default

¶ 8

The explanation was also inconsistent: the ITAT application described a search under s. 132, whereas the grounds before the High Court described a survey under s. 133A

¶ 8

The claim of changing three tax consultants was unspecified as to names and periods and did not explain management's failure to ascertain the outcome of its own appeal

¶ 9

The period from 2022 to 12.08.2023 and the eleven-month gap before the condonation application was moved (12.08.2023 to 17.07.2024) remained wholly unexplained

¶ 10

The plea of management's unawareness was negated by the appellant's own admission that the Revenue's pending ITAT appeals arose from the same CIT(A) order, and by its admission that the major confirmed addition under s. 36(1)(iii) was connected to the Revenue's appeal

¶ 11

The court held that management's involvement in other agency actions reflected negligence, not sufficient cause

¶ 12

Because the ITAT had exercised its s. 253(5) discretion on a proper consideration of the explanation, no substantial question of law arose

¶ 13

Since Question (i) was answered against the appellant, the court held it unnecessary to examine the merits questions

¶ 14

05Holding

The court answered Issue 1 against the appellant: the explanation for the 1862-day delay does not constitute sufficient cause under s. 253(5), and no question of law arises from the ITAT's refusal to condone delay

¶ 13

On Issue 2, the court held that the merits questions need not be answered

¶ 14

Both appeals (ITA Nos. 104 and 106 of 2026) are dismissed, and the ITAT's order dated 04.08.2025 is upheld

¶ 15
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Ms Rana Sugars LtdvsDeputy Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 21, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment