Punjab and Haryana High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Writ court will not disturb a Tribunal's factual finding of transfer over termination absent perversity or no evidence.

Dharampalv.Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda And Others

Writ court will not disturb a Tribunal's factual finding of transfer over termination absent perversity or no evidence.. Dharampal vs Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the petitioner's services were terminated on 01.03.2013 or whether he was validly transferred to another place of deployment, such that the Tribunal's finding of transfer is sustainable.

The court held

The Tribunal's finding that the petitioner was transferred, not terminated, is a sustainable finding of fact, and the failure to prove actual service of the transfer letter does not by itself make the award perverse.

It also directed

The Section 25-F claim could not arise without a termination.

Finding no perversity, jurisdictional error, or patent error of law, the Court held that no ground for interference was made out, dismissed the writ petition, and disposed of pending applications. The award dated 20.02.2025 in Reference No. 62 of 2017 stands.

01Facts

The petitioner was engaged as a Packing Helper on 11.10.2010 through respondent No. 4, a manpower contractor, and deployed at the establishment of respondent Nos. 2 and 3.

¶ 2

He claimed continuous service until 01.03.2013 at Rs. 7,500 per month and alleged that his services were terminated that day without notice, enquiry, or retrenchment compensation.

¶ 2

After conciliation failed, the dispute was referred to the Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda, as Reference No. 62 of 2017.

¶ 2

The management pleaded that, due to surplus manpower, 75 workers, including the petitioner, were transferred to M/s Lumex Industry Limited, Dharuhera, Rewari, by communication dated 01.03.2013, with a joining date of 08.03.2013, and that the petitioner did not join.

¶ 2

The Tribunal, relying on the appointment letter's transfer clause (Clause 10), the transfer list (Ex. M-1), postal material, and the petitioner's own affidavit (Ex. W-1/A), answered the reference against the workman by award dated 20.02.2025.

¶ 3, 10–13

The management witness admitted in cross-examination that registered letters had been received back and no newspaper publication followed.

¶ 4, 12

The affidavit refers to a transfer communication dated 21.03.2013.

¶ 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the petitioner's services were terminated on 01.03.2013 or whether he was validly transferred to another place of deployment, such that the Tribunal's finding of transfer is sustainable.

¶ 9

ii.2. Whether the non-proof of actual service of the transfer communication renders the Tribunal's award perverse or amenable to interference under Articles 226/227.

¶ 12, 17

iii.3. Whether non-compliance with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, arising from 240+ days of service and non-payment of compensation, independently vitiates the award.

¶ 5, 14

03Law Applied

Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution: the Court does not sit as an appellate court over Industrial Tribunal findings and interferes only where a finding is based on no evidence, is perverse, suffers from a patent error of law or jurisdiction, or ignores material evidence; a mere possibility of a different view is insufficient.

¶ 15

Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which requires notice and retrenchment compensation for retrenchment, applies only where a termination is established; completion of 240 days alone does not establish retrenchment.

¶ 14

Whether a transfer or a termination occurred is a question of fact, to be decided on an overall appreciation of the evidence, including the contractual transfer clause and the workman's own evidence.

¶ 11, 13, 18

Provisions in the judgment · 2

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Section 2ASection 25F

04Reasoning

The Court first identified the foundational question as whether there was a termination or a transfer.

¶ 9

The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the appointment letter's transfer clause, the list of 75 transferred workers, the transfer communication, postal material, and both oral and documentary evidence.

¶ 16

The Court accepted the petitioner's argument that actual service of the transfer letter was not conclusively proved, since the management witness conceded that registered letters were returned unclaimed and no publication was made.

¶ 12

The Court held that this gap did not render the award perverse, because the Tribunal weighed it alongside the petitioner's own affidavit, which referred to the Rewari transfer, and his failure to produce any document showing termination by respondent No. 4.

¶ 13, 17

Because the transfer finding stood, the Section 25-F claim fell away, as no retrenchment occurred.

¶ 14

The Court held that these were findings of fact supported by evidence, and that the petitioner's challenge sought a re-appreciation of evidence, which is beyond writ jurisdiction.

¶ 15, 18

05Holding

The Tribunal's finding that the petitioner was transferred, not terminated, is a sustainable finding of fact, and the failure to prove actual service of the transfer letter does not by itself make the award perverse.

¶ 17–18

The Section 25-F claim could not arise without a termination.

¶ 14

Finding no perversity, jurisdictional error, or patent error of law, the Court held that no ground for interference was made out, dismissed the writ petition, and disposed of pending applications. The award dated 20.02.2025 in Reference No. 62 of 2017 stands.

¶ 18–21
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

DharampalvsPresiding Officer Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment