01Facts
The plaintiff sought a declaration of absolute ownership of 42 cents of nanjai/alanchai land in Survey No. 371/8 (Patta No. 352, Thiruppakottai Village), with a permanent injunction against interference.
pp. 6-7He claimed the land came to his share through an oral partition in 1970 and a family partition dated 03.11.1970.
p. 7 · ¶ 7He also pleaded a usufructuary mortgage of 25.03.1927 (Ex. A2) in favour of the defendant's grandfather, redeemed on 20.08.1955, and continuous possession and kist payment thereafter.
pp. 7-8 · ¶ 2(ii)The defendant admitted the 1970 partition but denied the allotment, claiming title under the Samasthanam/Adheenam and a settlement patta (No. 1199).
pp. 8-9 · ¶ 2(iii)The trial court decreed the suit, and the first appellate court dismissed the defendant's appeal.
p. 9 · ¶ 2(v)Before the trial court, the plaintiff relied on Exs. A1–A13 and five witnesses; the defendant relied on Exs. B1–B8 and four witnesses.
p. 9 · ¶ 2(iv)Ex. A1 is an unregistered notebook partition list dated 03.11.1970 that includes Survey No. 371/8, 0.42 acres.
¶ 10-11Exs. B6–B8 are patta, adangal and kist records for Fasli 1343, 1348 and 1356 in the name of the defendant's grandfather.
¶ 14The Court admitted the second appeal on two substantial questions of law.
pp. 9-10 · ¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below are sustainable when Ex. A1 (an unregistered partition list) was held not to be acted upon and inadmissible as evidence of title.
p. 10 · ¶ 4(a) · ¶ 10-13ii.2. Whether the concurrent findings are sustainable in view of Exs. B6–B8, which allegedly show the defendant's long possession of the suit property.
p. 10 · ¶ 4(b) · ¶ 14-1603Law Applied
The Court applied Section 100 CPC, under which a second appeal lies only on substantial questions of law and concurrent findings of fact are not disturbed absent perversity or material illegality in appreciation of evidence.
¶ 17A document like Ex. A1, even if it cannot create or declare rights in immovable property for want of registration, may be looked into for a collateral purpose, subject to the requirements of law.
¶ 13, 15No specific statutory provision (e.g., Registration Act, s. 17/49) is cited in the judgment.
The Court applied the maxim nemo dat quod non habet, holding that a mortgagee's successors cannot acquire superior title merely from revenue entries.
¶ 15The Court applied the principle possessio sequitur titulum, holding that revenue records are at best evidentiary of possession and not instruments of title.
¶ 16No judicial precedents are cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The courts below did not rely solely on Ex. A1. It was read alongside Ex. A2 (mortgage and redemption endorsement), the oral evidence of PW2, PW3 and PW5 (Village Assistant), and kist receipts Exs. A3–A10, all of which corroborated the plaintiff's allotment and possession.
¶ 12-13Since Ex. A1 was used only for a collateral purpose, the objection on registration did not vitiate the findings.
¶ 13Exs. B6–B8 related to Fasli years within the subsistence of the 1927 mortgage. The mortgagee's possession was referable to the mortgage transaction and conferred no independent title.
¶ 14-15The documents did not establish possession after redemption on 20.08.1955, whereas the plaintiff proved post-redemption possession through kist receipts and PW5's testimony.
¶ 15The revenue entries could not displace the plaintiff's title and subsequent possession.
¶ 16The Court found no perversity or illegality in the concurrent appreciation of evidence.
¶ 1705Holding
Both substantial questions of law were answered against the appellants.
¶ 17The Court held that Ex. A1 could be considered for a collateral purpose alongside other evidence, and that Exs. B6–B8 did not establish title or post-redemption possession in the defendant.
¶ 13, 16The Second Appeal is dismissed, and the judgments and decrees of the trial court (O.S. No. 188/1987) and first appellate court (A.S. No. 4/1990) are confirmed, with no order as to costs.
¶ 18Original Court PDF
JEBAMALAI(DIED)vsSEMBAIAH UDAIYAR,(DIED)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
