01Facts
On 19.08.2024, the mother of a minor girl (the victim) complained that her daughter, then a minor, had gone missing from home on the night of 17.08.2024. FIR No. 237/2024 (Lingasugur PS) was registered under s.137(2) BNS against unknown persons.
¶ 6–7, 17The victim was later traced with petitioner No.1 (accused No.1). Petitioner No.1 was arrested and remanded to judicial custody on 29.08.2024.
¶ 20After investigation, a charge sheet was filed against petitioner No.1 and respondents No.4–8 under ss.137(2), 54, 64 BNS, ss.4, 6, 17 POCSO Act, and ss.9, 10, 11 Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006 (PCMA).
¶ 8, 18The case is Special Case No. 5394/2024 before the III Addl. Sessions Judge, Sindhanur. Petitioner No.1 filed Crl.P. 201545/2025 under s.528 BNSS to quash it.
¶ 8The victim's statement under s.183 BNSS alleged a consensual relationship and voluntary travel with petitioner No.1.
¶ 10, 22The court noted that the victim's date of birth (17.02.2008) was undisputed, making her a child on the date of the 2024 incident.
¶ 24, 35On 05.01.2026, the victim's aunt (respondent No.2) alleged that petitioners No.1 and 2 abducted the victim, then in her custody, from a farm field.
¶ 4–5FIR No. 3/2026 (Mudgal PS) was registered on 06.01.2026 under ss.329(3), 137(2) r/w 3(5) BNS.
¶ 12Petitioners No.1 and 2 sought quashing of this FIR under s.528 BNSS (Crl.P. 200566/2026). They relied on a marriage between petitioner No.1 and the victim on 20.02.2026, registered on 27.02.2026. A joint memo was filed for quashing.
¶ 13–14, 31–32, 3402Issues
i.1. Whether the alleged eight-month delay in lodging the complaint warrants quashing of Special Case No. 5394/2024.
¶ 19–26ii.2. Whether the victim's consent, her subsequent majority, the marriage with petitioner No.1, and the alleged settlement warrant quashing of the POCSO/BNS proceedings against petitioner No.1 and respondents No.4–8.
¶ 27, 36–38, 46–60iii.3. Whether the subsequent FIR No. 3/2026 amounts to double jeopardy and is liable to be quashed on the basis of the marriage/compromise.
¶ 29–3403Law Applied
The court applied s.528 BNSS (inherent power to quash).
¶ 1–2The court relied on ss.137(2), 54, 64 BNS, ss.4, 6, 17 POCSO Act, and ss.9–11 PCMA, under which the victim's consent is immaterial where she is a child.
¶ 27The court applied the principle from State of A.P. v. M. Madhusudhan Rao (2008) 15 SCC 582 that delay in lodging an FIR must be satisfactorily explained, but that such explanation is a matter for trial.
¶ 28The court relied on Prithivirajan v. State (2025 SCC OnLine SC 696) and Kunal Chatterjee v. State of W.B. (SLP, 29.07.2025) on consent in promise-to-marry cases.
¶ 27On compromise, the court applied the Coordinate Bench orders in Crl.P. 6214/2022, 4658/2024, 13469/2023 and 28856/2024, and Sri Munendra v. State of Karnataka (Crl.P. 16959/2025, 19.02.2026), which quashed POCSO proceedings after marriage, but only where the settlement was shown to involve the parents and elders and the factual matrix differed.
¶ 37–47The court applied Ashish v. State of Rajasthan (SLP (Crl.) 19215/2025, 12.02.2026), which holds that Art. 142 quashing on settlement of heinous offences is to be exercised sparingly.
¶ 51–53The court applied the principles that offences committed during pendency of prior proceedings weigh heavily against leniency, and that non-compoundable heinous offences against society cannot be closed by private settlement.
¶ 57, 59Provisions in the judgment · 23 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 183Section 528
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 3Section 54Section 64Section 126Section 137Section 329Section 351Section 352
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 3Section 4Section 6Section 8Section 12Section 17
Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006 Section 9Section 10Section 11
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 343Section 363Section 366Section 376
04Reasoning
On delay, the court found that the complaint dated 19.08.2024 concerned a kidnapping on 17.08.2024, not the 12.01.2024 incident alleged by petitioner No.1. The complaint was lodged within two days, and petitioner No.1 was arrested within ten days. The delay argument therefore failed on the facts.
¶ 20, 25Even if delay existed, its explanation is a trial question, not a ground for quashing.
¶ 26, 28On consent and marriage, the court held that the victim's consent is legally immaterial because she was a child under POCSO on the date of the alleged offence, which was undisputed.
¶ 27, 35The later marriage and majority did not extinguish the offences.
¶ 36The compromise decisions were distinguished. Those cases involved parental consent, elders' intervention, child births, and factual settings absent here. No such material existed here.
¶ 38–50The court noted that the victim's aunt had complained of a fresh kidnapping on 05.01.2026, when the victim was still a child, and that the marriage followed 46 days later.
¶ 34, 49, 55–56On double jeopardy, the court held that the 2026 FIR concerns a distinct act (kidnapping on 05.01.2026) from the 2024 offences (kidnapping and sexual assault). The Art. 20(2) plea therefore failed.
¶ 33The 2026 kidnapping occurred while the earlier case was pending, which the court treated as aggravating conduct.
¶ 54, 57Respondents No.4–8 had not settled and had not sought quashing. The offences are heinous and non-compoundable, and a settlement cannot legitimize them.
¶ 21, 54, 58–5905Holding
The court answered all issues in the negative. The petitioners failed to show grounds for quashing.
¶ 60The Crl.P. No. 201545/2025 is dismissed. The proceedings in Special Case No. 5394/2024 (III Addl. Sessions Judge, Sindhanur) will continue against petitioner No.1 and respondents No.4–8.
¶ 61(i)The Crl.P. No. 200566/2026 is also dismissed as to FIR No. 3/2026 (Mudgal PS). The court granted petitioners liberty to challenge the final report if aggrieved.
¶ 61(ii)Original Court PDF
SHIVAGYANAPPAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
