01Facts
The complainant, an engineer running "Padmini Engineers," and the accused, his college mate, had a financial dealing.
¶ 3(i)–(ii)In 2004 the complainant met the accused's marriage expenses through his credit cards and personal loans, and an add-on card was issued to the accused.
¶ 3(i)–(ii)The complainant also raised funds for the accused's venture "India Projects." The accused undertook to repay, but did not.
¶ 3(i)–(ii)After a police complaint (12.10.2007), the accused issued two cheques (Nos. 893051 for Rs.13,44,505.73 and 893052 for Rs.7,00,000), both dishonoured.
¶ 3(ii)He then issued cheque No. 893053 dated 10.08.2009 for Rs.20,44,505.73.
¶ 3(ii)It was presented on 23.09.2009 and returned on 24.09.2009 with "Insufficient Funds."
¶ 3(iii) · Ex.P2A statutory notice dated 08.10.2009 (Ex.P3) was sent by registered post acknowledgement due, delivered on 10.10.2009 and received by one Rajeswari at the accused's residence (Ex.P4).
¶ 3(iii)No reply or payment followed, and the complaint was filed on 07.11.2009.
¶ 3(iii)The trial court (29.08.2017) convicted the accused under s.138 NI Act, imposing one year's simple imprisonment and compensation of Rs.40,89,011.46.
¶ 1The first appeal was dismissed on 24.07.2018, but this Court (Crl.R.C.No.590 of 2019, 28.06.2024) remanded it for want of hearing to the accused.
¶ 2On remand, the Principal Sessions Judge (03.12.2024) acquitted the accused, holding that service was not proved, the misuse defence was probable, and liability was not established.
¶ 2, 9The complainant appealed.
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the complainant complied with the proviso to s.138 NI Act, and whether the statutory notice (Ex.P3) was served on the accused in law.
¶ 15(i) · ¶ 20–23ii.2. Whether the accused rebutted the presumptions under ss.118 and 139 NI Act by raising a probable defence, and whether the Sessions Judge's contrary findings are perverse or contrary to law.
¶ 15(ii) · ¶ 24–29iii.3. Whether the order of acquittal is liable to be set aside and, if so, what sentence and compensation should follow.
¶ 15(iii) · ¶ 30–3103Law Applied
The Court applied s.138 NI Act and its provisos (presentation within validity, notice within 30 days, payment within 15 days), together with s.142(1)(b) on limitation.
¶ 17It applied ss.118(a) and 139 NI Act, which presume consideration and a legally enforceable debt, and which are rebuttable on a preponderance of probabilities, citing Rangappa v. Sri Mohan, (2010) 11 SCC 441, and Basalingappa v. Mudibasappa, (2019) 5 SCC 418; see also K.N. Beena v. Muniyappan, (2001) 8 SCC 458, para. 29.
¶ 18Under C.C. Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed, (2007) 6 SCC 555, posting a correctly addressed notice raises a presumption of service under s.27 General Clauses Act and s.114 Evidence Act, which the drawer must rebut.
¶ 20The Court applied Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415, holding that an appellate court may reappreciate evidence and interfere with acquittal where findings are perverse or based on misreading or disregard of material evidence.
¶ 16On compensation, it relied on R. Vijayan v. Baby, (2012) 1 SCC 260, treating compensation as compensatory and restitutive and requiring it to be practical and realistic.
¶ 30Provisions in the judgment · 15 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 419
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138Section 118Section 139Section 142Section 148Section 147
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 255Section 357Section 313Section 156
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 406Section 418Section 420
General Clauses Act, 1897 Section 27
04Reasoning
On service, the Court held that the Sessions Judge erred by disregarding the admitted address, and that the accused's own documents (Ex.D2 petition under s.156(3) CrPC and Ex.D3 FIR) identify Rajeswari as the wife of Kannan, the accused's father, residing at the same address.
¶ 21–22Nothing was put to PW1 in cross-examination or to the accused under s.313 CrPC questioning service, and the accused neither examined the postman nor rebutted the presumption.
¶ 22Applying Alavi Haji, the Court held that service was established.
¶ 20–23On rebuttal, the Court found the misuse defence improbable: no material supported it in cross-examination; no police complaint or stop-payment instruction was made; no explanation was given for leaving signed cheques with the complainant; the cheque was dated nearly two years after the alleged 2007 breakdown; the amount equalled the aggregate of the two earlier cheques; and no reply to the notice was sent.
¶ 25On liability, the Court relied on the unobjected-to e-mails (Ex.P9), which contained the accused's acknowledgement of dues, and on Exs.P5–P11 as corroboration.
¶ 26It held that the absence of books of account and of a specific ITR entry did not defeat the presumption, since the accused had not shown the complainant lacked financial capacity.
¶ 27The closure of the earlier FIR as a mistake of fact was not conclusive of the cheque liability, which is adjudicated independently.
¶ 28The Court found the Sessions Judge's contrary view erroneous and unsustainable.
¶ 29On sentence, given the period of deprivation and the accused's contest, it found the trial court's sentence and compensation neither excessive nor disproportionate.
¶ 3005Holding
The Court held that the statutory notice was served and the preconditions of s.138 were satisfied.
¶ 23It further held that the accused failed to raise a probable defence and that the complainant proved the offence beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 29The appeal is allowed. The acquittal dated 03.12.2024 in Crl.A. No. 277 of 2017 is set aside, and the conviction, one year's simple imprisonment, compensation of Rs.40,89,011.46, and three months' default sentence are confirmed.
¶ 32(i)–(ii)Any amount in deposit in C.C. No. 17 of 2010 shall not be refunded to the accused but shall be adjusted toward compensation and released to the complainant, with the balance payable by the accused.
¶ 31The trial court is directed to secure the accused to undergo the sentence, but may consider compounding under s.147 NI Act if he settles the matter acceptably to the complainant.
¶ 32(iii)The compensation is to be paid to the complainant, and the bail bond stands cancelled.
¶ 32(iv)Original Court PDF
R.Thanigai ArasuvsM.K.Balamurugan
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
