Tripura High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceInsurance Law

Insurer Allegedly Withheld Road Accident Compensation for 9 Years by Claiming Payment Was Made to the Wrong Forum; Tripura HC Imposes Costs

The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.v.Smt. Rina Debbarma and Ors.

Insurer Allegedly Withheld Road Accident Compensation for 9 Years by Claiming Payment Was Made to the Wrong Forum; Tripura HC Imposes Costs. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Smt. Rina Debbarma and Ors.. Tripura High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a deposit of the enhanced-award balance made with the Registrar General of the High Court, instead of before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal as directed, constitutes satisfaction of the decretal debt.

The court held

The deposit made with the Registrar General of the High Court did not satisfy the decretal debt, since the 2016 order required deposit before the Tribunal, and the petitioner had not proved the deposit.

It also directed

The Tribunal's direction for realisation of the balance with interest through the District Collector therefore stands.

The Tribunal's order dated 10.8.2026 was upheld, and the revision was dismissed. The petitioner's conduct was found not bona fide and costs of ₹10,000 were imposed, payable to the respondents within four weeks. All pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.

01Facts

The respondents, dependants of Falguna Debbarma who died in a motor accident, filed TS (MAC) No. 01 of 2012 before the MAC Tribunal No. 4, West Tripura, against the petitioner insurer and the vehicle owner (TR-01-N-1794).

¶ 2

The Tribunal awarded ₹26,05,240 with interest at 7% p.a.

¶ 2–3

The petitioner appealed (MAC (Appeal) No. 38 of 2014), depositing ₹25,000 and, under an order of the High Court, ₹34,61,610.

¶ 4

On 21.9.2016, the High Court enhanced the compensation to ₹28,72,670 with 9% interest from 2.1.2012, and directed the insurer to deposit the difference "within a period of 2 (two months) in the Tribunal".

¶ 5

The petitioner allegedly deposited ₹4,48,577 by cheque dated 9.2.2018 with the Registrar General of the High Court, and filed no proof of that deposit.

¶ 7

The respondents filed Civil Misc. No. 33 of 2017 before the Tribunal for recovery of ₹4,98,194 with 9% interest.

¶ 8

The petitioner resisted execution on the ground that the amount was deposited in the High Court.

¶ 9–10

On 25.5.2026 the petitioner sought certified copies of office notes dated 17.9.2018 and 19.9.2018, which the Registry declined to provide on 15.6.2026 as "office notes".

¶ 11

On 10.8.2026, the Tribunal held that no material showed satisfaction of the award and directed notice to the District Collector for realisation of the balance with interest.

¶ 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether a deposit of the enhanced-award balance made with the Registrar General of the High Court, instead of before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal as directed, constitutes satisfaction of the decretal debt.

¶ 6, 16–17

ii.2. Whether the Tribunal correctly refused to treat the award as satisfied and rightly ordered recovery through the District Collector, given the petitioner's unproven claim of deposit.

¶ 12, 14–15

iii.3. Whether the petitioner's conduct warrants costs in the revision.

¶ 19–21

03Law Applied

The Court relied on the specific operative direction in its own order dated 21.9.2016 that the enhanced balance be deposited "in the Tribunal".

¶ 5–6

A deposit made in the wrong forum is treated as not amounting to "full satisfaction" of the decretal debt.

¶ 16

A party asserting payment or deposit must prove it, and the petitioner filed no proof of the 2018 deposit.

¶ 7, 17

The claim was adjudicated under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, though no specific provision governing recovery through the Collector is identified.

¶ 2

Conduct which is not bona fide and is aimed at harassing the decree-holder may attract costs.

¶ 20–21

04Reasoning

The petitioner, a public sector insurer with a legal department and panel counsel, had a clear direction to deposit the balance before the Tribunal and offered no explanation for depositing elsewhere.

¶ 16

Because the High Court's own order fixed the forum, the deposit with the Registrar General could not discharge the decree.

¶ 16

The petitioner filed no proof of the 2018 deposit in the High Court, and the Registry declined copies of the office notes it relied on.

¶ 7, 11, 17

Given its assets, the petitioner could have satisfied the award years earlier or sought refund of the alleged deposit through proper channels.

¶ 18

The petitioner's stand was found unreasonable and not bona fide, and its purpose was to deprive the respondents of the amount for about nine years.

¶ 19–20

The Tribunal's refusal to accept the unproven plea of satisfaction and its direction for recovery through the Collector were consistent with these findings.

¶ 12, 15

05Holding

The deposit made with the Registrar General of the High Court did not satisfy the decretal debt, since the 2016 order required deposit before the Tribunal, and the petitioner had not proved the deposit.

¶ 15–17

The Tribunal's direction for realisation of the balance with interest through the District Collector therefore stands.

¶ 12, 21

The Tribunal's order dated 10.8.2026 was upheld, and the revision was dismissed. The petitioner's conduct was found not bona fide and costs of ₹10,000 were imposed, payable to the respondents within four weeks. All pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.

¶ 20–21
Tripura High Court

Original Court PDF

The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.vsSmt. Rina Debbarma and Ors.

Tripura High Court · November 21, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment