01Facts
On 24 September 2016, the claimant, then 17 years old, was riding a motorcycle with his cousin from Meerut (U.P.) to Burari (Delhi) when an Indica car, HR-05F-7171 (the "offending vehicle"), struck them near Baleni, Baghpat (U.P.).
¶ 4The claimant suffered an above-elbow amputation of the right arm and 85% permanent disability of the right upper limb.
¶ 5, 28The insurer, National Insurance Co. Ltd., pleaded that the policy was procured by suppressing that the registered owner, Satish Gupta (driver-cum-owner), had sold the vehicle in 2005. Its evidence showed the policy ran from 26 December 2015 to 25 December 2016.
¶ 10The chain of sale was recorded in the driver-cum-owner's written statement: sale to Navneet Sharma (2005), then Upender Kumar (2006), then Shamim Ahmed (2010).
¶ 14The RTO record showed the vehicle completed 15 years on 1 September 2014, its RC was not renewed, and the registered owner was "Satish Gulati".
¶ 18, 21The driver-cum-owner had been served a notice under Order XII Rule 8 CPC to produce the permit, which was not produced.
¶ 24The Tribunal's award of 1 June 2024 granted ₹20,84,863 with 8% interest and recovery rights to the insurer against the driver-cum-owner.
¶ 2, 24On the claimant's review application under Section 114/151 CPC and Section 169(1) MV Act, the Tribunal's award of 16 December 2024 granted an additional ₹20,00,000 for the prosthetic limb.
¶ 2Both parties appealed: the claimant sought enhancement (MAC.APP. 399/2025), and the driver-cum-owner challenged recovery rights (MAC.APP. 210/2026).
¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the insurer, having pleaded fraud/non-disclosure of material facts and the absence of a valid RC, is entitled to recovery rights against the driver-cum-owner despite its statutory liability to satisfy the third-party award.
¶ 22–27ii.2. Whether the claimant is entitled to enhancement of compensation, specifically regarding (a) notional income based on minimum wages of a skilled worker, (b) multiplier, future prospects and functional disability, and (c) the cost of prosthetic limbs over his lifetime.
¶ 29–4203Law Applied
Section 149(2)(b) MV Act (renumbered Section 150(2)(b) after the 2019 amendment), under which a policy obtained by non-disclosure of material facts or false representation is void, and Section 149(4) (Section 150(4)), under which the insurer may recover sums it pays towards third-party liability from the insured person.
¶ 12, 23Section 41 MV Act and the principle that failure to renew registration does not automatically cancel it.
¶ 25 (Absence of valid RC)The uberrima fidei principle from Reliance Life Insurance v. Rekhaben Rathod, (2019) 6 SCC 175.
¶ 25(vii)The line of authority holding that third-party interests cannot be defeated by insurer defences, with recovery left to the insurer, as in G. Govindan v. New Assurance (1999) 3 SCC 754, National Insurance v. Swaran Singh, (2004) 3 SCC 297, Pankaj Aggarwal v. Tata AIG (2017 SCC OnLine Del 9865) and National Insurance v. Kamal Kishore (2019 SCC OnLine HP 932).
¶ 25Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343, on functional disability.
¶ 35Hitesh Nagjibhai Patel (2025 SCC OnLine SC 3446), Baby Sakshi Greola (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3692) and Vineet Singh v. Oriental Insurance (2026 SCC OnLine Del 2225) on minimum wages for minors.
¶ 33Mohd. Sabeer v. U.P. SRTC, (2023) 20 SCC 774, and Prahlad Sahai v. Haryana Roadways (2026 SCC OnLine SC 651) on prosthetic limb replacement cycles, cost and maintenance (₹3,00,000 per limb; ₹15,000 p.a. maintenance).
¶ 38–39Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 114Section 151
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 169Section 149Section 150Section 2Section 41
04Reasoning
The driver-cum-owner's own pleading admitted the 2005 transfer, yet he procured a policy in his name in 2015. This amounted to non-disclosure of material facts, since a prudent insurer would have been influenced by it.
¶ 26(ii)–(iii)The RC had also lapsed in 2014, so no fresh insurance could be obtained for the vehicle.
¶ 26(iv)The driver-cum-owner led no evidence to rebut these facts, and the permit was never produced despite a notice under Order XII Rule 8.
¶ 24, 26(v)The Court did not decide whether the policy was void ab initio or whether the insurer was exonerated, which it reserved as a separate question. It instead followed the precedents that let the insurer pay the third-party award and recover from the owner, and sustained the Tribunal's recovery order.
¶ 23, 27A 17-year-old is not a non-earning person, so the notional income was fixed at ₹11,622 per month (minimum wage of a skilled worker, Delhi, 2016).
¶ 33–34The Court applied 40% future prospects, a multiplier of 18 and 70% functional disability, given the prosthesis would partly mitigate the impairment. Loss of future earnings works out to ₹24,60,175.
¶ 34–35, 43 (item 8)For the prosthetic limb, the Court relied on the PW-2 testimony that a limb costs about ₹6,00,000 today, unrebutted on cross-examination.
¶ 31–32Applying Prahlad Sahai's five-year replacement cycle over a 70-year life expectancy, the Court assessed 11 limbs, with ten remaining after the first purchase.
¶ 40–41Deducting the ₹22,00,000 already awarded under the head of prosthetic/future medical treatment, the Court awarded ₹45,95,000 for the prosthetic limb.
¶ 41–4205Holding
The Court dismissed MAC.APP. 210/2026 and sustained the insurer's recovery rights against the driver-cum-owner, being the Tribunal's order that the insurer pay the third-party award and recover from him.
¶ 27In MAC.APP. 399/2025, the Court enhanced compensation by ₹22,60,175 with 8% interest from the date of filing.
¶ 43–44Of the enhanced amount, ₹2,00,000 is to be released to the claimant, with the balance held in FDRs of ₹25,000 each over successive periods.
¶ 45The insurer must deposit ₹45,95,000 for prosthetic limbs within six weeks in an interest-bearing FDR, with no interest for the period before the award. The insurer's recovery rights extend to the prosthetic amount.
¶ 46This amount is released only against a verified original invoice and proof of payment from a reputed vendor, and any unwithdrawn balance on the claimant's death is refundable to the insurer.
¶ 47–48The originally awarded sums are to be released as per the Tribunal's directions.
¶ 49Both appeals are disposed of accordingly.
¶ 50Original Court PDF
Shubham TyagivsSh. Satish Gupta And Another
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
