01Facts
On 29.03.2021, the claimant, a loadman travelling in Bolero van TN-48-AP-2633 owned by the first respondent, was injured when the van lost control and capsized. His right femur was seriously damaged, and he could not continue his employment.
¶ 2.1He filed M.C.O.P. No. 5 of 2022 claiming Rs. 10,00,000.
¶ 2.1The insurer denied the manner of the accident, alleged a delay in lodging the FIR, and contended that the claim was excessive.
¶ 2.2The claimant examined himself and one other witness; Exs. P1–P9 and X1–X3 were marked, and the Medical Board disability certificate was marked as Ex. C1. The respondents led no evidence.
¶ 2.3The Tribunal, by award dated 14.12.2023, fixed negligence on the driver and awarded Rs. 8,97,760, including Rs. 7,25,760 for loss of earning capacity based on 18% disability.
¶ 3.1The insurer did not challenge negligence but challenged quantum.
¶ 3.202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in adopting the multiplier method to compute loss of earning capacity based solely on 18% permanent physical disability, absent evidence of functional disability.
¶ 7.1–7.3ii.2. Whether the remaining heads of compensation (loss of income, amenities, attendant charges, pain and suffering, and future medical expenses) were adequately quantified.
¶ 7.5–7.603Law Applied
The Court relied on Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343, for the principle that permanent physical disability and functional disability affecting earning capacity are distinct, and that the multiplier method cannot be applied mechanically on the percentage of physical disability without evidence of functional disability.
¶ 7.1–7.2For permanent disability not justifying a multiplier computation, the Court applied the per-percentage rate in force on the date of accident, Rs. 10,000 per percentage point.
¶ 7.4For the remaining heads, the Court applied the general standard of assessing compensation in light of the nature of injuries, the treatment undergone, the duration of incapacity, and the need for future treatment.
¶ 7.5–7.6No specific statutory provision or other precedent is cited for these heads.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The Court held that the Tribunal erred in applying the multiplier to the 18% disability rating, since the record contained no evidence of functional disability affecting the claimant's earning capacity.
¶ 7.1–7.3The Court set aside the Rs. 7,25,760 award and substituted Rs. 1,80,000 as a notional permanent-disability award at Rs. 10,000 per percentage point.
¶ 7.3–7.4The Court enhanced loss of income from Rs. 45,000 (three months, as assessed by the Tribunal) to Rs. 1,25,000 on the basis that the claimant was unable to work for about ten months.
¶ 7.5Loss of amenities was enhanced to Rs. 50,000, attendant charges to Rs. 25,000, and pain and suffering to Rs. 1,00,000, each by reference to the nature of the injuries and treatment.
¶ 7.5Future medical expenses of Rs. 30,000 were awarded because the claimant had undergone surgeries and would need further treatment, though the Tribunal had made no such award.
¶ 7.6Transportation, extra nourishment, and damage to clothing were confirmed.
¶ 8.105Holding
The multiplier-based award for loss of earning capacity was unsustainable in the absence of functional disability evidence, and that head was reduced to a per-percentage award of Rs. 1,80,000.
¶ 7.1–7.4The loss of income, amenities, attendant charges, and pain and suffering heads were enhanced, and Rs. 30,000 was awarded for future medical expenses.
¶ 7.5–7.6The appeal was partly allowed. The total award was modified from Rs. 8,97,760 to Rs. 5,82,000, with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition.
¶ 8.1, 9.2The insurer was directed to deposit the modified amount with applicable interest within eight weeks, with any excess deposit refundable to it. No costs were awarded.
¶ 9.3–9.4Original Court PDF
Reliance General Insurance Company Limited,vskarthi
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
