Madras High CourtArbitration and MediationBanking and Finance Law

Madras HC Upholds Rs 7.52 Crore Arbitral Award Against Kumbakonam Traders, Rejects Contempt Plea Over Bank's Shop Possession

SRI KALEESWARI STORESv.EQUITAS SMALL FINANCE BANK LTD

Madras HC Upholds Rs 7.52 Crore Arbitral Award Against Kumbakonam Traders, Rejects Contempt Plea Over Bank's Shop Possession. SRI KALEESWARI STORES vs EQUITAS SMALL FINANCE BANK LTD. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the arbitral proceedings are barred by the doctrine of election because the bank simultaneously invoked SARFAESI remedies

The court held

The Court held that the doctrine of election does not bar arbitral proceedings where SARFAESI remedies are simultaneously invoked

It also directed

It held that the award is not vitiated by perversity or Wednesbury unreasonableness and that no ground under Section 34 was made out

It held that no contempt was committed, as the interim order of 14.05.2026 restrained only the enforcement of the award and not SARFAESI possession

The Arbitration O.P. and the Contempt Petition were dismissed, and connected applications were closed, with no order as to costs

The interim protection was extended for two months, during which the respondent is directed not to proceed to sale of the repossessed assets

01Facts

The first petitioner, a partnership firm, obtained credit facilities of ₹10 crores from the respondent bank, sanctioned on 28.11.2017, comprising a cash credit and two term loans.

The firm hypothecated its stock, and the second and third petitioners executed guarantees. The second petitioner also created an equitable mortgage

¶ 8

The petitioners attributed their default to a business downturn aggravated by COVID-19

¶ 8

The bank invoked the arbitration clause and obtained an Advocate Commissioner's inventory order under Section 9 (20.09.2024).

Thereafter, by order dated 16.04.2025, Hon'ble Mr. Justice K. Kannan (Retd.) was appointed sole arbitrator

¶ 9

In parallel, the bank issued a Section 13(2) demand notice and a Section 13(4) possession notice under the SARFAESI Act. A Section 14 application was allowed by the CJM, Thanjavur, on 22.04.2025, and the petitioners' writ challenge was dismissed on 25.08.2025 with liberty to pursue alternative remedies

¶ 10–11

The Section 17 application before the DRT was dismissed on 04.10.2025, and an interim injunction obtained from the High Court against physical possession was conditional on a ₹25 lakh deposit, paid on 13.10.2025

¶ 12

The arbitral award dated 16.02.2026 held the petitioners jointly and severally liable for ₹7,52,32,079 with interest, plus ₹10 lakh costs

¶ 13

The Section 33 application seeking arithmetical correction was dismissed on 08.03.2026

¶ 14

The petitioners also state that a further ₹1.30 crore was paid after the award and a partial mortgage release was effected

¶ 18

By order dated 14.05.2026, this Court stayed the award subject to deposit of ₹1 crore within eight weeks

¶ 19, 22

Despite this, the bank executed a possession notice on 10.06.2026 through the Advocate Commissioner and took physical possession of the premises on 20.06.2026, after which the petitioners filed contempt proceedings.

¶ 20–22

The petitioners tendered a ₹50 lakh demand draft on 20.06.2026 and sought extension for the balance

¶ 20–22

The Court did not separately adjudicate the petitioners' challenges to Clause 7.1(a) (computation), Clause 7.1(d) (SARFAESI protection as extra-jurisdictional under Section 34(2)(a)(iv)), or the ₹10 lakh costs under Clause 7.1(b)

¶ 16–18, 26

02Issues

i.1. Whether the arbitral proceedings are barred by the doctrine of election because the bank simultaneously invoked SARFAESI remedies

¶ 30

ii.2. Whether the award suffers from perversity or Wednesbury unreasonableness, including on the COVID-19 force majeure/moratorium plea

¶ 31

iii.3. Whether the bank's taking of possession on 20.06.2026 violated the interim order dated 14.05.2026, such that contempt is made out

¶ 32–33

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Sections 34 and 33 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, read with the Wednesbury standard of unreasonableness for review of awards

¶ 31

It applied the SARFAESI Act, 2002, particularly Sections 13 and 14

¶ 10–11

On the doctrine of election, it relied on M.D. Frozen Foods Exports Pvt. Ltd. v. Hero Fincorp Ltd., (2017) 16 SCC 741, which holds that SARFAESI enforcement and arbitral proceedings may proceed simultaneously; SARFAESI is an enforcement mechanism, whereas arbitration is adjudicatory, and SARFAESI measures protect the value of the secured asset against the debt

¶ 30, 32

On the nature of possession, it relied on Transcore v. Union of India, (2008) 1 SCC 125, which treats a secured creditor's possession under SARFAESI as akin to a receiver's appointment to protect assets

¶ 32

Consequently, the Court held that an interim stay of an award restrains enforcement of the award amount only, not the creditor's possession of secured assets

¶ 33

Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9Section 11Section 33Section 34

Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 Section 13Section 14Section 17

04Reasoning

On the doctrine of election, the Court followed M.D. Frozen Foods and rejected the petitioners' contention that the bank's SARFAESI invocation extinguished its arbitral remedy

¶ 30

On the merits, the Court found no perversity or Wednesbury unreasonableness in the award. It held that the liability had been crystallised through adjudication and that the COVID-19 moratorium/restructuring plea could not assist the petitioners because the pandemic had subsided by 2022, while the SARFAESI proceedings were initiated in August 2024 after the accounts became NPA

¶ 31

On contempt, the Court reasoned that the award, once determined, limits SARFAESI enforcement to the award amount, and that the 14.05.2026 stay operates only against enforcing the award, not against the bank's possession under an independent statutory process

¶ 32–33

Since possession under the CJM's Section 14 warrant predated and was distinct from the stay, the Court found no wilful disobedience

¶ 33

The Court thus treated the statutory possession and the arbitral recovery as distinct tracks, reconciled through the limitation that any sale of repossessed assets must be confined to the award amount

¶ 32

05Holding

The Court held that the doctrine of election does not bar arbitral proceedings where SARFAESI remedies are simultaneously invoked

¶ 30

It held that the award is not vitiated by perversity or Wednesbury unreasonableness and that no ground under Section 34 was made out

¶ 31

It held that no contempt was committed, as the interim order of 14.05.2026 restrained only the enforcement of the award and not SARFAESI possession

¶ 32–33

The Arbitration O.P. and the Contempt Petition were dismissed, and connected applications were closed, with no order as to costs

¶ 34

The interim protection was extended for two months, during which the respondent is directed not to proceed to sale of the repossessed assets

¶ 34
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI KALEESWARI STORESvsEQUITAS SMALL FINANCE BANK LTD

Madras High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment