01Facts
The appellant, M/s. N.C. Arya Snuff & Cigar Co. ("the plaintiff firm"), was a family partnership in the snuff and cigar business. Its original partners were S. Chandrasekaran and S. Thara.
Their daughter-in-law/daughter, Anuradha (D-4), was inducted as a partner in 1995 and 1998 with a 25% profit share.
¶ 6.2, 19The respondent, M/s. Nico Quality Products ("the defendant firm"), is owned by K.C. Vijay, with Z. Gnanakanabady (Anuradha's husband) as an earlier partner.
¶ 7.1, 7.2Anuradha was found to have been in charge of the firm's affairs, and the business declined under her management. The plaintiff alleged that she retired on 30.06.2012 (retirement deed Ex.D7).
¶ 6.3, 6.4, 20, 21An authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 (Ex.P2) empowered Anuradha to assign the marks.
¶ 6.6, 7.4, 35An assignment deed dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) transferred ten Class 34 trade marks to the defendant firm for the "exclusive use and all benefits" of the marks in manufacturing and marketing Class 34 goods in India and abroad.
¶ 6.6, 7.4, 35The deed recited a cash consideration of Rs.75 lakhs. The two original partners acknowledged receipt of this sum by letter dated 20.12.2011 (Ex.P4).
¶ 7.5, 24Chandrasekaran's letter of 21.06.2012 (Ex.P20) confirmed the assignment, promised to hand over original certificates, and sought a further Rs.20 lakhs, with a blank cheque as security.
¶ 25Bank correspondence and receipts (Exs.P23–P25) showed that Vijay dealt with the firm's bank dues and paid Rs.16 lakhs.
¶ 27–30Registrations of the firm lapsed (Exs.P26, P27).
¶ 31The assignment was presented for registration only on 19.08.2013, about 18 months after execution (Ex.P5).
¶ 37The plaintiff filed C.S. (Comm. Div.) No. 882 of 2013 to declare the assignment null and void, and C.S. No. 587 of 2015 for passing off. The defendant firm filed C.S. No. 605 of 2013 for infringement and passing off.
¶ 3, 4, 8The learned Single Judge dismissed the plaintiff's suits (Nos. 882/2013 and 587/2015) and decreed the defendant's suit (No. 605/2013) by judgment dated 24.01.2025. The plaintiff appealed.
¶ 13, 1402Issues
i.1. Whether the authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 (Ex.P2) and the assignment deed dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) are the product of forgery or fabrication?
¶ 17(i), 34ii.2. Whether the deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 is valid in law, including in light of the six-month registration requirement under Section 42 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
¶ 17(ii), 37, 50iii.3. Whether the defendant's use of the marks amounts to infringement?
¶ 17(iii), 51iv.4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a permanent injunction against passing off?
¶ 17(iv), 51v.5. What other reliefs are the parties entitled to?
¶ 17(v), 5203Law Applied
Section 19 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 gives a partner in charge of the firm's business implied authority to bind the firm in acts done in the ordinary course.
¶ 20Forgery and fabrication are mutually inconsistent pleas, and the party alleging forgery bears the burden of proving it.
¶ 23–24Unchallenged documents are taken as proved.
¶ 26Section 42 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 provides that an assignment made otherwise than with the goodwill of the business does not take effect unless advertised within six months, so that an assignment with goodwill falls outside that requirement.
¶ 38–39, 50On goodwill, the court relied on the House of Lords in IRC v. Muller & Co.'s Margarine Ltd. (1901 AC 217).
¶ 41The court relied on S.C. Cambatta & Co. (P) Ltd. v. CEPT (1961) 41 ITR 500 and CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981) 2 SCC 460.
¶ 43K.A. Subramaniam v. CED (AIR 1962 Mad 315) and CIT v. Chunilal Prabhudas & Co. (AIR 1971 Cal 70) hold that goodwill cannot exist apart from the business and that a presumption of transfer of goodwill arises on transfer of the business.
¶ 44–45The joint-intention rule for interpreting commercial contracts applies, as laid down in Great Eastern Shipping Co. v. State of Karnataka (2020) 3 SCC 354 and BESCOM v. ES Solar Power Pvt. Ltd. (2021) 6 SCC 718.
¶ 46–47An assignor who has assigned the marks cannot infringe them, and the assignee may obtain injunctive relief.
¶ 52Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96
Trade Marks Act, 1999 Section 42Section 45
Indian Partnership Act, 1932 Section 19Section 21
04Reasoning
Thara admitted her signature on Ex.P2, and the plaintiff's contention that Chandrasekaran's signature was misused was not proved.
¶ 24Ex.P4, the letter from both original partners, contains no gap between signatures and contents and admits both the assignment and receipt of Rs.75 lakhs.
¶ 24Ex.P20, which was never disputed or challenged in cross-examination, confirms the assignment and records the promise to surrender the certificates.
¶ 25–26The bank letters and receipts (Exs.P23–P25) establish Vijay's role and payments.
¶ 27–30The firm's registration lapses and the non-opposition to Vijay's later registrations (Exs.P18, P19, P31) further showed that the plaintiff had withdrawn from the business.
¶ 31–32, 36The court concluded that the "forgery" plea was inconsistent with the plaintiff's own reliance on the "fabrication" plea, and that it was an afterthought.
¶ 23, 33–34The court read the recitals of Ex.P3 as conveying the "exclusive use and all benefits" of the marks, which it treated as transferring goodwill.
¶ 35, 40Goodwill has no independent existence apart from the business it attaches to, so the transfer of these benefits and the marks implied goodwill.
¶ 40–45Because the assignment was with goodwill, Section 42's six-month advertisement requirement did not apply, and the non-registration argument failed.
¶ 50The court drew the inference that the assignment was intended to transfer the entire business, as the debt-laden firm had ceased trading, its registrations had lapsed, and it had not opposed later registrations in the same class.
¶ 49The deed was held unconditional, supported by consideration, and relating to specific marks, and so it was valid.
¶ 50Because the marks and business had been validly assigned, the plaintiff could not claim infringement or passing off against the assignee.
¶ 51Having assigned the marks, the plaintiff could not use or infringe them, so the defendant was entitled to a permanent injunction against infringement and passing off.
¶ 5205Holding
Point (i) is answered against the plaintiff: Ex.P2 and Ex.P3 were not shown to be forged or fabricated.
¶ 34Point (ii) is answered against the plaintiff: the assignment deed was made with goodwill, so Section 42 did not apply, and it is valid in law.
¶ 50Points (iii) and (iv) are answered against the plaintiff: it is not entitled to an injunction against infringement or passing off.
¶ 51On Point (v), the defendant firm is entitled to a permanent injunction against infringement and passing off of the assigned marks.
¶ 52The three OSA appeals (Nos. 84, 90 and 96 of 2025) are dismissed, the common judgment and decree of the Single Judge dated 24.01.2025 are affirmed, and no costs are awarded. Connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
¶ 53–54Original Court PDF
N.C. ARYA SNUFF AND CIGAR CO.vsNICO QUALITY PRODUCTS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
