01Facts
The respondent, Agniv Sengupta, was accused in FIR No. 4 of 2025 at the Anti Narcotic Cell, North Goa, and was allegedly found in possession of 50.03 g of cocaine and 15.04 g of MDMA from Room/Flat No. 106 at Helen Oasis, Vagator, Goa, an Air-B&B facility.
p. 1The search was conducted in the presence of panchas, Mr. Jerry D'Souza (the facility manager), and an independent witness, after the respondent was detained from the basement and led to the room.
pp. 1-2 · p. 4The respondent refused to surrender the keys, and duplicate keys were obtained from Mr. D'Souza.
p. 1The proceedings were video-recorded.
p. 2The High Court granted bail, reasoning that the manager had unhindered access to the room and therefore there was prima facie reason to believe the respondent had not committed the offence.
p. 3Before the High Court, the respondent contended he was arrested two days earlier, tortured, burnt on the hand, and framed by planting contraband, and that he had never occupied the room; he relied on a Leave and License Agreement under which Mr. D'Souza was the licensee.
p. 2 · pp. 3-4The counter-affidavit recorded prior intimation of "reliable information" on 22.01.2025, a search warrant, and a seizure report signed by the manager.
p. 4A medical report recorded a forearm burn that the doctor opined could have occurred two days earlier.
p. 5The licence permitted commercial, daily-basis use, and the police case was that Mr. D'Souza had rented the premises to the respondent from 17.01.2025 to 26.01.2025, which encompassed the date of recovery.
pp. 5-602Issues
i.1. Whether the High Court erred in granting bail on the ground that the facility manager's unhindered access to the room made it prima facie unlikely that the respondent committed the offence.
p. 3 · p. 4ii.2. Whether the respondent's occupation of Room No. 106 was established such that the contraband recovered there could be attributed to him, notwithstanding the lease held by the manager.
pp. 3-4 · pp. 5-6iii.3. Whether the respondent's defence of planting, custodial torture, and a bogus raid was credible at the bail stage.
p. 2 · p. 503Law Applied
The order does not expressly cite any statute, section of the NDPS Act, or precedent; the offence is described only as narcotics possession under an Anti Narcotic Cell FIR.
Possession of premises is not negated by a third party's access or the existence of a management master key, since hotels and rental facilities retain alternate keys for cleaning and similar purposes, so recovery from a room cannot be attributed away from its occupant on that basis alone.
p. 3 · p. 4Occupation for the relevant period may be established through licence or rental documents and corroborating witness statements, including the manager's own statement.
pp. 5-6At the bail stage, a defence of framing or custodial torture must be assessed for prima facie credibility against contemporaneous material such as the search warrant, seizure report, video recording, and medical evidence.
p. 4 · p. 5The settled principle that bail orders resting on flawed reasoning may be set aside where the grant is unsustainable.
p. 604Reasoning
The High Court's reasoning was legally untenable. If a manager's access to a room sufficed to exclude the occupant's possession, recovery from any hotel or rental unit could never be pinned on its occupant.
p. 3 · p. 4The Court tested the respondent's defence against the record: the prior intimation and search warrant showed the operation was planned on 22.01.2025, the seizure report was signed by the manager and independent panchas, and the medical opinion that the burn could have occurred two days earlier did not establish custodial torture.
p. 4 · pp. 4-5The respondent's account of a bogus raid was held not to impress the Court prima facie.
p. 5On occupation, the Court found that the licence was for commercial daily-use letting and that the manager had rented the unit to the respondent for 17.01.2025 to 26.01.2025, a period covering the apprehension and recovery, as corroborated by the manager's statement.
pp. 5-6The defence's reliance on the lease therefore did not displace the prosecution's version of occupation at this stage.
p. 605Holding
The Supreme Court held that the High Court's grant of bail was unsustainable and that there was "absolutely no reason to sustain" it.
p. 6Issue 1 was answered in the negative, the manager's access not prima facie exonerating the respondent. Issue 2 was answered in favour of the State, the respondent's occupation of Room No. 106 during the relevant period being sufficiently indicated. Issue 3 was answered against the respondent, the framing and torture plea being prima facie unpersuasive.
pp. 3-4 · pp. 5-6 · p. 5The appeal was allowed and the impugned bail order set aside. The respondent was directed to surrender within three weeks, failing which he was to be apprehended and produced before the jurisdictional court for judicial custody, subject to any police custody order that court may pass. The appeal was disposed of and pending applications rejected.
p. 6 · pp. 6-7Original Court PDF
State Of GoavsAgniv Sengupta
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
