Punjab and Haryana High CourtTransport, Maritime, and Aviation LawInsurance Law

P&H HC Grants Sisters Consortium For Brother's Death, Though Not Financially Dependent On Him

Reliance General Insurance Co Ltdv.Supinder Kaur & Ors

P&H HC Grants Sisters Consortium For Brother's Death, Though Not Financially Dependent On Him. Reliance General Insurance Co Ltd vs Supinder Kaur & Ors. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the 298-day delay in filing the cross-objections should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.

The court held

The insurer's appeal seeking reduction of compensation is dismissed. The cross-objections are partly allowed and the compensation is enhanced from ₹6,58,000 to ₹10,97,200, an enhancement of ₹4,39,200

It also directed

The monthly income of ₹6,000 is affirmed, with 40% future prospects, a 50% deduction and a multiplier of 18, giving loss of dependency of ₹9,07,200

The delay of 298 days is condoned, with no interest for that period

The enhanced amount, payable to the mother, carries interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition, excluding the 298 days

The insurer must deposit the enhanced amount with accrued interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy of the judgment. The Tribunal is to disburse it without ordering recovery of sums already paid under the award

01Facts

On 19.06.2013, Luvpreet Singh (aged about 19) was pillion-riding on a scooter when a container truck driven by respondent Ayub Khan struck it, causing fatal injuries. An FIR was registered under Sections 279, 334 and 304-A IPC

¶ 2

The parents and two sisters filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, pleading that the deceased earned ₹15,000 per month from a utensils shop and was pursuing a Diploma in Civil Engineering, with a prospective income of ₹30,000 per month

¶ 3

The Tribunal held the accident was caused by the truck driver's rash and negligent driving, found the shop income unproved, and assessed notional income at ₹6,000 per month. After a 50% deduction and a multiplier of 18, it awarded ₹6,48,000 for loss of dependency plus ₹10,000 for transport and last rites, totalling ₹6,58,000 with 9% interest. It divided the amount equally between the parents and declined the sisters' claim

¶ 4

The insurer contended that admission to the diploma course was secured only on 06.06.2013, 13 days before the accident, so no reliable future earnings were shown

¶ 5

The claimants filed cross-objections seeking enhancement, accompanied by an application for condonation of 298 days' delay

¶ 1, 6, 8, 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether the 298-day delay in filing the cross-objections should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.

¶ 8–12

ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's notional monthly income of ₹6,000 for the deceased, a diploma student, was correct and whether it should be enhanced.

¶ 14–19

iii.3. Whether future prospects, the multiplier and the personal-expense deduction were correctly applied.

¶ 20

iv.4. Whether the sisters are entitled to compensation for loss of consortium and whether the conventional heads were adequately awarded.

¶ 21–24

v.5. Whether the parents' apportionment of compensation was correct, given the distinction between legal representatives and dependants.

¶ 26–28

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 5 of the Limitation Act, requiring "sufficient cause" to be construed liberally but supported by a bona fide explanation, as laid down in Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag v. Mst. Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy

¶ 10

On compensation, the court relied on Arjun Kumar Aggarwal and Kandasami for the relevance of professional qualifications and prospective earning capacity

¶ 15

Deepak Singh @ Deepak Chauhan holds that an engineering student's notional income must not be equated with unskilled minimum wages but must remain realistic and not conjectural

¶ 16

National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi and Kirti v. Oriental Insurance require a 40% future-prospects addition, and Sarla Verma governs the 50% deduction for a bachelor and the multiplier of 18

¶ 20

Magma General Insurance v. Nanu Ram and United India Insurance v. Satinder Kaur recognise consortium for parents and siblings, with love and affection subsumed within consortium and not separately awardable

¶ 21–22

Sarla Verma also holds that a mother is ordinarily presumed a dependant of an unmarried son, while a father is not presumed dependent absent evidence

¶ 26

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 334

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166

04Reasoning

On delay, the court found the explanation (delay in obtaining the full record and legal advice) unsatisfactory but accepted it liberally, because the claimants had already appeared in the insurer's appeal and the cross-objections arose from the same award, causing no prejudice to the insurer

¶ 11

To balance equities, interest was denied for the 298 days

¶ 12

On income, the court distinguished Gurmit Kaur (₹12,000 assessed), where the deceased was in his final semester with proven academic merit, whereas here admission was only 13 days old, with no academic record and no proof of the shop income or assured employment

¶ 17–18

The ₹6,000 assessment was therefore affirmed as neither excessive nor requiring enhancement

¶ 19

The Tribunal's omission of future prospects was corrected by adding 40%, and the 50% deduction and multiplier of 18 were retained

¶ 20

The sisters, though not financially dependent, were held entitled to consortium for the loss of companionship and affection, awarded at ₹40,000 each

¶ 21–23

Filial consortium of ₹40,000 each was awarded to both parents, and loss of estate and funeral expenses were set at ₹15,000 each, subsuming the earlier ₹10,000

¶ 24

On apportionment, the loss of dependency was attributed to the mother alone, because no evidence showed the father's dependence and the sisters were not shown to be dependent. Both parents retained their consortium entitlement

¶ 26–27

Since the insurer did not specifically challenge the apportionment, recovery of sums already paid to the father was not ordered

¶ 27

05Holding

The insurer's appeal seeking reduction of compensation is dismissed. The cross-objections are partly allowed and the compensation is enhanced from ₹6,58,000 to ₹10,97,200, an enhancement of ₹4,39,200

¶ 25, 29

The monthly income of ₹6,000 is affirmed, with 40% future prospects, a 50% deduction and a multiplier of 18, giving loss of dependency of ₹9,07,200

¶ 19–20, 25

The delay of 298 days is condoned, with no interest for that period

¶ 12

The enhanced amount, payable to the mother, carries interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition, excluding the 298 days

¶ 28, 30

The insurer must deposit the enhanced amount with accrued interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy of the judgment. The Tribunal is to disburse it without ordering recovery of sums already paid under the award

¶ 28, 31
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Reliance General Insurance Co LtdvsSupinder Kaur & Ors

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment