01Facts
The judgment concerns a large batch of civil appeals, special leave petitions, review petitions, miscellaneous applications, curative petitions and contempt petitions arising from land acquisitions in Delhi initiated under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 before the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 came into force.
¶ 7–10Following *Pune Municipal Corporation v. Harakchand Misirimal Solanki*, several Delhi High Court decisions declared acquisitions lapsed under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act; the Supreme Court later overruled that interpretation in *Indore Development Authority v. Manoharlal*.
¶ 13–16In 2024, the Supreme Court issued decisions addressing the effect of that change in law, including the treatment of concluded proceedings, delayed challenges, and cases not previously considered under the new legal position.
¶ 17–18The matters in this batch remained pending or arose from those earlier decisions, and the Court considered whether they should be individually decided or remitted to the Delhi High Court.
¶ 19 · ¶ 21–2402Issues
i.1. Whether the residual matters should be determined individually by the Supreme Court or remitted to the Delhi High Court for consideration under the principles in the 2024 judgments.
¶ 21–22ii.2. Whether the matters involving review, modification or recall of earlier Supreme Court orders, or contempt, should also be remitted to the High Court.
¶ 23iii.3. What framework the High Court should apply to matters requiring an initial determination under the 2024 judgments.
¶ 2403Law Applied
Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act governs whether certain pre-2014 acquisitions under the 1894 Act are deemed to have lapsed.
In *Indore Development Authority v. Manoharlal*, the Constitution Bench held that lapse under Section 24(2) requires both non-payment of compensation and failure to take possession; either payment of compensation or taking possession defeats the claim of lapse.
¶ 16The 2024 decisions—*State (NCT of Delhi) v. K.L. Rathi Steels Ltd.*, *State (NCT of Delhi) v. BSK Realtors LLP* and *DDA v. Tejpal*—addressed, among other matters, the maintainability of later applications after concluded Supreme Court proceedings, the doctrine of merger, and condonation of delay in appropriate cases.
¶ 18.1–18.4For cases requiring initial consideration, the High Court must examine the writ petitioners’ locus standi, whether the Supreme Court has already passed an appellate order giving rise to merger, and—where the petition is maintainable and no such appellate order exists—whether the acquisition lapsed under the governing law.
¶ 18.5, 24.1–24.3The Supreme Court invoked Article 142 to make orders for complete justice, while identifying the High Court’s Article 226 jurisdiction as the appropriate forum for the required case-specific determinations.
¶ 22, 25Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 Section 24
04Reasoning
The Court considered individual adjudication by the Supreme Court impractical because the cases involved diverse facts and would require examination of evidence, while the Supreme Court was the final forum for those factual determinations.
¶ 21Remittal to the High Court would allow case-by-case consideration under the 2024 judgments without reopening the original lapse question contrary to *Indore Development Authority*.
¶ 22, 24The High Court must first assess locus standi, then determine whether a prior Supreme Court appellate order has resulted in merger, and, only where appropriate, apply the law in force to the acquisition.
¶ 24Review, modification or recall matters and contempt petitions were treated differently because they concerned orders or proceedings of the Supreme Court and were not suitable for remittal.
¶ 2305Holding
The Court directed that the matters in List A be partly allowed, setting aside the impugned High Court orders and reviving the underlying writ petitions for adjudication in accordance with this judgment and the 2024 judgments.
¶ 25(i)The applications in List B were dismissed, but the underlying High Court writ petitions were restored for determination on that basis.
¶ 25(ii)The records are to be transferred to the Delhi High Court, and any interim relief granted by the Supreme Court is to continue until the High Court finally disposes of the cases.
¶ 25(iii)–(iv)The matters in List C are to be listed before an appropriate Supreme Court bench.
¶ 27The Court made no determination on the merits of the individual acquisition disputes.
¶ 25(iv)Original Court PDF
Delhi State Industrial Infrastructuraldevelopment Corporation Ltd (Dsiidc)vsTara Chand
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
