01Facts
On 20.12.2020, the deceased, T.K. Krishnappa, was riding a motorcycle at Tharahunase–Yelahanka Road when a tipper lorry (offending vehicle) struck it from behind. He died on the spot
¶ 3The deceased was 59 years old, and his legal heirs are his wife (Claimant No. 1), two unmarried daughters (Claimants 2 and 3), and a major son (Claimant 4)
¶ 4 · ¶ 13The Tribunal fixed his monthly income at ₹50,000, applied a 1/4th deduction for personal expenses, a multiplier of 9, and 10% future prospects, and awarded a total of ₹46,64,000
¶ 6The insurer (Respondent No. 1) appealed (MFA 4630/2023) contending that the income was unsupported, while the claimants appealed (MFA 4778/2023) seeking income of ₹10,00,000 per annum
¶ 9–10The evidence showed that the deceased held land measuring 3 acres 25 guntas 1.5 cents per RTCs (Ex. P-8)
¶ 16Other exhibits included a horticulture assistance certificate (Ex. P-9), a capsicum cultivation certificate (Ex. P-10), a water right certificate (Ex. P-11), and a milk society supply certificate showing ₹72,953.13 supplied over eight months (Ex. P-14)
¶ 16Education loan certificates for Claimants 2 and 3 were also produced (Ex. P-16 to P-28)
¶ 16PW-1 (Claimant 1) deposed that the deceased earned ₹10,00,000 per annum from agriculture
¶ 17PW-2 and PW-3's testimony on income was hearsay
¶ 1902Issues
i.1. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires modification?
¶ 11–12ii.2. Whether the income of the deceased adopted by the Tribunal (₹50,000 p.m.) is based on the available evidence?
¶ 14iii.3. Whether the loss of the deceased's supervisory capacity over agricultural land is compensable, and how it is quantified?
¶ 20–2103Law Applied
The appeals were brought under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
¶ 1 · Order (a)–(b)The Court accepted the Tribunal's use of a multiplier of 9, a 1/4th deduction for personal expenses (three dependents), and 10% future prospects as correct
¶ 13On the income question, the Court relied on the Division Bench decision in B. Parimala v. Riyaz Ahmed, ILR 2001 Kar 1443, which holds that where land is cultivated under supervision, the loss to dependants is not the land's gross yield but the value of the deceased's supervision and personal effort, or the cost of a manager if one is engaged
¶ 21The Court held that RTCs prevail over inconsistent revenue certificates
¶ 16Income derived from milk vending must be assessed net of cattle-feeding and milking costs
¶ 22Non-payment of income tax is relevant to proof of income
¶ 23Educational loans taken by minor children are not evidence of the deceased's financial capacity, since repayment is the children's responsibility after majority
¶ 24Conventional heads are awarded per National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680
¶ 25Hearsay evidence cannot be relied upon
¶ 19Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The Court examined RTCs and found the landholding to be 3 acres 25 guntas 1.5 cents, preferring them over the inconsistent revenue certificate. PW-1's testimony of ₹10,00,000 annual income was rejected as unsupported, and PW-2 and PW-3's hearsay evidence was excluded
¶ 16–17 · ¶ 19The Court held that the family continued to cultivate the land after the death, so the loss lay in the deceased's supervisory role, not in the land's full yield
¶ 20Applying Parimala, the Court treated the deceased's supervision and personal effort as the measure of loss
¶ 21For milk vending, Ex. P-14 showed approximately ₹9,000 per month gross; the Court took 50% as net income (₹4,500). No document established the profit from capsicum cultivation
¶ 22The deceased's non-assessment to income tax weakened the claim of substantial income
¶ 23The Tribunal had not examined the loan documents properly, and the loans did not prove financial capacity. The Court therefore found ₹50,000 p.m. exorbitant and fixed income at ₹25,000 p.m.
¶ 24–25Because the award was otherwise correctly computed, the Court interfered only with the dependency figure and left the conventional heads undisturbed
¶ 2505Holding
The Court held that the quantum of compensation requires modification
¶ 12The deceased's income is fixed at ₹25,000 per month, with 10% future prospects, a 1/4th deduction, and multiplier 9, giving loss of dependency of ₹22,27,500. Total compensation is ₹24,36,500 (loss of dependency ₹22,27,500; loss of estate ₹16,500; funeral expenses ₹16,500; spousal consortium ₹44,000; parental consortium ₹1,32,000)
¶ 25 · ¶ 26–27The Court ordered: (a) MFA 4778/2023 dismissed; (b) MFA 4630/2023 allowed in part; (c) award modified to ₹24,36,500 with interest at 6% p.a. from the date of petition until realisation; (d) the insurer to deposit the amount within six weeks of receipt of the certified copy; (e)–(f) transmission and apportionment as per the Tribunal's order; (g) no order as to costs; (h)–(i) modified award to be drawn and the TCR returned to the Tribunal
¶ 28(a)–(i)Original Court PDF
SMT ANANDAMMAvsM/S ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
