01Facts
The appellant was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in 2009, and her appointment was approved with effect from that year.
¶ 3–4After the school received grant-in-aid status, she alleged that the management excluded her from the salary-grant list.
¶ 4–5, 8, 12An Education Officer’s inquiry found that her name had been improperly omitted and directed its inclusion.
¶ 4–5, 8, 12The management later initiated disciplinary proceedings and terminated her services in February 2022.
¶ 9–14The School Tribunal set aside the termination and ordered reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages; on remand, it reaffirmed that relief.
¶ 15–16The High Court reversed the Tribunal’s order and confirmed the termination.
¶ 17The appellant challenged that judgment before the Supreme Court, principally alleging that the inquiry was tainted by bias because the Convenor was the real brother of the management’s Secretary, who was the complainant and a key witness.
¶ 18–2202Issues
i.1. Whether the circumstances of the inquiry gave rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias, viewed from the perspective of a fair-minded person, so as to render the disciplinary proceedings legally unsustainable.
¶ 33ii.2. Whether the appellant waived her objection to the Convenor’s appointment, or whether the doctrine of necessity justified his participation.
¶ 24–25, 58, 60–6403Law Applied
The principles of natural justice require not only an adequate hearing but also an independent and impartial decision-maker; the test is whether a reasonable likelihood or real possibility of bias exists, not whether actual bias or a specific instance of prejudice is proved.
¶ 34–35, 43–49A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India establishes that a decision-making process may be vitiated where a reasonable person, considering the circumstances and ordinary human conduct, would apprehend bias.
¶ 43–44Close kinship may disqualify a decision-maker where it creates such a likelihood of bias, including in administrative proceedings.
¶ 44–46, 50The doctrine of necessity is an exception to the rule against bias only where no other eligible or available decision-maker can act.
¶ 41A waiver of a natural-justice objection must be voluntary, informed and unequivocal.
¶ 60Under Rule 36(2)(a)(i) of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981, the management may nominate one of its members to the inquiry committee; Rule 26(2)(iii) provides for consideration of absorption in another aided school.
¶ 25, 6704Reasoning
The Court found that the inquiry was affected by “total familial capture”: the Convenor, Prakash Masurkar, was the Secretary’s real brother, while the Secretary initiated the proceedings and acted as a principal witness, including as the sole witness on eleven of the twenty charges.
¶ 51–53In those circumstances, the Convenor’s close relationship with the complainant and key witness created a reasonable likelihood of bias and undermined the separation of functions required for a fair inquiry; procedural compliance and cross-examination could not cure that foundational defect.
¶ 54–57Necessity did not apply because unrelated members of the management committee were available to be nominated.
¶ 58Nor was the objection waived: the inquiry report and the record before the Tribunal showed that the appellant had objected to the Convenor’s appointment.
¶ 61–6405Holding
The Court held that the inquiry was unsustainable because the circumstances established a reasonable likelihood of bias.
¶ 66It allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s judgment and restored the School Tribunal’s order quashing the termination and directing reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages.
¶ 67It also directed the Education Officer to consider the feasibility of absorbing the appellant in another 100% grant-in-aid school within the jurisdiction, in accordance with Rule 26(2)(iii) of the MEPS Rules.
¶ 67Original Court PDF
Ku. Kiran D/O Purushottam BhujadevsSudhir Shikshan Sanstha
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
