01Facts
The appellants' predecessors, the original plaintiffs, sued in 1990 to recover possession of Premises No. XI/4239-A/2 (Plot No. 3A), Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, after the tenancy of respondent no. 1 (M/s Goodyear India Ltd.) terminated on 31.12.1989.
¶ 2The original plaintiffs also claimed damages for use and occupation at Rs. 1,47,500 per month with 15% interest.
¶ 2The Trial Court decreed possession on 22.12.1998 and passed a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, leaving pendente lite and future mesne profits to a separate inquiry.
¶ 3The tenant's appeal (RFA No. 318 of 1999) was dismissed, and its SLP was dismissed in limine on 19.03.2001, so the possession decree became final.
¶ 4In the inquiry, the Trial Court fixed mesne profits at Rs. 22/sq. ft. per month (ground floor) and Rs. 11/sq. ft. (mezzanine), with 15% interest, relying on comparable premises let to Vijaya Bank.
¶ 5 · ¶ 11The First Appellate Court set this aside as speculative, and fixed mesne profits at the admitted rent rate, rejecting the Vijaya Bank comparison on grounds of age, use, and lack of valuation evidence.
¶ 6 · ¶ 12In second appeals (RSA Nos. 186 and 187 of 2010), the High Court held that the First Appellate Court had overlooked a material admission of respondent's witness DW-1 P.V. Ramani regarding prevailing rents of Rs. 5 to Rs. 8/sq. ft.
¶ 7The High Court fixed mesne profits at Rs. 7 (ground floor) and Rs. 5 (mezzanine), with simple interest at 7.5% p.a., reducible to 6% if paid within two months.
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the High Court was justified in interfering under Section 100 CPC with the First Appellate Court's determination of mesne profits, on the ground that a material admission of respondent's witness had been overlooked.
¶ 8 · ¶ 13ii.2. Whether the rate of mesne profits fixed by the High Court (Rs. 7/sq. ft. for the ground floor and Rs. 5/sq. ft. for the mezzanine) is a fair and reasonable determination warranting no interference.
¶ 10 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 18iii.3. Whether the High Court's award of simple interest at 7.5% p.a. (reducible to 6%) on mesne profits is sustainable.
¶ 1603Law Applied
Mesne profits are compensatory and are meant to recompense the true owner for wrongful occupation. Their assessment is not governed by any rigid formula but requires a fair and reasonable estimate considering the nature and location of the property, prevailing rental value, the evidence, and surrounding circumstances.
¶ 10Findings on mesne profits are factual and ordinarily not disturbed on appeal unless manifestly arbitrary, unsupported by the record, or based on an erroneous application of law, as laid down in Martin and Harris Private Limited v. Rajendra Mehta, (2022) 8 SCC 527.
¶ 10Interest is an integral component of mesne profits, compensating the owner for deprivation of beneficial enjoyment during wrongful occupation, as laid down in Mahant Narayana Dasjee Varu v. Board of Trustees, Tirumalai Tirupathi Devasthanam, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 125.
¶ 16 · ¶ 13(3)Order XX Rule 12 CPC provides the procedural framework of a preliminary decree followed by a separate inquiry for mesne profits.
¶ 3 · ¶ 5Section 100 CPC permits a second appeal only on a substantial question of law.
¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The First Appellate Court had omitted to consider DW-1's admission that prevailing rents ranged between Rs. 5 and Rs. 8/sq. ft., which bore directly on mesne profits. The omission was material and gave rise to a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.
¶ 13The High Court did not mechanically adopt the lowest admitted figure. It weighed the evidence as a whole, did not revive the Vijaya Bank comparison, and fixed rates within the range disclosed by respondent's own witness. This was a balanced assessment that was neither arbitrary nor baseless.
¶ 14Because the High Court corrected a real evidentiary omission and reached a reasoned finding without perversity or legal misapplication, the Court declined to disturb it.
¶ 15Interest was treated as an integral part of mesne profits. Given the facts, the 7.5% rate, with the 6% concession for prompt payment, was not disturbed.
¶ 16The Court weighed the age of the litigation: possession was decided in 2001, the appeals had been pending for nearly fifteen years, and the quantification turned on unchanged evidence. It therefore saw finality as serving the interests of justice.
¶ 1705Holding
The High Court properly interfered under Section 100 CPC to correct the First Appellate Court's omission of a material admission.
¶ 13 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 15The rates of Rs. 7/sq. ft. (ground floor) and Rs. 5/sq. ft. (mezzanine) are a fair and reasonable determination of mesne profits on the record.
¶ 14 · ¶ 15 · ¶ 18The award of simple interest at 7.5% p.a., reducible to 6% p.a. upon payment within the stipulated period, was upheld.
¶ 16Finding no legal infirmity, the Court dismissed both Civil Appeals and affirmed the High Court's common judgment dated 11.08.2011 in RSA Nos. 186 and 187 of 2010.
¶ 15 · ¶ 19Original Court PDF
Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Thr. Lrs.vsM/S Goodyear India Ltd .
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
