01Facts
The petitioner was engaged as a Peon on daily wages at the Jaspal Bangar branch of Punjab and Sind Bank from 06.08.1997 and later worked at the Gill Road, Ludhiana branch, until his services were terminated with effect from 24.08.2002 without notice or retrenchment compensation.
¶ 2He raised an industrial dispute by a demand notice dated 17.03.2003, and the Government referred the dispute under Section 10(1)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (the "Act") as I.D. No. 715 of 2005.
¶ 2The Bank contended that the engagement was not made in accordance with procedure, was need-based and not against a sanctioned post, and that no Peon post existed.
¶ 3The Tribunal held that the petitioner had neither pleaded nor proved 240 days of actual work in the twelve months preceding termination under Section 25-B, noting the management's evidence of intermittent engagement at different branches, and answered the reference against him by award dated 28.12.2012.
¶ 4The petitioner's cross-examination showed daily-wage payment for periods of two to five days, and his application for production of attendance and payment records was met with the management's statement that old records were not readily available, together with tabulated particulars of service.
¶ 11The petitioner challenged the award under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner established, under Section 25-B of the Act, that he had rendered 240 days of actual work in the twelve calendar months preceding his termination on 24.08.2002.
¶ 4, 10–13ii.2. Whether the termination was in violation of Section 25-F of the Act for want of notice and retrenchment compensation.
¶ 14iii.3. Whether the termination violated Section 25-G of the Act (retention of junior employees).
¶ 15iv.4. Whether the question of re-employment under Section 25-H fell within the scope of the reference.
¶ 16v.5. Whether the findings of the Tribunal warrant interference in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 9, 1703Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 25-B of the Act, under which a workman must have actually worked for 240 days in the twelve calendar months preceding termination to attract the protection of Section 25-F.
¶ 4, 14It applied Section 25-F (notice and retrenchment compensation), Section 25-G (retention of juniors, requiring evidence that a junior was retained), and Section 25-H (re-employment) as framed in the reference.
¶ 14–16It relied on Surendranagar District Panchayat v. Dahyabhai Amarsinh, (2005) 8 SCC 750, which holds that the burden of proving 240 days of actual work lies on the workman, must be discharged by cogent evidence rather than a self-serving statement, and that non-production of muster rolls does not automatically warrant an adverse inference against the employer.
¶ 8Under Articles 226 and 227, the Court does not ordinarily interfere with findings of fact merely because another view is possible, but interferes where findings are perverse, based on no evidence, or suffer from patent error of law or jurisdictional infirmity.
¶ 9Provisions in the judgment · 6
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Section 10Section 25Section 25Section 25FSection 25GSection 25H
04Reasoning
The Court first held that the bare assertion of engagement over several years does not establish the 240-day requirement for the specific twelve-month period before 24.08.2002.
¶ 10The cross-examination evidence of intermittent daily-wage work, combined with the management's tabulated service particulars, supported the Tribunal's finding that the petitioner had not discharged his burden.
¶ 11The petitioner's request for production of records and the non-production of the entire record did not relieve him of his initial burden, since his oral assertion lacked supporting material.
¶ 12Because the Tribunal's finding on the absence of 240 days was not perverse, the petitioner could not invoke Section 25-F, and the non-compliance challenge failed.
¶ 13–14On Section 25-G, the absence of evidence that any junior was retained meant no violation was established.
¶ 15The Court also upheld the Tribunal's view that Section 25-H re-employment was outside the scope of a reference confined to the legality of termination.
¶ 16Since no perversity, illegality, or jurisdictional error was shown, the Court declined to re-appreciate the evidence.
¶ 9, 1705Holding
The Court answered the issues against the petitioner: he failed to prove 240 days of actual work under Section 25-B, so Section 25-F protection was not attracted; no violation of Section 25-G was established; and Section 25-H was beyond the reference.
¶ 13–16The Tribunal's findings were neither perverse nor contrary to the record, and no interference was warranted under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 17The impugned award dated 28.12.2012 was upheld and the writ petition was dismissed, with pending miscellaneous applications disposed of.
¶ 18–19The petitioner's prayers for reinstatement, continuity of service, and back wages were therefore refused.
¶ 5, 18Original Court PDF
Gurdeep SinghvsP.O. & Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
