01Facts
The petitioner was appointed Assistant Professor after regular selection at Seemant Institute of Technology, Pithoragarh, by order dated 9.8.2012.
The order provided for the scale of ₹15,600–39,100 with AGP of ₹6,000.
¶ 4He is instead paid a consolidated salary of ₹48,963 per month.
¶ 4The respondent University states that he later joined Women Institute of Technology, Dehradun, in 2012 and now serves at the Faculty of Technology, Uttarakhand Technical University, Dehradun.
¶ 5The University's Finance Committee sanctioned consolidated salary/honorarium of ₹60,000 per month.
¶ 5The petitioner refuses this amount and insists on payment under the UGC scale.
¶ 5Counsel for the petitioner states that the University conditions the revised salary on an undertaking that the faculty member will not claim regularisation.
¶ 6The petitioner sought (i) regularisation or treatment of his appointment as regular and permanent, with service benefits at par with regular faculty, and (ii) a direction not to fill his posts from the open market before regularisation.
¶ 3The court noted that the petitioner had served as Assistant Professor in a campus college of the University for more than a decade.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, having served for over a decade as Assistant Professor in a campus college, has earned a right to be considered for regularisation under the existing scheme/rules.
¶ 7ii.2. Whether the University may condition payment of the Finance Committee–sanctioned salary of ₹60,000 per month on an undertaking not to claim regularisation, and whether that condition is reasonable.
¶ 6, 7iii.3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to salary and service benefits at par with regular faculty on equivalent posts under UGC Regulations.
¶ 4, 803Law Applied
The existing scheme/rules governing regularisation of faculty appointments in the University.
¶ 7The UGC Regulations, as the basis for salary and service benefits at par with regular faculty on equivalent posts.
¶ 4, 8A faculty member who has rendered over a decade of service acquires a right to be considered for regularisation.
¶ 7A condition requiring a waiver of future regularisation claims as a prerequisite for payment is prima facie unreasonable.
¶ 7Where merits require administrative determination, the matter is relegated to the competent authority through representation, with a time-bound decision.
¶ 804Reasoning
The court held that the petitioner had completed more than a decade of service and therefore had a right to be considered for regularisation under the existing rules.
¶ 7Because the Finance Committee had already sanctioned ₹60,000 per month, the court found the undertaking condition unreasonable, as it effectively required the petitioner to surrender a claim in exchange for payment he was already entitled to receive.
¶ 7The court did not decide the merits of regularisation or the claim to UGC pay scales. It instead disposed of the petitions with liberty to submit separate representations to the competent University authority.
¶ 8This approach reflects the existence of factual disputes regarding the petitioner's place of service and the applicable scheme, which require administrative determination.
¶ 4–5, 8To prevent prejudice pending decision, the court directed interim payment without the undertaking.
¶ 805Holding
The condition requiring an undertaking not to claim regularisation as a precondition for payment of the sanctioned salary is unreasonable.
¶ 7The writ petitions are disposed of without adjudicating the claims for regularisation or UGC-scale salary. The petitioner may submit a representation within two weeks, and the competent authority must decide it within six months thereafter, as per law. Pending that decision, the petitioner shall be paid salary/honorarium as sanctioned by the Finance Committee, without any undertaking that he will not claim regularisation in future. The order does not prejudice any ongoing selection for faculty positions.
¶ 8Original Court PDF
MOHD SAAQIBvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
