01Facts
Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd. (SRSL), a manufacturer of denatured ethanol anhydrous, received an export order for 3000 MT from M/s Kolmar Group, Switzerland.
¶ 18–19Under Rule 4 of the Karnataka Excise (Denatured Spirit) Rules, 1967, exports had to be routed through the Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Ltd. (KSBCL).
¶ 20KSBCL's Circular No. 135 dated 19.06.2007 made the manufacturer liable for compliance and taxes (cl. 6) and required it to indemnify KSBCL (cl. 16).
¶ 20–21SRSL furnished an indemnity bond dated 17.08.2013.
¶ 22SRSL invoiced KSBCL as consignee, and KSBCL invoiced the foreign buyer.
¶ 23The Deputy Commissioner (Audit) issued a notice under Section 9(2) of the CST Act, contending that the deemed export claim lacked Form "H" declarations.
¶ 24A reassessment order dated 21.10.2016 fixed KSBCL's liability at ₹1,86,92,460.
¶ 25KSBCL invoked the indemnity bond.
¶ 26The First Appellate Authority dismissed KSBCL's appeal on 31.03.2017.
¶ 27KSBCL filed STA No. 297/2017 before the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (KAT).
¶ 28SRSL filed W.P. No. 9571/2017 seeking refund of ₹56,07,738 recovered under the indemnity and release of ₹1,32,97,074.
¶ 7The learned Single Judge held the demand unsustainable because the goods were exported and directed KAT to decide STA No. 297/2017 in KSBCL's favour.
¶ 9The Revenue appealed (WA No. 1153/2025).
¶ 10KSBCL then filed W.P. No. 25944/2025 to enforce that order; it was allowed on 04.09.2025.
¶ 11KAT disposed of the appeal in KSBCL's favour on 12.09.2025, solely to comply with the directions and not on merits.
¶ 12–13The Revenue filed STRP No. 15/2026 under Section 65(1) of the KVAT Act. The Court held it was not time-barred.
¶ 502Issues
i.1. Whether the learned Single Judge was justified in entertaining KSBCL's tax liability, which was pending before KAT, and in directing KAT to decide STA No. 297/2017 in KSBCL's favour.
¶ 16, 34, 40ii.2. Whether a deemed export claim can be allowed without furnishing the Form "H" declarations required under the CST Act.
¶ 40–42iii.3. Whether the inter-se dispute between SRSL and KSBCL, arising from the indemnity, is maintainable under Article 226 of the Constitution.
¶ 45iv.4. Whether the orders dated 21.10.2024, 04.09.2025 and 12.09.2025 are sustainable.
¶ 15–16, 47–4803Law Applied
The CST Act, 1956, under which a sale is an export sale or a deemed export only on the basis of prescribed declarations, including Form "H" under Section 5(3).
¶ 37The CST Act, 1956, under which the assessing authority may reassess under Section 9(2).
¶ 24The KVAT Act, 2003, under which a second appeal lies to KAT under Section 63 and a revision lies under Section 65(1).
¶ 10, 28, 34, 49Rule 4 of the Denatured Spirit Rules and Circular No. 135, clauses 6, 15 and 16, which place compliance and tax liability on the manufacturer, provide for indemnity, and provide for arbitration of disputes.
¶ 20–21, 33The settled principle that a writ court should not decide questions pending before a statutory authority.
¶ 32–34The principle that the inter-se contractual dispute must be considered in light of the arbitration clause and the maintainability of writ jurisdiction under Article 226.
¶ 45The principle that consequential benefits obtained under a set-aside order must be reversed.
¶ 4604Reasoning
The learned Single Judge erred because the question of KSBCL's tax liability was the subject of pending KAT proceedings and was not apposite for the writ court.
¶ 34, 40The demand arose from statutory proceedings in which KSBCL had already availed remedies, so the inter-se contract dispute could not displace them.
¶ 32The learned Single Judge did not decide whether Form "H" was mandatory, which was the principal question before KAT.
¶ 39–40The finding that the goods were exported did not answer whether the deemed export benefit could be granted without the prescribed declarations.
¶ 41–42The Revenue's objection that the transaction was not revenue-neutral was never considered.
¶ 43Since the single judge's conclusion on tax liability was "ex-facie erroneous," the order could not stand.
¶ 44The KAT's order rested entirely on the single judge's directions and was therefore also unsustainable.
¶ 13, 48The Court left the inter-se dispute open, to be examined by the single judge, including whether it is fit for Article 226 proceedings.
¶ 45The Court restored STA No. 297/2017 to KAT for fresh decision, without regard to the set-aside orders.
¶ 4905Holding
The learned Single Judge's order of 21.10.2024 in W.P. No. 9571/2017 was unsustainable. It did not decide whether Form "H" was mandatory and it improperly determined KSBCL's tax liability pending before KAT.
¶ 40–44W.A. No. 1153/2025 is allowed. The order dated 21.10.2024 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the learned Single Judge. The inter-se contentions between SRSL and KSBCL are reserved, including whether they may be entertained under Article 226.
¶ 45W.A. No. 677/2026 is allowed. The order dated 04.09.2025 in W.P. No. 25944/2025 is set aside and the writ petition is disposed of.
¶ 47STRP No. 15/2026 is allowed. KAT's order dated 12.09.2025 in STA No. 297/2017 is set aside and the appeal is restored to KAT for a fresh decision, uninfluenced by this Court's orders. The Court expresses no opinion on whether Form "H" was mandatory or whether KSBCL is entitled to deemed export benefits.
¶ 48–49Any consequential benefit SRSL derived from the set-aside orders must be reversed.
¶ 46The delay in filing the appeals is condoned.
¶ 1Original Court PDF
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES (AUDIT) 4.3,vsKARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES CORPORATION LIMITED
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
