01Facts
The petitioner is an Indian wholly owned subsidiary of JFE Steel Corporation, Japan ("JFE Japan"). It provides market research services to JFE Japan under General Service Agreements.
¶ 4The petitioner engages JFE Japan personnel under a Dispatch Agreement (2013), a Secondment Agreement (2014) and individual employment contracts. The Dispatch Agreement makes the petitioner responsible for role, work, control and salary, and the petitioner deducts tax under s. 192 of the Income Tax Act and issues Form 16.
¶ 5–7A 2019 service tax show cause notice on the same arrangement was dropped by the Principal Commissioner on 24.02.2021. That order is under appeal before CESTAT and is not stayed.
¶ 8–9After Northern Operating Systems was decided on 19.05.2022, the Department sought the agreements and reimbursement details, which the petitioner supplied.
¶ 10–11The CBIC issued Instruction No. 05/2023-GST on 13.12.2023, and Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST on 26.06.2024 on valuation of related-person imports where full ITC is available.
¶ 12–13A Show Cause Notice dated 30.07.2024 under s. 74(1) of the CGST Act, read with s. 20 of the IGST Act, proposed IGST of Rs. 13,08,57,858 for July 2017 to March 2023, with interest and penalty under s. 122(2)(b).
¶ 2, 14The petitioner replied and was heard, and the Order-in-Original dated 09.01.2025 confirmed the demand. The petitioner challenged the order under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 1, 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the writ petition ought to be refused entertainment because an appeal lies under s. 107 of the CGST Act.
¶ 27–28ii.2. Whether the proceedings could validly be initiated and concluded under s. 74 of the CGST Act.
¶ 27, 34iii.3. Whether the demand could be confirmed notwithstanding Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024.
¶ 27, 47iv.4. Whether the impugned order satisfies the requirement of a reasoned order under s. 75(6).
¶ 27, 6003Law Applied
Alternative remedy is a rule of discretion, not law, and does not bar relief where the challenge concerns jurisdiction, natural justice, or a pure question of law on undisputed facts (Whirlpool; Godrej Sara Lee).
¶ 29–31Section 74 applies only where non-payment is by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, a condition that must be evident from the notice itself (Cosmic Dye Chemical; G.R. Infra Projects Limited v. State of Madhya Pradesh; Tata Steel Limited v. Union of India).
¶ 34–37Instruction No. 05/2023-GST bars mechanical invocation of s. 74 in secondment cases.
¶ 38Under s. 168(1) of the CGST Act, officers must observe and follow Board circulars, and a circular cannot be read down by the adjudicating authority.
¶ 47, 52Under the second proviso to Rule 28(1) of the CGST Rules, read with para. 3.7 of Circular 210/4/2024-GST, the value of a related-person service is deemed "Nil" where full ITC is available and no invoice has been issued (Metal One Corporation India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine Del 7499; Alstom Transport India Ltd. v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 15572).
¶ 48–50, 53–54Section 75(6) requires reasons that engage with the relevant facts and submissions. A rubber-stamp recital is not a valid decision (Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan; S.N. Mukherjee v. Union of India).
¶ 60Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 10 provisions
Section 7Section 17Section 31Section 50Section 73Section 74Section 75Section 107Section 122Section 168Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 Section 20
Central Excise Act, 1944 Section 11
04Reasoning
The Court held the petition maintainable. Its challenge to the s. 74 jurisdictional fact and its reliance on a binding circular raised pure questions of law on undisputed facts, and Greatship did not displace these exceptions.
¶ 31–32On s. 74, the SCN rested only on non-payment and the post-Northern Operating Systems "clarificatory" nature of that judgment. Neither paragraph disclosed any fact from which intent to evade could be inferred.
¶ 39–40The petitioner's position was stronger than the assessee's in Northern Operating Systems, because the same arrangement had been adjudicated in its favour in 2021 and was never shown to have changed. Non-payment on a bona fide view of non-taxability is not suppression.
¶ 41, 44The Court also held that an affidavit cannot supply what the notice lacks.
¶ 43On the Circular, the Court rejected the authority's reading that it applies only where "consideration is not involved." Paragraphs 3.5–3.7 contain no such limit, and Metal One involved the same secondment-and-salary facts and was expressly considered.
¶ 52–54The reasoning that the value is the remuneration paid also ignored the proviso that is part of Rule 28.
¶ 55The impugned order was further criticised for reproducing the SCN, ignoring the petitioner's defence and the Board Instruction, and misnaming the petitioner's foreign affiliate as "Metal One Japan". It also stated a period (July 2017–March 2022) that differed from the SCN and the DRC-07 summary.
¶ 56, 61–65Because the s. 74 foundation failed and the Circular defeated any demand, the Court declined to remand. It left open whether the arrangement is employment under Schedule III because the matter is pending before CESTAT.
¶ 67–6805Holding
(A) The s. 107 appeal remedy does not bar relief under Art. 226 in these facts.
¶ 28–33, 70(A)(B) The pre-conditions for s. 74 were not disclosed in the SCN and did not exist, so the proceedings and penalty are unsustainable.
¶ 39–45, 70(B)(C) The petitioner is eligible for full ITC and issued no invoice, so the value is deemed "Nil" under Rule 28(1) read with para. 3.7 of Circular 210/4/2024-GST, and the demand of tax, interest and penalty is contrary to s. 168(1).
¶ 50, 58–59, 70(C)(D) The order is not a reasoned order under s. 75(6).
¶ 60–67, 70(D)The writ petition was allowed. The Order-in-Original dated 09.01.2025 (Annexure P-1) and the DRC-07 summaries are quashed, and the SCN dated 30.07.2024 (Annexure P-13) with its DRC-01 summary is quashed.
¶ 71(i)–(ii)Any amount deposited or recovered must be refunded within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy. No order as to costs.
¶ 71(iii) · ¶ 72Original Court PDF
Ms Jfe Steel India Private LimitedvsUnion Of India And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
