01Facts
On 03.01.2020, a motorcycle (KA-03/JK-2128) ridden by the deceased, B. Umesh, with a pillion rider, was struck by a Tata Ace vehicle (KA-07/B-0959) that came from the opposite side.
¶ 3–4The deceased died after being taken to Government Hospital, Malur.
¶ 3–4His wife, three children, and parents filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (MVC No. 354/2020).
¶ 3–4The Tribunal awarded ₹66,61,751.
¶ 6The Tribunal's computation used a monthly income of ₹46,376 less professional tax of ₹200, a 30% future prospects addition, income tax deduction, a one-fourth personal expense deduction, and a multiplier of 13, yielding ₹64,71,751 as loss of dependency.
¶ 6The Tribunal added ₹40,000 (consortium), ₹15,000 (estate), ₹15,000 (funeral), and ₹1,20,000 (parental consortium to claimants 2–4).
¶ 6The income basis was Ex.P.20, an income certificate covering April 2019 to January 2020; December 2019 income was adopted.
¶ 14The deceased's age was taken as 48.
¶ 14The claimant father died during pendency of the claim and was not awarded consortium.
¶ 10, 15The accident occurred on 03.01.2020 and the award was passed on 31.01.2022.
¶ 18The claimants appealed under Section 173(1) of the MV Act seeking enhancement.
¶ 1, 702Issues
i.1. Whether the claimants are entitled to enhancement of compensation.
¶ 12ii.2. Whether the Tribunal correctly computed loss of dependency, including the income assessment, future prospects, and deductions.
¶ 9, 14iii.3. Whether the father of the deceased, who died during pendency of the claim, is entitled to loss of consortium.
¶ 15–17iv.4. Whether escalation charges are payable on conventional heads when the award was passed about two years after the accident.
¶ 10, 1803Law Applied
The Court applied Section 166 and Section 173(1) of the MV Act as the statutory basis for compensation and appellate review.
¶ 1, 3National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 is relied upon for the principle that future prospects of 30% are added to income where the deceased was a permanent employee.
¶ 14National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 is relied upon for the principle that conventional heads carry 10% escalation for every three years after the date of accident.
¶ 18The cause of action arises on the date of death, and loss of consortium is personal to the individual claimant and does not pass to the family as a unit.
¶ 17Enhanced compensation carries interest at 6% per annum, subject to the Court's discretion on delay.
¶ 19(iii)No authority is cited for the consortium proposition.
¶ 17Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166
04Reasoning
The Court accepted the Tribunal's income assessment, holding that the Ex.P.20 income certificate, the December 2019 income, the 30% future prospects addition for a permanent BESCOM employee, the deduction of professional and income tax per the applicable slab, and the one-fourth personal expense deduction were correct.
¶ 14Although the appellants argued that Form 16 was not considered, the Court did not separately address the argument and found no basis for interference with the dependency calculation.
¶ 9, 14On consortium, the Court reasoned that the claim is personal to each claimant. Because the father died before adjudication, he was not alive to receive it, so no award could be made to him.
¶ 17On escalation, the Court found that the Tribunal omitted the Pranay Sethi escalation on conventional heads. Since the accident preceded the award by about two years, it applied 10% escalation on each conventional head, bringing the total to ₹67,01,651.
¶ 18The Court further denied interest on the enhanced amount for a 226-day delay period.
¶ 19(iii)05Holding
The claimants are partly entitled to enhancement. The Tribunal's loss of dependency calculation was affirmed, but the conventional heads were enhanced by 10% + 10% escalation, bringing the award to ₹67,01,651 instead of ₹66,61,751.
¶ 18–19(ii)The father's loss of consortium was rejected.
¶ 17The enhanced compensation carries 6% interest, except for the 226-day delay period.
¶ 19(iii)The insurer (R2) must deposit the amount with accrued interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving the certified copy. Apportionment and disbursement follow the Tribunal's order, the modified award is to be drawn accordingly, and no costs are awarded.
¶ 19(iv)–(vii)The appeal is allowed in part.
¶ 19(i)Original Court PDF
SMT V AMBUJAvsSMT NAGAMMA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
