01Facts
The Petitioner Society (322 members), formed from four chawls at Agripada on BMC land, executed Development Agreements with the predecessor of Hare Krishna Builders ("HK Builders") in December 2005.
¶ 2Members moved to transit accommodation between 2006 and 2008.
¶ 2The 2019 Rectification cum Supplementary Deed ("2019 SDA") contained Clause 11, requiring completion within 24 months, subject to force majeure, a 6-month grace period and phase-wise shifting of members.
¶ 5The Society alleged non-furnishing of the full performance guarantee (Clause 5), mortgage of Clause 8 flats, unpaid property tax exceeding Rs. 11 crores (Clause 14), and an unauthorised 80% induction of new partners (Clause 17).
¶ 6Following COVID-19, the Society issued notices in 2021 and HK Builders inducted two new partners on December 6, 2021.
¶ 7Parallel proceedings produced a Holding Order (August 10 and December 14, 2023) restraining termination.
¶ 8, 10An architect appointed by the Section 9 Court reported on the work done.
¶ 10On July 23, 2024, the matter was referred to arbitration, with a direction to decide the Section 17 application expeditiously and "uninfluenced by the interim orders".
¶ 11The Impugned Order dated April 4, 2025 (collected by the Society on September 3, 2025) refused to terminate the 2019 SDA, held the Holding Order the status quo ante, and imposed conditional directions with a vacation trigger if 71 units in Wing A and 79 in Wing B were not completed by November 18, 2025.
¶ 1, 13, 14, 39–40The Society challenged the order under Section 37(2)(b).
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Arbitrator wrongly used the Holding Order as the baseline, contrary to Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order.
¶ 18(A) · ¶ 23–25ii.2. Whether the prima facie findings on pre-2016 work, post-2019 position and the "80%" completion claim are open to interference.
¶ 18(B) · ¶ 26–29iii.3. Whether the prima facie findings on the mortgage, tax dues, transfer of control and the August 2022 waiver are open to interference.
¶ 18(C) · ¶ 30–32, 36iv.4. Whether the treatment of loss of trust is open to interference.
¶ 18(D) · ¶ 31, 36v.5. Whether the Petition was duly authorised by the Society.
¶ 18(E) · ¶ 34vi.6. Whether the with-prejudice offer accepted by the Arbitrator and the delay in communicating the Impugned Order warrant interference.
¶ 18(F) · ¶ 38–4103Law Applied
Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 operates as an appeal against a Section 17 order and carries the same scope of review as the original power.
¶ 20Following Jute Corporation of India Ltd. v. CIT, interference is confined to discretion exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or perversely.
¶ 20Following Wander Ltd. v. Antox India (P) Ltd., interference is confined to cases where settled principles were ignored; that another view is possible is insufficient, and the appellate court must not conduct a mini-trial.
¶ 19, 21–22, 36Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order, directing that the Section 17 application be decided expeditiously and uninfluenced by the interim orders.
¶ 11, 23Rajawadi Arunodaya CHSL v. Value Projects Pvt. Ltd. (Category 3 cases, where the society has vacated, the developer has done work and financial/completion default has followed).
¶ 31Hind Construction Contracts v. State of Maharashtra (time not of the essence in construction contracts), as cited in the Impugned Order.
¶ 13(B), fn. 1, fn. 3Authorities on the Society's representative capacity and the Section 17 interim-relief framework, applied through the same deferential standard.
¶ 34, 36Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 37Section 17Section 9
Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 14
04Reasoning
The Arbitrator had examined the architect's report, the 2019 SDA and the Society's internal divisions before treating the Holding Order as the baseline. That approach was analytical and reasoned, not a dogmatic postulate, so it did not breach Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order.
¶ 24–25The prima facie findings on work completed, the effect of the 2019 SDA, COVID-19 and the Society's post-2019 conduct were reasonable, reasoned and not perverse. Disputed facts on the accuracy of the architect's findings were for trial.
¶ 26–29, 32A Category 3 characterisation under Rajawadi Arunodaya was open on these facts.
¶ 31The induction of new partners was not prohibited by contract, and the absence of a change-in-control clause supported the prima facie view. Waiver and loss of confidence were also matters for trial.
¶ 30, 36The mortgage and tax issues were expressly left for the tribunal to address at trial.
¶ 36 · ¶ 42The balance of convenience favoured HK Builders not being reduced to a money claim, given the project's stage.
¶ 37The conditional directions were treated as reasonable moulding of relief, not rewriting of contract. The with-prejudice offer was a condition of the interim arrangement and was not a rewriting of the contract.
¶ 38The Petition was properly authorised, since the Managing Committee had decided to appeal and the Section 37 challenge was considered on the merits.
¶ 34The delay in communicating the order was explained by the correspondence, and the Society did not impeach its bona fides.
¶ 39–4105Holding
The Holding Order was not improperly used as a baseline, the prima facie findings were not perverse, the Petition was duly authorised, and the with-prejudice offer and the delay in communication did not warrant interference. The Court answered all six points against the Petitioner.
¶ 42, 34, 38, 41The Petition is dismissed without interference, and the Interim Application stands disposed of. The parties are to place the current factual position before the Arbitral Tribunal, which will assess the effect of subsequent events on the interim arrangement. There is no order as to costs, with liberty to seek costs before the Tribunal for this round. The Court declined to continue the interim directions of September 17, 2025.
¶ 43, 44, 45Original Court PDF
Deeplaxmi Co Operativew Housing Society LimitedvsHare Krishna Builders
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
