01Facts
The petitioner, a Lecturer in Physiology in a State medical college, sought a writ of mandamus under Articles 226/227 directing his re-designation as Senior Lecturer (now Assistant Professor) and placement in the corresponding pay scale with effect from 14.11.2006
¶ 1He relied on State instructions dated 26.08.1991 (Annexure P-5), which sanctioned 15 Senior Lecturer posts in medical specialities and extended Senior Lecturer scale to doctors holding post-graduation in their specialities, subject to a condition that such re-designation confers no seniority over Lecturers senior to them
¶ 2The petitioner stated that the same instructions were applied to a co-employee, Dr. Aditya Jain, in the same Physiology Department, by order dated 11.06.2015
¶ 3The Director, Research and Medical Education, Punjab, recommended the petitioner's re-designation (Annexures P-16 and P-17), but no decision followed
¶ 4 · ¶ 11The State opposed the petition, contending that the matter was not one of re-designation. It argued that the service is governed by the Punjab Medical Education State Service (Class-II) Rules, 1979 ("Rules of 1979"), under which Appendix-B lists only "Lecturer" for Physiology, with no Senior Lecturer post
¶ 5 · ¶ 7The State relied on the proviso to Rule 4 reserving the Government's power to create posts, and on the differing qualifications (Rule 9, Appendix-C) and pay scales (Rule 13, Appendix-D) for Lecturers and Senior Lecturers
¶ 6 · ¶ 8–902Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner can be re-designated as Senior Lecturer (Physiology) and granted the corresponding pay scale, despite the absence of that category in Appendix-B of the Rules of 1979
¶ 5, 7, 8, 10ii.2. Whether the denial of the relief, when the same benefit was extended to a similarly situated co-employee and the Director had recommended it, amounts to discriminatory treatment
¶ 11iii.3. Whether the writ court should itself grant the relief or direct the competent authority to decide the petitioner's claim afresh
¶ 11–1203Law Applied
Rule 4 of the Rules of 1979 confines the service to the posts in Appendix-B, subject to a proviso preserving the Government's inherent power to add, reduce, or create posts with different designations and pay scales, permanently or temporarily
¶ 6Rules 9 (with Appendix-C) and 13 (with Appendix-D) distinguish Lecturers from Senior Lecturers in qualifications and pay
¶ 8–9 · ¶ 11The State instructions of 26.08.1991 are treated as an executive measure operating de hors the Rules, enabling re-designation of post-graduate doctors as Senior Lecturers with pay scale benefits but without seniority rights over senior Lecturers
¶ 11Similarly situated employees must not be treated differently without a plausible reason, which is reflected in the court's reasoning on discrimination, though no Article 14 authority is cited
¶ 1104Reasoning
The court rejected the State's central contention that no Senior Lecturer post exists in Physiology. It reasoned that the 1991 instructions, issued under executive power to encourage post-graduate doctors, operate independently of the Rules of 1979 and expressly contemplate re-designation with a seniority rider
¶ 11The court relied on the fact that the same instructions had already been applied to Dr. Aditya Jain in the same department, which undercut the State's rule-based objection
¶ 11The court gave weight to the Director's specific recommendation under Annexures P-16 and P-17, which the State had not met
¶ 4, 11Since the State offered no plausible reason for treating the petitioner differently from his co-employee, the court found the non-decision prima facie discriminatory and unreasoned
¶ 11The court did not finally adjudicate the merits of the re-designation claim or the pay scale entitlement. Instead, it left those determinations to the competent authority, which must weigh the 1991 instructions, the Aditya Jain precedent, and the Director's recommendation in a reasoned decision after hearing the petitioner
¶ 1105Holding
The court did not finally decide whether re-designation is legally available. It held that the State's "no such post" objection cannot defeat the claim at this stage, given the 1991 instructions, the parity with Dr. Aditya Jain, and the Director's recommendation, and that no plausible reason justified the differential treatment
¶ 11The writ petition was disposed of with a direction to Respondent No. 1 to decide the petitioner's case afresh by a reasoned and speaking order, after affording him a hearing, within six weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order
¶ 11–12The petitioner retains liberty to challenge the speaking order in accordance with law
¶ 13COCP-434-2022 was disposed of in the same terms
¶ 14Original Court PDF
Iqbal SinghvsState Of Punjab & Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
