01Facts
The Revenue appealed under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against a common order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru, dated 05.08.2020 in IT(TP)A No. 52/Bang/2016 and IT(TP)A No. 97/Bang/2016, both relating to Assessment Year 2011-2012.
¶ 1The assessee, M/s. L.G. Soft India Pvt. Ltd., provides software development services to its Associate Enterprise (AE).
¶ 7The Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), by direction dated 16.10.2015, allowed the assessee's objections and directed the exclusion of ten companies from the list of comparables as not comparable to the assessee.
¶ 3The Revenue appealed to the Tribunal. The assessee also appealed, seeking exclusion of three further comparables, which the Tribunal rejected.
¶ 3The Tribunal heard both appeals together and passed a common order. It upheld the exclusion of the ten companies and, on the assessee's appeal, held that Persistent Systems and Solutions Ltd., Sasken Communication Technologies Ltd. and Persistent Systems Ltd. were not comparable.
¶ 6The Revenue contended that the authorities failed to properly appreciate the annual reports and website details of the companies.
¶ 5 · ¶ 8Both appeals were admitted on 12.12.2022 and 27.01.2022 on four substantial questions of law.
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was right in excluding M/s. Acropetal Technologies Ltd., Infosys, L&T Ltd., Tata Elxsi Ltd., E-Infochips Ltd., E-Zest Solutions Ltd., ICRA Techno Ltd., Persistent Systems & Solutions Ltd., Sasken Communication Technologies Ltd. and Persistent Systems Ltd. from the comparables list as functionally different, without appreciating that they satisfied the TPO's qualitative and quantitative filters and Rule 10B.
¶ 2, Q.1ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's exclusion of these companies is perverse, given that comparable selection depends on assessee-specific FAR analysis and the TPO's materials were ignored.
¶ 2, Q.2iii.3. Whether the Tribunal was right in excluding M/s. L&T Infotech Ltd. on the basis of onsite revenue exceeding 50% and related party transactions of 18.66%, when the TPO applied the RPT filter per OECD guidelines.
¶ 2, Q.3iv.4. Whether the Tribunal erred in not appreciating that relaxing or applying any filter alters the accept/reject matrix and produces an altogether new set of comparables.
¶ 2, Q.403Law Applied
The Court's jurisdiction under Section 260-A is confined to substantial questions of law, and it did not re-appreciate factual material.
¶ 8The transfer pricing framework under Rule 10B, which governs the application of comparability filters, was referenced in the framing of the questions.
¶ 2, Q.1The principle that selection of comparables is an assessee-specific, fact-based FAR (functions, assets, risks) analysis was invoked.
¶ 2, Q.2The OECD guidelines on related party transaction filters were cited in the questions.
¶ 2, Q.3The governing principle, applied by the Court, is that a finding of fact by the Tribunal or DRP based on the annual reports and other material is not interfered with unless it is perverse, based on irrelevant material, or omits relevant material.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8 · ¶ 9No specific precedent was cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 1
Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 260A
04Reasoning
The Court examined the DRP direction and the Tribunal order and found that both authorities compared each company's annual report with the assessee's functionality and recorded a finding of fact that the comparables had functions that could not be compared with the assessee's software development services.
¶ 7Because both authorities expressly recorded that their findings were based on the annual reports and other details, the Court held that it could not re-appreciate those findings in a Section 260-A appeal.
¶ 8The Revenue did not establish that the Tribunal relied on irrelevant material or ignored relevant material, nor did it point to any perversity.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8The Revenue's central contention, that the annual reports and website details were not properly appreciated, was therefore a challenge to factual appreciation and not a substantial question of law.
¶ 8The Court did not separately discuss Questions 3 and 4, but its reasoning on the absence of perversity and the bar on re-appreciation applies to the entire set of questions.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8 · ¶ 905Holding
The Court answered all substantial questions of law in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue, holding that the Tribunal's exclusion of the disputed comparables was a finding of fact that was not perverse and could not be re-appreciated under Section 260-A.
¶ 9Both appeals, ITA No. 241/2021 and ITA No. 242/2021, were dismissed, and the Tribunal's common order dated 05.08.2020 stands affirmed. No further directions or relief were granted.
¶ 9Original Court PDF
PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAXvsM/S. L.G. SOFT INDIA PVT. LTD.,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
