01Facts
The dispute concerns 58 cents out of an original 1 acre 50 cents in Okkiyam Thuraipakkam, gifted in 1925 by Raghavan Naicker to his daughter Kannammal (Doc. No. 2704 of 1925). The property passed to Ayyasamy, whose heirs, PW1 and PW2, were in possession.
¶ 2The accused A1 (Santha) executed a settlement deed (Doc. No. 4719 of 2005, dated 17.08.2005) in favour of her son A2 (Kathiresan), who sold the land to A3 (Boominathan) by sale deed (Doc. No. 5867 of 2005, dated 10.10.2005).
¶ 3A1's title rested on a 1964 sale deed (Doc. No. 2648 of 1964), which the prosecution alleged was a mortgage between strangers and that the purported sale deed (Ex. P9) was forged, using a stamp paper issued by a vendor not licensed until 1990.
¶ 3-4The petitioner (A5) and A4 (Nallasivam) attested the 2005 settlement and sale deeds.
¶ 4Crime No. 102 of 2005 was registered by the CCB; the final report was filed in C.C. No. 233 of 2006.
¶ 5The trial court (JMC-I, Poonamallee, 27.03.2015) convicted A1 to A5 under ss. 465 r/w 120(B), 468 r/w 471 and 420 r/w 34 IPC.
¶ 6-7The Sessions Court (Crl.A. No. 125 of 2017, 21.03.2019) dismissed the appeal, holding the attestation "more than mere witness" and the conspiracy established.
¶ 8The petitioner's revision was dismissed as withdrawn on 14.06.2019 for non-surrender, restored after SLP proceedings, and sentence was suspended on 20.03.2020.
¶ 9A1 lost her challenge, A4 died, A2 absconded, and A3 was acquitted in Crl.R.C. No. 1064 of 2017 (07.04.2022) on the same evidence.
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the conviction and sentence of A5 suffer from any infirmity in law or in appreciation of evidence warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction.
¶ 15ii.2. Whether there is legally admissible evidence connecting A5 with the alleged forgery or with any agreement to commit or use the forged document.
¶ 17-18iii.3. Whether attestation of registered documents, without other incriminating circumstances, establishes knowledge of forgery or criminal conspiracy.
¶ 19-21iv.4. Whether the Courts below impermissibly shifted the burden of proof onto the accused.
¶ 22v.5. Whether the substantive offences under ss. 465, 468, 471 and 420 IPC are made out against A5.
¶ 23-24vi.6. Whether the uncertified police statement dated 24.02.2017 can be relied upon.
¶ 2603Law Applied
The Court's revisional power under ss. 397 and 401 CrPC is limited to correcting jurisdictional error, material illegality, or perversity resulting in miscarriage of justice, and a finding of guilt based on no legally admissible evidence, or arrived at by impermissibly shifting the burden of proof, is vulnerable to interference, citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri, (1999) 2 SCC 452, and Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460.
¶ 16Under s. 120-A IPC, conspiracy requires an agreement to do an illegal act; it may be inferred from proved circumstances only where they form a complete chain consistent with guilt and inconsistent with any other reasonable hypothesis, as stated in Kehar Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.), (1988) 3 SCC 609, and Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116.
¶ 20Under s. 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, an attesting witness certifies only the fact of execution and does not vouch for title or the truth of recitals.
¶ 19Under s. 464 IPC, a document executed in the executant's own name is not a "false document" merely because the title asserted is untrue, as held in Mohammed Ibrahim v. State of Bihar, (2009) 8 SCC 751.
¶ 24Sections 463-465 (forgery), 468 (forgery for cheating), 471 (using forged document as genuine) and 420 IPC (cheating) require proof of their respective ingredients, including making, using or knowledge of forgery, inducement, and dishonest intent.
¶ 24Under s. 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, a confession to a police officer is inadmissible against the maker save for information leading to discovery.
¶ 26The prosecution bears the burden of proving every ingredient throughout, and the accused is presumed innocent.
¶ 22Provisions in the judgment · 13 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313Section 397Section 401Section 464
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 34Section 109Section 420Section 463Section 464Section 465Section 468Section 471
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 3
04Reasoning
The Court accepted the concurrent finding that Doc. No. 2648 of 1964 was not genuine.
¶ 17The conviction, however, rested on a single circumstance: A5's signature as attesting witness to two registered 2005 documents.
¶ 18The Court held that attestation of registered documents, absent other circumstances, at most creates suspicion and does not prove knowledge of forgery or agreement to commit an offence.
¶ 19The two deeds were consecutive links in one chain of title, and the attestation was equally consistent with an innocent explanation, such as acquaintance with the parties. No evidence showed prior acquaintance, meetings, knowledge of the family, receipt of consideration, or use of the forged document.
¶ 21The trial court's reasoning that A4, as A1's brother-in-law, would know of the other heirs did not extend to A5.
¶ 21The Court found an impermissible shift of burden: the lower courts faulted the defence for not showing A5 lacked a culpable mind, and the trial court placed on the defence the burden of proving the 1964 document genuine, which could not replace the prosecution's duty to connect A5 with the forgery.
¶ 22The Court also noted the 2005 documents were not formally marked, and the lower appellate court itself recorded uncertainty on this point, so the attestation was not properly proved.
¶ 23Since A5 had no role in the 1964 document, the substantive offences under ss. 465, 468, 471 and 420 IPC were not established, and no common intention under s. 34 IPC was shown.
¶ 23-24The Court relied on consistency with the acquittal of A3 in Crl.R.C. No. 1064 of 2017, which rested on the same evidence.
¶ 25The 2017 police statement was disregarded because it was recorded in a different crime, after conviction, while A5 was in custody, and no s. 27 discovery was shown.
¶ 2605Holding
The Court held that the prosecution failed to establish by legally admissible evidence that A5 was party to any criminal conspiracy or committed the offences under ss. 465, 468, 471 and 420 IPC. The conviction, resting on suspicion and an impermissible shift of the burden of proof, was perverse and legally erroneous.
¶ 27The Criminal Revision Case is allowed. The judgment of the Sessions Court in Crl.A. No. 125 of 2017, confirming the trial court's conviction in C.C. No. 233 of 2006, is set aside as to A5, and A5 is acquitted of all charges under ss. 465 r/w 120(B), 468 r/w 471 and 420 r/w 34 IPC. Any fine paid is to be refunded, bail bonds discharged, and the condition in the order dated 20.03.2020 vacated.
¶ 28Original Court PDF
QUIDBUDEENvsTHE STATE REP BY ITS,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
