01Facts
The petitioner’s grandmother had received Site No. 374 in Banashankari 3rd Stage as an alternate site in lieu of her site, which was acquired.
pp. 2–6After paying part of the sital value, she failed to pay the balance within the prescribed time, and the allotment was cancelled.
pp. 2–6In 2014, the BDA approved transfer of the allotment to the petitioner, subject to conditions, but the allotted site had already been allotted to another person.
pp. 2–6The petitioner sought an alternate site and, after an earlier writ petition directed the BDA to consider her representation, the BDA rejected her request, citing non-payment and Rule 13 of the Bangalore Development Authority (Allotment of Sites) Rules, 1984.
pp. 2–6She challenged that rejection and sought allotment of an alternate site.
pp. 2–602Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner’s claim to an alternate site, arising from an allotment made in lieu of acquisition, could be treated like an application for allotment under the Bangalore Development Authority (Allotment of Sites) Rules, 1984.
pp. 6–9ii.2. Whether the BDA could reject the petitioner’s request solely because the balance sital value had not been paid within the stipulated time, or whether it could instead require payment with interest and allot an alternate site.
pp. 7–1003Law Applied
Rule 13 of the Bangalore Development Authority (Allotment of Sites) Rules, 1984 was relied on by the BDA in rejecting the request; the Court held that the petitioner’s claim, founded on an alternate allotment made in lieu of acquisition, was distinguishable from an ordinary application for allotment under those Rules.
pp. 6–9The Court also considered The Commissioner, Bengaluru Development Authority v. T. Seetharamappa (Dead) Through LRs., SLP (C) Nos. 13871–13872/2021, concerning the obligation of ordinary allottees to pay the allotment price within the prescribed period, and distinguished it on the facts.
pp. 6–904Reasoning
The BDA did not dispute that the original allotment to the petitioner’s grandmother was made in lieu of acquisition of her site.
pp. 8–9The Court therefore found that the petitioner could not be equated with an applicant seeking a site under the 1984 Rules.
pp. 8–9Although the balance sital value remained unpaid, the BDA could be compensated by requiring payment with interest.
pp. 8–9The Court also observed that the value of the acquired site would have increased, and rejected the BDA’s reliance on T. Seetharamappa because that case concerned applicants under the 1984 Rules, not an allotment made in lieu of acquisition.
pp. 8–905Holding
The Court allowed the petition and quashed the BDA’s letter dated 1 March 2023.
pp. 9–10It directed the BDA to allot the petitioner an alternate site in Banashankari VI Stage or another layout, upon payment of Rs. 5,000 with interest at 12% per annum from 1 May 1985 until payment.
pp. 9–10The direction was to be complied with within three months of receipt of the order.
pp. 9–10Original Court PDF
SMT. G. RAJESHWARIvsTHE COMMISSIONER
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
