01Facts
The petitioner's father, Sh. Massa Singh, serving as Branch Manager of the Gramin Bank, Village Saidpur, District Amritsar, died in harness on 20.11.1990, leaving a widow and a minor son, the petitioner, who was about three years old.
¶ 2, 5Family pension was sanctioned to the mother, who remarried in 2003.
¶ 2The petitioner completed secondary education in 2005 and an Art and Craft course in 2007.
¶ 2He attained majority in 2005.
¶ 5He first sought compassionate appointment through representations dated 07.07.2020, 10.08.2020 and 17.08.2020, to which no response was received.
¶ 2, 5The respondents contended that the claim was barred by delay and laches, as it was made about 15 years after the petitioner attained majority.
¶ 3The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution directing consideration of his claim.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether a claim for compassionate appointment, made about 15 years after the petitioner attained majority and about 30 years after the employee's death, can be entertained.
¶ 5, 6, 13ii.2. Whether the petitioner's minority at the time of his father's death furnishes a valid explanation for the delay in seeking compassionate appointment.
¶ 1303Law Applied
Compassionate appointment is an exception to the general mode of recruitment, intended to provide immediate relief from financial crisis, and is not a vested right exercisable at any time.
¶ 6, 9, 10Under Chief Commissioner, Central Excise Customs v. Prabhat Singh (2013), a claim must be made within the period prescribed by the governing scheme, and delay defeats the object of the scheme.
¶ 6Jagdish Prasad v. State of Bihar (1996) holds that a dependant who attains majority long after the death cannot be appointed, as this would be an impermissible alternate mode of recruitment.
¶ 7Bijender Singh v. State of Haryana (1999, Division Bench) holds that a minor dependant cannot claim appointment as of right on attaining majority, and a long gap between death and application indicates the family was not in dire need.
¶ 8Debabrata Tiwari holds that a claim may not be entertained after a considerable lapse of time, since the sense of immediacy is lost and the family may have stabilised.
¶ 10Gurbhinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2025, Coordinate Bench) applies these principles and treats the financial condition of the family at the time of death as the primary consideration.
¶ 11Parwati Devi v. Director (G) (Raj. HC) follows Punjab State Power Corporation v. Nirval Singh and P. Venkatesh in holding that delay mitigates against such claims and that successive re-consideration orders cannot cure initial delay.
¶ 1204Reasoning
The object of compassionate appointment is to relieve immediate hardship following the breadwinner's death.
¶ 13The petitioner's minority at the time of death did not itself entitle him to relief, because he could have applied upon attaining majority in 2005 but first applied in 2020, after an inordinate and unexplained delay of about 15 years.
¶ 5, 6, 13The claim, therefore, could not be treated as a right, and by the time of the application the immediacy of the crisis had ceased to exist.
¶ 13The petitioner also offered no satisfactory explanation for the delay.
¶ 13Following Prabhat Singh and Debabrata Tiwari, the Court held that entertaining such a claim would convert compassionate appointment into a matter of inheritance, contrary to the constitutional requirement of appointment through a merit-based process.
¶ 6, 10, 13The Court declined to exercise sympathy or discretion beyond the prescribed norms.
¶ 605Holding
1. A claim made about 15 years after attaining majority, without satisfactory explanation, cannot be entertained.
¶ 132. The petitioner's minority does not excuse the delay.
¶ 13The writ petition was dismissed on the ground of delay and laches, with no order as to costs, and the Court found no ground to direct consideration of the claim at this belated stage.
¶ 14Original Court PDF
Amandip SinghvsGramin Bank And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
