01Facts
On 25 September 2014 at about 2:15 a.m., Tarandeep Singh (deceased, aged about 22, who ran a snack shop) was driving an Accent car on Mall Road, Delhi, when it collided with the rear of a stationary JCB wheel loader (HR 74 2045) parked in the middle of the road
¶ 2, 18The JCB was allegedly parked without blinkers, parking indicators or reflectors at an unlit spot
¶ 3The deceased suffered grievous injuries, was treated at several hospitals, and died on 30 September 2014
¶ 3, 18FIR 425/2014 was registered
¶ 3There were no eyewitnesses. The mother of the deceased (PW1) deposed to the parking position, and her testimony was unrebutted because the driver and owner did not cross-examine her
¶ 20–21The driver, who was charge-sheeted, did not testify
¶ 21The Detailed Accident Report and site plan (PW2/2) placed the collision in the middle of the road, with blinkers "not on"
¶ 23–24The JCB was insured under a Contractors Plant & Machinery (CPM) policy (valid 05.10.2013 to 04.10.2014) that covered the equipment "at the location."
¶ 6, 25–26Exclusion clause (h) excluded loss or damage in transit and stated that public liability would not be payable while the equipment was on public roads
¶ 6, 25–26An endorsement, CPM-3, provided third-party liability capped at Rs 2,65,168 (10% of the sum insured of Rs 26,51,683)
¶ 7, 25The MACT awarded Rs 27,13,262 with 9% interest
¶ 1The insurer contended the JCB was not a motor vehicle under the MV Act and that its liability was contractual and capped
¶ 4–5, 902Issues
i.1. Whether the JCB wheel loader is a "motor vehicle" under Section 2(28) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
¶ 12, 28, 38ii.2. Whether contributory negligence can be attributed to the deceased
¶ 14–15, 32–33iii.3. Whether the CPM policy, including the CPM-3 third-party endorsement, covered third-party liability arising from the JCB's use on the public road, such that the insurer is liable to pay compensation
¶ 34, 39–45iv.4. Whether the compensation awarded by the MACT requires modification, specifically the rate of future prospects
¶ 17, 46–4703Law Applied
Rule 2(cab) of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 (CMV Rules) defines "construction equipment vehicle" to include a loader, treats it as a non-transport vehicle whose road driving is incidental and limited to 50 kmph, and excludes only purely off-highway machines not equipped to travel on public roads
¶ 28Rule 2(h) CMV Rules, as read in Italian-Thai Development, treats such vehicles as motor vehicles under Section 2(28) MV Act
¶ 36, 38Rule 109 CMV Rules requires parking lights to remain lit when such a vehicle is stationary on the road
¶ 31–32Under Yashwant Krishna Kumbar (SC, 2025), the burden of proving contributory negligence lies on the party alleging it, and absent cogent proof no such finding can stand
¶ 33Under Sections 146 and 147 MV Act, an owner must obtain statutory third-party cover for use on roads, and a contractual policy outside Section 147 does not discharge that obligation
¶ 40, 43, 45Contracts of insurance are construed strictly according to their terms, per Harchand Rai and Chandmull Jain
¶ 37Future prospects are fixed at 40% for a deceased in private employment, per National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi (Constitution Bench)
¶ 46The court also referred to Bose Abraham (SC) and several High Court decisions (Tara Chanda, Iffco Tokio, Ranganath C., Munilakshmma, Manjunatha, Jagat) as persuasive authority
¶ 35–36Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 2Section 146Section 147
04Reasoning
Applying Rule 2(cab) and Rule 2(h), the court held that the JCB is a construction equipment vehicle that is also a non-transport motor vehicle under Section 2(28), since it can move, has a chassis, is mechanically propelled and is adapted for road use
¶ 38On contributory negligence, the court drew an adverse inference against the driver, the only possible eyewitness, for not testifying. It found the JCB stationary in the middle of the road at night without parking lights, in breach of Rule 109, and held that the insurer had led no evidence of negligence by the deceased
¶ 32–33On coverage, the court found that the CPM policy was not issued under Section 147 and that the insured did not seek road-use cover. Exclusion clause (h) and the CPM-3 endorsement, read holistically, did not extend third-party liability to the vehicle's use on the public road
¶ 34, 40–42Because the owner did not obtain statutory cover under Section 146 and the accident occurred while the JCB was on the road, liability fell on the owner, and the insurer was exonerated
¶ 43, 45On quantum, the court reduced future prospects from 50% to 40%, reduced loss of consortium to Rs 40,000, and reduced loss of estate and funeral expenses to Rs 15,000 each, yielding Rs 25,52,787
¶ 46–4705Holding
The JCB is a motor vehicle under Section 2(28) MV Act, and no contributory negligence is attributable to the deceased
¶ 33, 38The CPM policy did not cover third-party liability for on-road use, so the insurer is exonerated and liability is borne by the owner and driver
¶ 42–45The compensation is revised to Rs 25,52,787, a reduction of Rs 1,60,475 from the MACT award, with 9% interest
¶ 47–48The appeal is allowed. The insurer may recover the Rs 7,00,000 already released to the claimant from the driver and owner, but not from the claimant
¶ 50The balance of the deposit, with accrued interest, is refunded to the insurer
¶ 51The owner must deposit the revised compensation with interest before the MACT within four weeks, for release to the claimant as a lump sum within two weeks thereafter
¶ 52–53Original Court PDF
Icici Lombard General Insurance Co.Ltd.vsSmt. Harjeet Kaur & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
