01Facts
The appellant, Omega SA, a Swiss watchmaker, filed Application No. 5932/CHE/2013 on 18.12.2013 for a patent titled "Decorative piece produced by setting on Amorphous Metal," containing about 30 claims.
¶ 2The First Examination Report of 20.06.2019 found the invention non-patentable for lack of inventive step. The appellant responded on 18.03.2020, and a hearing notice issued on 13.01.2023 citing prior art documents D1 to D4.
¶ 2By order dated 12.06.2023, the Controller rejected the application, holding that Claims 1 to 30 lacked inventive step and were obvious to a person skilled in the art (PSITA) in view of D1 to D4.
¶ 2The appellant states that corresponding applications were granted in the USA and Europe, and that D1, D3 and D4 were considered in the European proceedings.
¶ 4Claim 1 concerns setting an aesthetic element (e.g., a gemstone) on a support lacking plastic deformation, with an at least partially amorphous alloy introduced between them, held by a catching means.
¶ 4, 16The appellant contended that D1 is a fully amorphous alloy jewellery article, D2 is a mechanical retaining device, D3 involves hot-forming inlay, and D4 is a precious-metal amorphous jewellery.
¶ 5The respondent contended that D1 teaches gemstones cast in amorphous alloy with the same technical effect, and that D2 to D4 supply the retaining structure, so the claims are obvious.
¶ 10The respondent also argued that the claims fall within ss. 3(d), 3(e) and 3(f) of the Patents Act, 1970.
¶ 9, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether Claims 1 to 30 of Application No. 5932/CHE/2013 lack inventive step under s. 2(1)(ja) of the Patents Act, 1970, in view of D1 to D4, such that the Controller's rejection is sustainable.
¶ 13, 15 to 21ii.2. Whether the Controller's obviousness finding is supported by reasons and free from perversity, including whether D2 and D3 were properly considered and whether the combined reading of D1 to D4 was adequately explained.
¶ 5, 18 to 21iii.3. Whether the foreign grants of the corresponding patents, and the difference between Indian and foreign patent law, justified the refusal.
¶ 8 to 9, 2103Law Applied
The court's reasoning rests principally on s. 2(1)(ja) of the Patents Act, 1970, which defines inventive step.
¶ 6, 21A quasi-judicial refusal must be supported by reasons that identify how the cited prior art teaches the claimed invention.
¶ 21The court did not expressly restate a test for inventive step. Counsel relied on Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam v. Hindustan Metal Industries and F. Hoffmann-La Roche v. Cipla (five-point obviousness test), AB Initio Technology LLC v. Controller of Patents (2025), Rhodia Operations v. Assistant Controller (2024), Microsoft Technology Licensing v. Assistant Controller (2024), Lava International v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (2024, on hindsight), and Avery Dennison v. Controller of Patents (Delhi HC), but the judgment does not apply these authorities by name.
¶ 6 to 8Foreign grants are not binding, but an authority departing from them must articulate the Indian statutory distinction relied upon.
¶ 21The respondent's invocation of ss. 3(d), 3(e) and 3(f) of the Patents Act, 1970 was not adjudicated.
¶ 9, 11Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Patents Act, 1970 Section 2Section 3Section 10
04Reasoning
The court compared each cited document against claim 1 as construed from its features. It accepted that D1 teaches jewellery with a gemstone cast in amorphous alloy, but held that the claimed invention places a gemstone on a partially amorphous alloy within a hollow, which D1 does not disclose.
¶ 16 to 17D2 was held to disclose a pyramid-trapezoid crown and conical pavilion with a three-claw retainer, which is not the claimed amorphous-alloy hollow arrangement.
¶ 18D3, which teaches hot-forming inlay, was held irrelevant because no such process is claimed.
¶ 19D4 was held to concern precious-metal amorphous jewellery, whereas the claim does not require precious metals.
¶ 20Since none of D1 to D4 teaches a partially amorphous alloy, the court held the Controller's combined-teaching finding unsupported by reasoning explaining how a PSITA would arrive at the claim, and therefore perverse.
¶ 21The court observed that the claim was granted in the USA and Europe, and that the Controller did not identify any rigour in Indian law that would justify a different result.
¶ 21The court did not examine the s. 3 or s. 10 objections, and its reasoning rests on the inventive-step and reasons analysis.
05Holding
The court held that the cited prior art D1 to D4 does not disclose the partially amorphous alloy feature of the claimed invention, and that the obviousness finding was unreasoned and perverse.
¶ 17, 21The appeal under s. 117A is allowed, the order dated 12.06.2023 is set aside, and the Controller is directed to grant the patent for the claimed invention, with no order as to costs.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
Omega SAvsController of Patents and Designs
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
