Madras High CourtAdministrative and Public LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Objections already finally rejected in earlier writ proceedings cannot be reraised against the same candidate in a fresh petition.

K.B. Surryav.THE SECRETARY

Objections already finally rejected in earlier writ proceedings cannot be reraised against the same candidate in a fresh petition.. K.B. Surrya vs THE SECRETARY. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether R5's experience as an "Assistant Engineer" fails to satisfy the workshop experience requirement under Para 6(B) of the Notification.

The court held

R5's experience as an Assistant Engineer does not disqualify him under Para 6(B), because the requirement is workshop experience, and most of his experience was as a Mechanic.

It also directed

The objection to R6 is barred by the earlier final order in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021, and the fraud allegation is rejected because the attendance register is genuine.

The challenge to R7 is premature, since he has neither been selected nor appointed. If he falls within the zone of consideration, TNPSC must strictly apply the age terms of the 14.02.2018 notification, regardless of the later enhancement to 60 years.

The writ petition is dismissed with no costs.

01Facts

TNPSC issued Notification No. 03/2018 dated 14.02.2018 for direct recruitment to 113 (later revised to 110) posts of Motor Vehicle Inspector, Grade-II, in the Tamil Nadu Transport Subordinate Service.

p. 2

The petitioner cleared the written examination, and a selection list of 32 candidates was published.

p. 2

The process was then subject to prolonged litigation. The Supreme Court, by order dated 15.06.2026, confirmed the Division Bench decision in W.A. No. 590 of 2023 (dated 22.12.2023), clarifying paras 83 and 88(f), and directed TNPSC to conclude the process within 12 weeks.

pp. 2–3

TNPSC published a list of candidates satisfying the workshop experience condition under Para 6(B) on 17.08.2026, and a list of candidates in the zone of consideration for the oral test on 18.08.2026.

p. 3

The petitioner challenged the inclusion of Respondents 5, 6 and 7 in these lists.

p. 3

R5: His experience was as "Assistant Engineer," not "Mechanic," as Para 6(B) requires.

¶ 5

R6: The attendance register differed from the one filed for workshop approval, and his favourable order dated 10.02.2023 in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021 was obtained by fraud.

¶ 6

R7: He had crossed 58 years before the oral test was called, contrary to the explanation to Para 6(A).

¶ 7

The respondents relied on the MVMD report and the Inspecting Officer's remarks, which recorded that R5 worked as Assistant Mechanic (Jan–Apr 2014), Mechanic (May–Sep 2014), and Mechanic/Assistant Engineer (Oct–Dec 2014).

¶ 8

The respondents also relied on para 49 of the 10.02.2023 order in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021, which had rejected the attendance-register objection against R6.

¶ 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether R5's experience as an "Assistant Engineer" fails to satisfy the workshop experience requirement under Para 6(B) of the Notification.

¶ 5, 8, 10–11

ii.2. Whether the objection to R6's candidature on the ground of an improper attendance register, and the allegation that the earlier order was obtained by fraud, can be re-agitated in view of the earlier final determination.

¶ 6, 9, 12–15

iii.3. Whether R7, who had crossed 58 years of age, is ineligible for inclusion in the zone of consideration under Para 6(A).

¶ 7, 16

03Law Applied

The Court construed Para 6(B) of the Notification dated 14.02.2018, which requires at least one year of full-time experience on petrol and diesel vehicles in an automobile workshop undertaking repairs of light motor vehicles, heavy goods vehicles and heavy passenger motor vehicles, and held that the paragraph prescribes no specific designation.

¶ 10

The Court relied on the finality of its earlier adjudication in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021 (order dated 10.02.2023), which had rejected the attendance-register objection against R6 and was not disturbed on appeal, and applied the principle that a party cannot re-agitate the same objection once it has been decided. No authority for this principle is cited.

¶ 9, 13, 15

The Court applied the Supreme Court's order dated 15.06.2026 and the Division Bench judgment in W.A. No. 590 of 2023, which fixed the 12-week timeline.

pp. 2–3

Under Para 6(A) and its explanation, the age limit is governed by the notification's terms, and the later enhancement of the superannuation age to 60 years is irrelevant to eligibility under it.

¶ 16

Article 226 of the Constitution provides the writ jurisdiction invoked.

p. 1

04Reasoning

On R5, the Court held that Para 6(B) requires workshop experience, not a particular designation, so the "Assistant Engineer" objection fails.

¶ 10

Independently, the Inspecting Officer's record showed that R5 worked as a Mechanic for most of his workshop experience and as an Assistant Engineer only towards its end.

¶ 11

On R6, the Court examined the attendance register and found no irregularity, noting that the Government Automobile Workshop, Trichy had verified it on 28.08.2020.

¶ 12

Because the same objection had already been rejected in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021 and the respondents were directed to consider R6's candidature, the petitioner could not raise it again.

¶ 13

The fraud allegation failed because the Court was "fully convinced" of the register's genuineness.

¶ 14

The Court also rejected the claim that the earlier order had been remanded, since the appellate court did not interfere with its findings.

¶ 15

On R7, the Court held that he had not been selected or appointed and had not yet been shown to fall within the zone of consideration, so the challenge was premature. If he later falls within the zone, TNPSC must apply the notification's terms strictly, and the later enhancement of the superannuation age is irrelevant.

¶ 16

05Holding

R5's experience as an Assistant Engineer does not disqualify him under Para 6(B), because the requirement is workshop experience, and most of his experience was as a Mechanic.

¶ 10–11

The objection to R6 is barred by the earlier final order in W.P. No. 15330 of 2021, and the fraud allegation is rejected because the attendance register is genuine.

¶ 12–14

The challenge to R7 is premature, since he has neither been selected nor appointed. If he falls within the zone of consideration, TNPSC must strictly apply the age terms of the 14.02.2018 notification, regardless of the later enhancement to 60 years.

¶ 16

The writ petition is dismissed with no costs.

¶ 17
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

K.B. SurryavsTHE SECRETARY

Madras High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment