01Facts
The petitioner, a Companies Act company executing marine electrical EPC projects, won a tender by the respondent, NLC India Ltd., for a 15 MW (AC) solar plant at Ettankulam, Tamil Nadu.
¶ 2The letter of award issued on 28.02.2017 and the contract was executed on 08.06.2017.
¶ 3The petitioner alleged grid connectivity on 04.03.2019 and commissioning on 28.04.2021, sought permission for the PG test on 16.06.2021, obtained consent on 30.06.2021, and conducted the test from 01.07.2021.
¶ 4The respondent issued a final acceptance certificate on 19.07.2025.
¶ 4Under Clauses 6.7.4, 6.9.3 and 6.10.3, 5% retention money became payable on these events.
¶ 5On 04.11.2025 the respondent stated that release of retention money was "in process."
¶ 5On 11.11.2025 the respondent passed the impugned order proposing liquidated damages under Clause 10.22.2.8, reserving a right of set-off against the retention money, and threatening to invoke the performance bank guarantee.
¶ 5The respondent opposed the petition, contending that the communication was merely clarificatory, that there were delays and shortfalls, and that disputes must go to arbitration.
¶ 6–7, 9The petitioner's senior counsel argued that the action was arbitrary and sought interference under Article 226.
¶ 8The Court asked whether the parties would invoke arbitration or attempt amicable resolution.
¶ 10Counsel sought time to negotiate, and the matter was reserved.
¶ 11A joint memo followed.
¶ 12–1302Issues
i.1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable against the impugned order, given the contractual arbitration clause (Clause 10.44.2) and the factual disputes regarding delay, shortfall and liquidated damages.
¶ 6, 7, 9ii.2. Whether the dispute over retention money, liquidated damages and the performance bank guarantee can be resolved by consensual appointment of a sole arbitrator, subject to refund of the retention amount and continued subsistence of the bank guarantees.
¶ 10–1403Law Applied
The contractual arbitration mechanism under Clause 10.44.2, invoked by the respondent.
¶ 7, 9The joint memo, under which the parties consented to appointing Hon'ble Mr. Justice E. Padmanabhan (Retd.) as sole arbitrator, subject to refund of retention money.
¶ 13Arbitrator fees to follow Schedule IV of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, borne equally.
¶ 15(ii)The Court's power to dispose of the writ petition derives from its Article 226 jurisdiction.
¶ 1The petitioner's authorities (Mohinder Singh Gill, Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi, ABL International, Unitech Ltd., Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour) were cited for the limits of contractual disputes in writ jurisdiction; the Court did not discuss or apply them.
¶ 8The parties' undertaking that bank guarantees remain alive pending arbitration.
¶ 1404Reasoning
The Court did not decide the merits of the liquidated damages, set-off or retention claims. Faced with the respondent's arbitration objection and the factual disputes on delay and shortfall, it sought the parties' willingness to arbitrate or settle.
¶ 6, 9, 10The parties could not settle fully but agreed on a sole arbitrator, conditional on refund of the retention amount. The Court therefore gave effect to the consensual arbitration route rather than adjudicating whether the writ was maintainable. The refund condition addressed the petitioner's core grievance regarding withheld retention money, and keeping the bank guarantees alive protected the respondent's security pending arbitration.
¶ 5, 11–1405Holding
The Court did not decide maintainability or the merits. It recorded the joint memo as part of its order and disposed of the writ petition by consent.
¶ 13, 15Hon'ble Mr. Justice E. Padmanabhan (Retd.) is appointed sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes; the arbitrator shall enter reference and decide disputes, with fees per Schedule IV of the 1996 Act, borne equally; the entire retention amount is to be refunded to the petitioner within four weeks of receipt of the uploaded copy of the order; the petitioner shall keep the bank guarantees alive until disposal of arbitration; and connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
¶ 15(i)–(v)Original Court PDF
Marine Electricals (India) LimitedvsNLC INDIA LIMITED (NLCIL)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
