01Facts
The Appellant, a subsidiary of Honda Trading Corporation, Japan, engaged in trading steel coils and processing them through slitting, blanking and welding.
pp. 2–3It entered into international transactions with Associated Enterprises (AEs), including purchases of raw materials and capital goods and payment of royalty/technical fees, and supported these with a transfer pricing study.
pp. 2–3The Appellant contended that its processing activities were not full-fledged manufacturing and that its business should be treated as a single segment.
p. 3For AY 2009-10 the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) treated the Appellant as the tested party, split its business into manufacturing and trading segments, applied TNMM to each, rejected the Appellant's comparables and introduced new ones.
pp. 3–4The Assessing Officer (AO) incorporated the TPO's adjustments in final assessment orders for AYs 2009-10 and 2010-11.
p. 4The CIT(A) largely upheld the adjustments, granting only partial relief.
p. 5The ITAT, by its common order dated 27.03.2025, upheld the segmentation, the TNMM application and the choice of tested party, remitted the comparables issue to the TPO, and granted a capacity utilisation adjustment for AY 2009-10 subject to verification.
pp. 5–6The Appellant appealed to the High Court under Section 260A.
p. 602Issues
i.1. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the TPO's transfer pricing adjustments without first examining whether the TPO validly rejected the Appellant's transfer pricing study before substituting his own benchmarking analysis.
p. 7 · ¶ 3 · p. 9 · ¶ 7ii.2. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the bifurcation of the Appellant's unified business into manufacturing and trading segments without independently examining whether the activities amounted to manufacture, relying instead on a coordinate Bench decision for AY 2016-17 that was under challenge.
pp. 7–8 · ¶ 4 · pp. 9–10 · ¶ 803Law Applied
The Court did not finally decide the substantive legal questions. It relied on the Appellant's submissions that the TPO must expressly reject a transfer pricing study before substituting his own benchmarking, citing Li & Fung India (P.) Ltd. v. CIT, 361 ITR 85 (Del.) and PCIT v. Coim India (P.) Ltd., 160 taxmann.com 756 (Del.).
p. 7 · ¶ 3It also noted the Appellant's reliance on Section 2(29BA) of the IT Act, Saraswati Sugar Mills v. Haryana State Board, (1992) 1 SCC 418, and Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association v. UOI, 2004 (178) E.L.T. 1099 (Del.), for the proposition that mere processing of steel is not manufacture.
pp. 7–8 · ¶ 4The governing principle applied is that an appellate forum must return categorical findings on contested issues before the outcome can be sustained, and that a decision resting on findings later set aside cannot survive independently.
pp. 9–10 · ¶ 7–8The Court relied on its own decision in ITA 175/2023 (AY 2016-17), which set aside the ITAT's findings in that year and remanded the matter.
p. 10 · ¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 4
Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 143Section 144CSection 260ASection 2
04Reasoning
The Court first held that the Appellant had specifically challenged the TPO's basis for substituting its benchmarking without expressly rejecting the transfer pricing study. The ITAT had noticed this contention and the supporting precedents but returned no clear finding on it. The validity of the TPO's approach therefore had to be examined before the correctness of the adjustments could be determined.
p. 9 · ¶ 7On segmentation, the Court held that whether the activities amounted to manufacturing required examination of the activities performed, the machinery used, the extent of value addition and the Appellant's functional, asset and risk (FAR) profile. The ITAT had substantially adopted the AY 2016-17 findings without independently assessing the material and the Appellant's objections for the years in question.
p. 9 · ¶ 8 · pp. 9–10 · ¶ 8Since this Court had set aside those AY 2016-17 findings in ITA 175/2023, the foundation of the impugned order was itself unsound and required reconsideration.
p. 10 · ¶ 8 · p. 10 · ¶ 9The Court did not address the Revenue's inconsistency argument on AYs 2012-13 and 2014-15, the capacity utilisation issue, or the merits of TNMM and comparables. These were left for the AO/TPO.
p. 8 · ¶ 4 · p. 10 · ¶ 1005Holding
The Court did not decide whether the TPO's substitution was valid or whether the activities constituted manufacturing. It held that the ITAT's decision rested on findings since set aside and that the threshold procedural and factual questions were unresolved.
p. 10 · ¶ 8–9The appeals are allowed. The ITAT order dated 27.03.2025 is set aside to the extent challenged, and the matter is remanded to the AO, who must obtain a TPO report where required. The AO/TPO must examine the transfer pricing study and the Appellant's objections, the nature of the business, segmentation, selection of comparables and claimed adjustments after affording an effective hearing, and must pass a reasoned order uninfluenced by the Court's observations. All contentions are left open. Pending applications stand disposed of.
p. 10 · ¶ 9–10 · pp. 10–11 · ¶ 10–11 · p. 11 · ¶ 12Original Court PDF
Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Center Private LimitedvsDeputy Commissioner Of Income Tax
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
