01Facts
The petitioner was allegedly engaged as a Beldar-cum-Mali in Charkhi Dadri Range from 22.10.1994 to 25.12.2017, when her services were terminated without notice or retrenchment compensation.
¶ 2She claimed more than 240 days of service in the preceding twelve months and alleged that junior persons were retained, in breach of Sections 25-F, 25-G and 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
¶ 2After a demand notice under Section 2-A, failed conciliation, and reference, the Labour Court (Hisar) registered Reference No. 33 of 2018.
¶ 2–3The management denied any employer-employee relationship, pleaded that old records had been weeded out, and stated that no sanctioned post of Beldar-cum-Mali existed.
¶ 2The petitioner relied on muster roll cards Ex.W1 to Ex.W11. The Labour Court found that none bore a muster roll number, some lacked signatures or departmental stamps, and the cards did not substantiate the alleged work under named Forest Guards.
¶ 8Summoned departmental records, produced and inspected by the petitioner's representative, did not reflect her name. The attendance register was stated not to have been maintained.
¶ 9The Labour Court dismissed the claim, and the petitioner challenged the award dated 23.12.2022 under Articles 226/227.
¶ 1, 302Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner established the foundational facts of employment and qualifying service (240 days under Section 25-B) necessary to invoke protection under Section 25-F of the Act.
¶ 7ii.2. Whether the non-production of muster rolls, wage registers and attendance records by the management warranted an adverse inference against it.
¶ 4, 10iii.3. Whether the alleged retention of juniors and engagement of fresh persons established violation of Sections 25-G and 25-H.
¶ 4, 11iv.4. Whether the Labour Court's award is vitiated by perversity, patent illegality or jurisdictional error, warranting interference under Articles 226/227.
¶ 13–1503Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which requires notice and retrenchment compensation before retrenchment, and held that its protection is available only where the workman first proves employment and the qualifying continuous service under Section 25-B.
¶ 7The Court applied Range Forest Officer v. S.T. Hadimani, (2002) 3 SCC 25, for the principle that a workman's bare statement or affidavit is insufficient to prove 240 days of service, and that the claim must rest on evidence actually on record.
¶ 7Sections 25-G and 25-H were treated as dependent on the foundational proof of employment, and allegations of junior retention must be substantiated by particulars.
¶ 11The management's duty to produce relevant records does not automatically yield an adverse inference; the inference depends on the nature of the records, the explanation offered, and the other evidence.
¶ 10Under Articles 226/227, the High Court does not sit as an appellate court and interferes only where findings are perverse, based on no evidence, contrary to the record, or vitiated by patent illegality or jurisdictional error.
¶ 13Provisions in the judgment · 5
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Section 25FSection 25GSection 25HSection 2ASection 25
04Reasoning
The petitioner's foundational case failed because her muster roll cards lacked muster roll numbers, authentication, and consistent signatures, and did not link her to the named Forest Guards.
¶ 8This evidentiary gap was reinforced by the departmental record, which did not reflect her name even though the petitioner's own representative inspected it.
¶ 9On the production issue, the management had explained the weeding of old records and the non-maintenance of the attendance register, and the Labour Court considered this explanation. The Court held that this did not justify an adverse inference, since no specific record was shown to have been wrongly disbelieved or ignored.
¶ 10The allegations under Sections 25-G and 25-H failed because no junior's name or replacement particulars were given.
¶ 11Because employment and 240 days of service were not proved, the Section 25-F claim necessarily failed; non-issuance of notice or compensation could not by itself confer reinstatement rights.
¶ 12Measured against the writ standard, the Court found the Labour Court's appreciation neither perverse nor based on misreading, and the petitioner's contrary view of the evidence did not establish a jurisdictional error.
¶ 13–1405Holding
The petitioner failed to establish employment and the qualifying service required to invoke Section 25-F; no adverse inference arose against the management on non-production of records; the Sections 25-G/25-H allegations were unsubstantiated; and the award was free from perversity or jurisdictional infirmity.
¶ 7–8, 10–12, 14–15The writ petition was dismissed, and the Labour Court's award dated 23.12.2022 (declining reinstatement, continuity of service and back wages) was upheld. Pending civil miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 16–17Original Court PDF
Usha RanivsState Of Haryana And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
