01Facts
The petitioner, a Senior Advocate and then Lok Sabha MP chairing the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development, appeared for power distribution companies in O.A. No. 122/2017 before the NGT.
The respondent no. 2, counsel for the applicant in that matter, objected to the appearance on conflict-of-interest grounds and filed Complaint No. 111/2018 before the Bar Council of Delhi.
¶ 3(ii)On 27.08.2018, the Economic Times reported the complaint and quoted the petitioner as calling the complainant a "crook".
¶ 3(iii)After a legal notice dated 31.08.2018 and a reply dated 07.09.2018, the Bar Council dismissed the complaint on 16.11.2018.
¶ 3(iv) · ¶ 3(v)The respondent no. 2 then filed Complaint Case No. 11/2019 under Sections 499/500 IPC. Cognizance was taken on 15.01.2019.
¶ 3(vi)On 02.02.2019 the complainant examined himself as the sole pre-summoning witness (CW-1) and declined to examine any other witness.
¶ 3(vi)On 20.04.2019 the ACMM summoned the petitioner under Section 500 IPC.
¶ 3(vii)The High Court issued notice and stayed the summoning order on 15.05.2019.
¶ 3(viii)The petitioner argued that Explanation 4 to Section 499 was unsatisfied, that the summoning order was mechanical and identical to that in Complaint Case No. 10/2019 (quashed in CRL.M.C. 2595/2019), and that the complainant had not appeared in proceedings.
¶ 4(a)–(c)The respondent had not appeared before the High Court on several listed dates.
¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the complainant, having examined only himself at the pre-summoning stage, prima facie established that the alleged imputation lowered his reputation "in the estimation of others" as required by Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC.
¶ 8 · ¶ 10 · ¶ 21ii.2. Whether a summoning order can rest on an online news report where neither the reporter, author, editor, nor any person associated with the publication was examined to prove that the words were uttered by the accused.
¶ 10 · ¶ 11 (operative portion, ¶20) · ¶ 21iii.3. Whether the summoning order and complaint should be quashed where a Coordinate Bench has quashed the summoning order in a connected complaint between the same parties, arising from the same controversy, on identical grounds.
¶ 9 · ¶ 12 · ¶ 15–1603Law Applied
Section 499 IPC (defamation) and Explanation 4, under which an imputation harms reputation only if, directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others, it lowers moral or intellectual character, caste/calling-related character, or credit, or causes belief in a loathsome or generally disgraceful state.
¶ 5Jeffrey J. Diermeier v. State of West Bengal, (2010) 6 SCC 243, which restates Explanation 4 and confirms that reputational harm must be shown through its effect on others' estimation.
¶ 6Jaideep Bose v. M/s Bid & Hammer Auctioneers Pvt. Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 3481, which holds that a summoning order is procedurally irregular where the complainant produces no witness to prima facie establish lowering of reputation in others' estimation.
¶ 7 & fn. 1Madanjit Kumar v. J.P. Singh & Ors., 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6853, which upheld dismissal of a complaint where no person to whom the imputation was published was examined.
¶ 7 & fn. 2 · ¶ 8The principle, from the Coordinate Bench judgment in CRL.M.C. 2595/2019 (2026:DHC:7169), that at the cognizance/summoning stage the basic ingredients of the offence must be prima facie disclosed, and that a newspaper report is, at best, hearsay or secondary evidence requiring proof through the reporter or editor, as articulated in R.P. Goenka (Allahabad HC).
¶ 10 · ¶ 11 (¶¶19–20)The inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to prevent abuse of process and secure the ends of justice.
¶ 1 · ¶ 11 (¶21)Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 190Section 200
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 499Section 500
04Reasoning
The complainant's claim of reputational harm rested solely on his own assertion. He named no reader of the report and examined no one other than himself at the pre-summoning stage. This failed the prima facie requirement of Explanation 4, which demands evidence of lowered estimation in others.
¶ 8 · ¶ 11 (¶18)Because the alleged statement came from an online report, the publication alone did not prove that the petitioner made the statement. No reporter, author, or editor was examined. The respondent had instead impleaded the news portal's editor/owner as an accused, leaving no independent material linking the petitioner to the words.
¶ 11 (¶20)The petitioner had specifically denied giving the interview and had written to the publication seeking a clarification.
¶ 11 (¶20)The impugned order did not consider the context of the remarks or the Bar Council's dismissal of the underlying complaint.
¶ 16The respondent's counter-affidavit dated 03.09.2019 merely reiterated allegations of conflict and general reputational damage and did not address the absence of evidence of lowered reputation in others' estimation.
¶ 14Relying on CRL.M.C. 2595/2019, which involved the same parties, the same controversy, and identical grounds, the Court found the dicta "squarely" applicable.
¶ 12 · ¶ 15–16The respondent's repeated non-appearance was noted but was not the ground of decision.
¶ 1305Holding
The complainant had not prima facie established lowering of reputation in others' estimation under Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC.
¶ 8 · ¶ 21A summons founded on an unproved online report, without examination of the reporter or associated person, could not be sustained.
¶ 11 (¶20–21)Quashing was warranted given the identical Coordinate Bench decision. The petition was allowed. The summoning order dated 20.04.2019 in Complaint Case No. 11/2019 was set aside, and the complaint and all proceedings emanating from it were quashed.
¶ 12 · ¶ 15–18The petition and pending applications were disposed of, and a copy of the order was directed to be sent to the trial court for compliance.
¶ 19–20Original Court PDF
Pinaki MisravsState & Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
