Supreme CourtAdministrative and Public LawProperty and Real Estate Law

Supreme Court Sends Property Owners' Highway Demolition Disputes to High Courts, With Removals Held Back Meanwhile

In Re: Phalodi Accidentv.National Highways Authority Of India

Supreme Court Sends Property Owners' Highway Demolition Disputes to High Courts, With Removals Held Back Meanwhile. In Re: Phalodi Accident vs National Highways Authority Of India. Supreme Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the directions dated 13.04.2026 in the suo motu proceedings authorise the removal of structures as encroachments without determining whether they are in fact unauthorised encroachments on highway land and without following the procedure under Section 26 of the CNH Act.

The court held

The 13.04.2026 directions do not conclusively determine whether any structure is an unauthorised encroachment and cannot dispense with the statutory procedure under Section 26 of the CNH Act.

It also directed

The individual applicants are relegated to their jurisdictional High Courts, expressly without expressing any opinion on the merits. The 13.04.2026 directions continue to operate, subject to consistency with statutory provisions and the affected persons' rights to remedies.

Interim protection granted by the Court continues until disposal of High Court proceedings, and in cases where no protection was granted, NHAI and the concerned authorities are restrained from demolition or coercive action under the impugned notices until such disposal. High Courts are requested to decide matters expeditiously and independently, with all questions of ownership, demarcation, acquisition and statutory compliance left open. Interim protection is confined to the subject structures and creates no equity or right to fresh construction.

Listed I.A.s (including I.A. Nos. 269085, 269086, 305732, 305733, 308232–308234, among others) stand disposed of; the remaining applications remain pending and the main matter is to be listed with connected matters.

01Facts

Suo motu proceedings were initiated on road safety on National Highways following accidents at Phalodi, Rajasthan, and elsewhere.

The Court's order dated 13.04.2026 directed authorities to file consolidated reports on highway inspection and encroachments, prohibited new commercial structures within the Right of Way (ROW) of National Highways, directed District Magistrates to remove unauthorised structures within 60 days under the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 ("CNH Act") and the SOP dated 07.08.2025, and constituted District Highway Safety Task Forces.

¶ 2

Pursuant to these directions, NHAI and State authorities initiated removal of structures alleged to be encroachments.

¶ 4

Multiple applicants, many having first approached their jurisdictional High Courts, sought clarification of the 13.04.2026 directions and interim protection against demolition.

¶ 5–10

Applicants asserted ownership through registered sale deeds, acquisition, or permissions, disputed demarcation, and in some cases alleged that no formal notice was served.

¶ 5–10

Status quo orders were passed on 08.09.2026, 22.09.2026 and 06.10.2026.

¶ 4, 11

NHAI contended that removal was mandated by the 13.04.2026 directions and that notices were issued under the CNH Act, while ownership and boundary disputes were questions of fact for the competent court.

¶ 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the directions dated 13.04.2026 in the suo motu proceedings authorise the removal of structures as encroachments without determining whether they are in fact unauthorised encroachments on highway land and without following the procedure under Section 26 of the CNH Act.

¶ 14–15

ii.2. Whether the individual grievances concerning ownership, the extent of the ROW, demarcation and acquisition, which are raised in the interlocutory applications, should be adjudicated by the Supreme Court or relegated to the jurisdictional High Courts.

¶ 17–18

03Law Applied

Section 26 of the CNH Act, 2002 provides the statutory mechanism for removing unauthorised occupation of highway land, requiring notice, an opportunity to make a representation, and consideration of the cause shown (subsections 2–6). Subsections 7 and 8 permit removal without prior notice only under specified statutory conditions.

¶ 16

The Court applied its own decision in Gyan Prakash v. Union of India & Ors., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1189, holding that Section 26 procedure is essential to natural justice.

¶ 16

Direction 4(c) of the 13.04.2026 order itself requires removal in accordance with the CNH Act procedure and the SOP dated 07.08.2025.

¶ 15

A general direction to remove encroachments is not a conclusive adjudication that a particular structure is an encroachment, and a mere assertion by authorities cannot substitute for the determination required by law where the basis is disputed.

¶ 15, 17

The jurisdictional High Courts are the appropriate forum for fact-intensive adjudication of individual rights.

¶ 18

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 Section 26

04Reasoning

The Court distinguished the systemic objective of the 13.04.2026 directions, which concerned highway safety, from the individual rights of property owners. The directions did not examine or determine whether any particular structure was an unauthorised encroachment.

¶ 14

Applying the principle that such directions cannot override the CNH Act, the Court held that the authorities could not rely on them as an independent justification for dispensing with Section 26 procedure.

¶ 16

The Court accepted that mere assertion of ownership does not bar statutory action, but held that disputed claims regarding ownership, ROW extent, demarcation and acquisition required examination of revenue records, acquisition proceedings and survey reports, and hence adjudication under law.

¶ 17

Because the Court would be required to undertake factual examination of each disputed property, which would be neither appropriate nor practicable in suo motu proceedings on systemic safety, it relegated these disputes to the High Courts, which are better placed to examine records and the legality of the action.

¶ 18

05Holding

The 13.04.2026 directions do not conclusively determine whether any structure is an unauthorised encroachment and cannot dispense with the statutory procedure under Section 26 of the CNH Act.

¶ 15–16

The individual applicants are relegated to their jurisdictional High Courts, expressly without expressing any opinion on the merits. The 13.04.2026 directions continue to operate, subject to consistency with statutory provisions and the affected persons' rights to remedies.

¶ 18–20, 22 · ¶ 19

Interim protection granted by the Court continues until disposal of High Court proceedings, and in cases where no protection was granted, NHAI and the concerned authorities are restrained from demolition or coercive action under the impugned notices until such disposal. High Courts are requested to decide matters expeditiously and independently, with all questions of ownership, demarcation, acquisition and statutory compliance left open. Interim protection is confined to the subject structures and creates no equity or right to fresh construction.

¶ 21 · ¶ 22 · ¶ 23

Listed I.A.s (including I.A. Nos. 269085, 269086, 305732, 305733, 308232–308234, among others) stand disposed of; the remaining applications remain pending and the main matter is to be listed with connected matters.

¶ 24–25
Supreme Court

Original Court PDF

In Re: Phalodi AccidentvsNational Highways Authority Of India

Supreme Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment