01Facts
The petitioner, a Government of India enterprise (State Trading Corporation), floated an e-tender on 08.09.2017 for lifting its urad dhal stock.
¶ 2 · p. 2The respondent bid Rs. 9,13,46,600 and, with the petitioner's acceptance, adjusted Rs. 46,00,000 from an earlier transaction as earnest money deposit (EMD) of Rs. 45,67,330 (5%).
¶ 2 · p. 2The respondent was awarded 696 MT on 22.09.2017, with payment due by 29.09.2017.
¶ 3 · p. 3The respondent paid Rs. 3 crore and sought an extension for the balance, which was granted subject to additional EMD and a further payment of Rs. 4 lakh. It did not pay the balance by the final extended date of 20.11.2017 but lifted the stock.
¶ 3 · p. 3A risk sale notice dated 21.11.2017 followed, and a risk sale tender for 1,176 MT was floated on 06.12.2017.
¶ 4-5 · pp. 3-4The respondent paid the balance, including carrying costs of Rs. 20,68,603, on 14.12.2017 and lifted the entire stock on 24.01.2018.
¶ 4-5 · pp. 3-4The petitioner refunded an excess of Rs. 11,70,439 but, by letter dated 09.05.2018, confirmed forfeiture of the EMD.
¶ 5 · p. 4The Sole Arbitrator (Arb. Case No. 04 of 2025, O.P. No. 81 of 2021) on 30.01.2026 held that time was of the essence but was extended by conduct; that forfeiture was not warranted or proportionate; and that the EMD be refunded with 12% interest from the date of the award.
¶ 8-9 · pp. 5-602Issues
i.1. Whether the arbitral award directing refund of the forfeited EMD of Rs. 45,67,330 is liable to be set aside under Section 34 as perverse, patently illegal, or beyond the arbitrator's jurisdiction, given the petitioner's contractual right of forfeiture.
¶ 10-14 · pp. 6-8ii.2. Whether the arbitrator, in holding forfeiture unreasonable and disproportionate, impermissibly decided the dispute on reasonableness or equity rather than on contractual interpretation.
¶ 12 · p. 7 · ¶ 16-20 · pp. 9-11iii.3. Whether the award of 12% post-award interest is justified and sustainable.
¶ 22 · pp. 11-1203Law Applied
The limited scope of interference under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as reflected in Associate Builders, Ssangyong Engineering, and related authorities cited by the petitioner, under which an award is interfered with only if perverse or patently illegal, and the court is not a first appellate court.
¶ 13-14, 18 · pp. 7-9, 10Sections 55 and 63 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, as invoked by the petitioner.
¶ 11 · pp. 6-7Section 74 of the Contract Act governs forfeiture of a deposit: where forfeiture is penal, the sum forfeited is the outer limit, and only reasonable compensation may be allowed, per Fateh Chand, Maula Bux, Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA (2015) 4 SCC 136, and Shanmugavelu as collated in the court's own decision in P.S.T. Engineering v. HSCC (India) Ltd. (2025:MHC:981).
¶ 16, 19-20 · pp. 9-11National Highways Authority of India v. Ganga Enterprises (2003) 7 SCC 410, which concerns earnest money as part of the sale price on non-performance, was held inapplicable.
¶ 19 · p. 10Post-award interest is governed by Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd. (2025) 7 SCC 1, under which the court may modify interest where the facts so require.
¶ 22 · pp. 11-12Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 34
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 55Section 63Section 74
04Reasoning
The forfeited sum was retained as security, not as earnest money forming part of the sale price, so the case was not one of non-performance under Ganga Enterprises.
¶ 19 · p. 10The petitioner's invocation of the forfeiture clause as a penalty, while extending deadlines and accepting belated performance with additional carrying costs, brought the forfeiture within Section 74.
¶ 20 · p. 11Once the forfeiture was penal, the arbitrator was required to determine what was reasonable compensation within the statutory outer limit. Having considered the additional sums paid and the petitioner's acceptance of performance, the arbitrator's conclusion that nothing further was payable was a contractual construction and appreciation of evidence, not an exercise of equity or a decision outside jurisdiction.
¶ 16-17, 20 · pp. 9-11The award was therefore not perverse, patently illegal, or contrary to fundamental legal policy under Section 34.
¶ 21 · p. 11The award ordered 12% interest without discussing the rate or circumstances. The court also noted the respondent's delay, although the petitioner had allowed lifting of stock on the understanding that the deposit could be forfeited. The rate was therefore reduced to 9%.
¶ 22 · pp. 11-1205Holding
The refund of Rs. 45,67,330 directed by the arbitrator cannot be disturbed under Section 34, as the award is neither perverse nor patently illegal and applies Section 74 of the Contract Act to the contract terms and record.
¶ 21, 23(i) · pp. 11-12Post-award interest at 12% was not justified in the circumstances and is modified to 9% per annum from the date of the award until realisation.
¶ 22, 23(ii) · p. 12The petition is partly allowed in these terms, with no order as to costs, and the connected application is closed.
¶ 23(iii) · p. 12Original Court PDF
The State Trading Corporation of India LimitedvsRajni Exports and Imports,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
