01Facts
The suit properties were purchased by Maruthanna Gounder, who died intestate and was succeeded by his only son, Subbanna Gounder.
p. 9The plaintiff, Subbanna Gounder’s daughter, sought partition, alleging that he died intestate and claiming a share alongside his other children.
pp. 2–3, 9The defendants relied on a registered Will dated 16 May 1986, said to have been executed by Subbanna Gounder in favour of his three sons.
pp. 3, 9–10The trial court granted the plaintiff 9/40 share; the first appellate court modified the decree, awarded her 1/8 share, and upheld the Will only to the extent of Subbanna Gounder’s supposed 1/8 share.
pp. 2, 5–6The defendants appealed to the High Court.
p. 602Issues
i.1. Whether property inherited by Subbanna Gounder from his father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act was his absolute property or coparcenary property.
pp. 6, 12–13ii.2. Whether Subbanna Gounder’s children acquired a birthright in the property, limiting his testamentary power to a 1/8 share.
pp. 6, 13–14iii.3. Whether the Will dated 16 May 1986 was proved and could govern succession to the suit properties.
pp. 9–10, 13–1403Law Applied
The Court applied Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, holding that property inherited by a Hindu from his father as a Class I heir devolves upon him as his separate property and does not become coparcenary property in the hands of his children.
pp. 12–13The Court relied on Govindan v. Revathi, 2019 SCC OnLine Mad 39757; Arunagiri v. Ayyar Muthuraja, 2014 (1) CTC 73; S. Dakshina v. Chinnaponnu, (2012) 7 MLJ 414; and M. Premkumar v. P. Murugan, A.S. (MD) No. 177 of 2018, for that proposition.
pp. 12–13It also held that a Will may be proved through the evidence of an attesting witness and that excluding female heirs, by itself, is not a suspicious circumstance invalidating the Will.
p. 10Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 8
04Reasoning
Maruthanna Gounder had purchased the properties separately, and Subbanna Gounder succeeded to them as his Class I heir.
p. 9The Court therefore treated the properties as Subbanna Gounder’s separate property, not as ancestral coparcenary property in which his children acquired rights by birth.
pp. 12–13The attesting witness’s evidence established execution and attestation of the Will, while the plaintiff had not raised any specific surrounding suspicious circumstances; the exclusion of daughters alone did not justify disbelieving it.
p. 10Accordingly, the first appellate court erred in restricting the Will to a 1/8 share and awarding the plaintiff a share on a coparcenary basis.
pp. 11–1405Holding
The High Court answered the substantial questions of law in favour of the appellants, holding that the suit properties were Subbanna Gounder’s separate property and that the plaintiff was not entitled to a share in them in light of the proved Will.
pp. 13–14It allowed the second appeal, set aside both lower courts’ decrees, dismissed the partition suit, made no order as to costs, and closed the connected miscellaneous petition.
p. 14Original Court PDF
S. MARUTHAKUTTI(Died)vsA. JEEVARATHINAM
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
