01Facts
The appellant, Ashok Kumar, joined the Central Bank of India on 1 March 1969.
He was suspended on 22 November 1978 for alleged defalcation.
¶ 5An FIR under IPC Sections 409, 420, 465, 468, 471 and 120B was registered, and he was acquitted on 15 July 1983.
¶ 5The High Court dismissed the State's and the Bank's appeal/revision on 27 May 1991, and the acquittal attained finality.
¶ 5The Bank initiated departmental proceedings by charge-sheet on 16 May 1990.
Kumar challenged them in the earlier writ petition (CWP-8983-1991), filed on 11 June 1991, which the High Court allowed on 12 October 2007.
¶ 6The order quashed the enquiry and directed reinstatement (if not superannuated) with consequential benefits.
¶ 18The Division Bench dismissed the Bank's intra-court appeal on 20 December 2007.
¶ 7This Court's interim order of 20 March 2009 restrained the Bank from giving effect to its dismissal order of 30 March 2009.
¶ 8Kumar retired on 31 March 2009 while under suspension.
¶ 9The Bank's SLP was dismissed on 26 July 2011.
¶ 10The Bank paid about Rs. 42 lakhs on 1 December 2011, after contempt proceedings, and the contempt action was closed on 28 October 2013.
¶ 11Kumar's fresh writ petition (CWP-11438-2015), filed on 26 May 2015, sought 18% compound interest on delayed salary and 24% on accrued interest.
¶ 12The Single Judge rejected it on 11 December 2023 on the ground that interest was not claimed earlier and that granting it would modify the 2007 judgment.
¶ 13Kumar then filed a miscellaneous application under Section 151 CPC in the earlier writ petition on 26 February 2024, seeking 18% interest.
¶ 13The Single Judge dismissed it on 21 March 2024.
¶ 14The Division Bench dismissed the LPA on 9 May 2024 on grounds of finality, constructive res judicata and estoppel.
¶ 15 · ¶ 1602Issues
i.1. Whether a miscellaneous application in a finally decided writ petition is a permissible vehicle for seeking substantive relief, such as interest on delayed salary, based on a fresh cause of action.
¶ 21 · ¶ 22ii.2. Whether the claim for interest is barred by constructive res judicata, Explanation IV to Section 11 CPC, or Order II Rule 2 CPC, given that it was not claimed in the earlier writ petition.
¶ 17 · ¶ 20iii.3. Whether the claim for interest arose from a cause of action distinct from the one in the earlier writ petition, and whether it could be raised in a fresh proceeding.
¶ 20 · ¶ 23iv.4. Whether the appellant is entitled to interest on delayed payment of salary/arrears, and whether equitable relief under Article 142 is appropriate.
¶ 23 · ¶ 24 · ¶ 25 · ¶ 2603Law Applied
The Court relied on the constructive res judicata principle in Explanation IV to Section 11 CPC and the bar in Order II Rule 2 CPC, as applied in CIT v. T.P. Kumaran (1996) 10 SCC 561.
¶ 17These bars apply only to claims that could have been raised when the earlier proceeding was instituted, and not to claims arising from a subsequent cause of action.
¶ 20A miscellaneous application in a finally decided writ petition is not an independent proceeding. It is confined to ancillary matters such as correction of arithmetical or clerical errors, clarification of ambiguity, modification of the mode of compliance, extension of time, and recall of dismissal orders. It cannot be used to seek a fresh or substantive relief or to reopen the merits.
¶ 21This rule was drawn from State of U.P. v. Brahma Dutt Sharma (1987) 2 SCC 179, Budhia Swain v. Gopinath Deb (1999) 4 SCC 396, Ram Chandra Singh v. Savitri Devi (2004) 12 SCC 713, K.A. Ansari v. Indian Airlines Ltd. (2009) 2 SCC 164, and Government of NCT of Delhi v. K.L. Rathi Steels Ltd. (2024) 7 SCC 315.
¶ 21Interest on a delayed payment is an accretion on capital and not a penalty, as stated in Alok Shanker Pandey v. Union of India (2007) 3 SCC 545.
¶ 23The Court applied the maxim actus curiae neminem gravabit.
¶ 23The Court relied on Jeypore Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer (1998) 9 SCC 358, which holds that the technical plea of constructive res judicata should not defeat otherwise due relief.
¶ 25Article 142 of the Constitution provides the power to do complete justice.
¶ 26Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 409Section 420Section 465Section 468Section 471
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151Section 11
04Reasoning
The original cause of action in the 1991 writ petition concerned the challenge to disciplinary proceedings and reinstatement. Non-payment of salary and interest did not form part of it, and no claim for interest could have been foreseen when the petition was filed.
¶ 20The delay in concluding litigation, which ended with the SLP dismissal on 26 July 2011, was a subsequent event. It gave rise to a distinct cause of action. Therefore, res judicata and Order II Rule 2 did not bar the claim.
¶ 20The claim for interest also required adjudication of new facts, such as entitlement, periods of delay attributable to each party, and the applicable rate. It was therefore substantive and independent, and the proper remedy was a fresh proceeding. That was correctly instituted in the 2015 writ petition.
¶ 20The Single Judge erred in dismissing that petition on an untenable ground, and Kumar should have appealed that order by LPA.
¶ 20The miscellaneous application in the 2007 writ petition was not maintainable because it sought a substantive relief on a different issue.
¶ 21 · ¶ 22The Court nonetheless found that the Single Judge and Division Bench had not held that Kumar was not entitled to interest. It also observed that Kumar had been kept from duty for decades through no fault of his own.
¶ 22 · ¶ 24Given his age and the multiple proceedings, the Court considered equitable relief appropriate. It applied the reasoning in Jeypore Sugar and invoked Article 142.
¶ 24 · ¶ 25 · ¶ 2605Holding
The miscellaneous application was not maintainable and the High Court correctly dismissed it.
¶ 22Constructive res judicata and Order II Rule 2 CPC did not bar the claim for interest, which arose from a subsequent and distinct cause of action.
¶ 20 · ¶ 23The appellant was entitled to claim interest, which the High Court wrongly refused to consider on merits.
¶ 23In exercise of its Article 142 powers, the Court directed the Bank to pay an additional Rs. 5,00,000 to the appellant within two months of the production of the judgment before the Bank's competent authority. This amount is in full and final settlement of his dues against the Bank.
¶ 26The appeal was disposed of accordingly, and connected applications stand disposed of.
¶ 27Original Court PDF
Ashok KumarvsCentral Bank Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
