01Facts
The respondent, Poonam Bahuguna, was engaged as a contractual employee in the library of the Advocate General's office, Uttarakhand, and has worked there continuously without a break.
¶ 3She was paid the minimum of the pay scale of a regular Class-III employee from 2010.
¶ 3By order dated 16.10.2023, the respondent was directed to continue as an outsourced employee through an agency, and she challenged that order by writ petition.
¶ 3The respondents' counter-affidavit did not deny that she was working regularly and being paid the minimum of the Junior Assistant scale, and stated that regularisation was under process.
¶ 4The State contended that no post of Assistant Librarian is sanctioned in the office, and that the Advocate General is not empowered to regularise.
¶ 5, 8The respondent's rejoinder relied on the Advocate General's file noting to show work since July 2007.
¶ 6The learned Single Judge held that she was entitled to regularisation as a Junior Assistant under the Regularisation Rules, 2013 (as amended in 2025), quashed the 16.10.2023 order and the notice dated 31.10.2023, and directed consideration of her regularisation within two months.
¶ 7, 8The State filed the present Special Appeal against the judgment dated 24.08.2026.
¶ 1, 902Issues
i.1. Whether the learned Advocate General is the appointing authority under the Uttarakhand Advocate General Office Establishment (Service of Employees) Rules, 2013.
¶ 24, 25ii.2. Whether the respondent had been working in the office of the Advocate General since 2007 or 2009.
¶ 24, 26iii.3. Whether the respondent is entitled to the benefit of the Uttarakhand Regularisation of Daily Wages, Work Charged, Contract, Fixed Pay, Part Time, Adhoc Employees Appointment Rules, 2013.
¶ 24, 2703Law Applied
Rule 3(a), Rules 14 and 15 of the Establishment Rules, 2013 define the Advocate General as "Appointing Authority," empower it to determine vacancies, and constitute the selection committee for Junior Assistant posts.
¶ 16, 25The Office Memorandum dated 22.02.2007 identifies the Advocate General as appointing authority.
¶ 25Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1, particularly paras. 43 and 45 (no regularisation of irregular appointments as a matter of right, subject to the constitutional scheme) and para. 53 (one-time regularisation of irregularly appointed employees with ten or more years' service).
¶ 12, 27The Regularisation Rules, 2013, read with the Division Bench-approved modification in Narendra Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, WP(S/B) No. 616 of 2018 (22.02.2024), under which ten years' service, rather than five, is counted after 04.12.2018.
¶ 20, 27Sukhendu Bhattacharjee v. State of Assam (2026 SCC OnLine SC 909), paras. 67, 70–71, 73–74, which discussed the State's model-employer obligations and the limits of Umadevi in relation to long-serving employees, and Jaggo v. Union of India (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826), as cited therein.
¶ 21, 27The State's contention that Jaggo and Dharam Singh are not good law in light of Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State of Maharashtra (2005) 2 SCC 673.
¶ 13, 27Bongaigaon Refinery v. Girish Chandra Sarma (2007) 7 SCC 206, para. 22, on raising pleas in appeal.
¶ 1504Reasoning
On the first issue, the Court found that the Establishment Rules, 2013 define the Advocate General as the appointing authority, and the State could not point to any rule showing otherwise.
¶ 25On the second issue, the Court accepted the respondent's case of service since 2007, relying on the Advocate General's own file noting dated 20.07.2018 and the library register bearing her signature from 2007, which the State could not deny.
¶ 26On the third issue, the Court held that the Regularisation Rules, 2013 apply in the Advocate General's office. It rejected the State's reliance on Umadevi paras. 43 and 45 because Umadevi para. 53 itself provides relief for irregularly appointed employees with long service, and the State framed the 2013 Rules consistently with that judgment.
¶ 27Applying the modified ten-year criterion from Narendra Singh, the respondent, with service from 2007 (or 2009), had completed the required period before the cut-off date, and the Sukhendu Bhattacharjee principles supported relief.
¶ 27The Court noted that the State did not contend that the Junior Assistant post was not vacant. The Court did not separately decide the State's objections based on the 25.04.2025 Government Order banning recruitment, the Jaggo/Dawoodi Bohra argument, or the impleadment of the Advocate General, nor the State's alternative prayer to redirect the relief to the State Government.
¶ 10–11, 13, 19, 22, 23, 27–2805Holding
The Advocate General is the appointing authority for Junior Assistant posts under the Establishment Rules, 2013.
¶ 25The respondent has worked in the Advocate General's office since 2007, as established by the file noting and library register.
¶ 26The respondent is entitled to regularisation under the Regularisation Rules, 2013, as modified in Narendra Singh. The Special Appeal is dismissed, and the Single Judge's judgment dated 24.08.2026 is upheld.
¶ 27, 28–29The operative direction stands: respondent no. 2 (the Advocate General) must consider the respondent's regularisation as Junior Assistant in the library or any Class-III post in the Advocate General's office within two months of receiving a certified copy of the order, and the 16.10.2023 order and 31.10.2023 notice remain quashed.
¶ 1, 8Original Court PDF
STATE OF UTTARAKHANDvsPOONAM BAHUGUNA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
