01Facts
The petitioners claimed ownership and possession of land in Sy. No. 104A/1, Virapur Village, within Bagalkot municipal limits.
pp. 8–10They had constructed and operated a Kalyana Mantapa on the land from 2014–15 without obtaining conversion of the land, a sanctioned building plan, or the required licence.
pp. 8–10Their application for regularisation remained unconsidered while a challenge to the relevant regularisation legislation was pending.
pp. 8–10Following a complaint, the Deputy Commissioner declined regularisation, and HESCOM disconnected the power supply.
pp. 8–10The petitioners also challenged an order concerning their conversion application.
pp. 8–10They relied on the land’s designation as commercial in the Master Plan and on a pending regular appeal concerning an alleged encroachment; the Court made any consideration of their request subject to the outcome of that appeal.
pp. 8–10, 12–17, 21–2202Issues
i.1. Whether the Deputy Commissioner’s refusal to consider regularisation and the related impugned communications should be quashed, with the petitioners’ applications reconsidered under the applicable land-revenue provisions.
pp. 10, 13–14, 17–22ii.2. Whether the petitioners could continue using the Kalyana Mantapa, and whether HESCOM should restore its power supply pending the required permissions and compliance.
pp. 10, 14–15, 21–2203Law Applied
Section 94 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 governs the requirement for permission to divert agricultural land to non-agricultural use; Section 96(4) provides for compounding diversion on payment of the prescribed amount.
pp. 17–19The Court relied on Aleemuddin S/o Qayyum Patel v. State of Karnataka, W.P. No. 226174/2020 (30 July 2020), which directed consideration of post-construction conversion and building regularisation, subject to the applicable Master Plan, payment of charges, obtaining approvals and restrictions on use pending compliance; the Court noted that the decision had attained finality.
pp. 17–19It also applied the proportionality reasoning in K. Raheja Corp. Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, particularly the proposition that demolition is not invariably justified where its consequences would be disproportionate to the public interest served.
pp. 20–21The Court distinguished the authorities cited against the petitioners as concerning violations in urban areas and buildings used or constructed contrary to the purpose for which the plots were permitted.
pp. 19–20Provisions in the judgment · 2
Land Revenue Act, 1964 Section 96Section 94
04Reasoning
The Court accepted that the construction was unauthorised because the petitioners had obtained neither land-use conversion nor building permission.
pp. 17–18However, it considered the location and circumstances: the hall stood on a larger parcel without adjacent construction, the area was described as semi-urban, the Master Plan designated the land for commercial use, and the building had existed for over ten years.
p. 17, 20In light of Aleemuddin and the proportionality reasoning in K. Raheja, the Court concluded that the petitioners’ applications should be considered under Section 96(4) read with Section 94, rather than refusing consideration outright.
pp. 18–22This did not confer a right to operate the building: required permissions and compliance remained necessary, and consideration was subject to the pending regular appeal concerning the alleged encroachment.
pp. 18–2205Holding
The Court allowed all three writ petitions and quashed the impugned communications and endorsements.
pp. 21–22It directed the Deputy Commissioner to consider the petitioners’ regularisation applications under Sections 96(4) and 94 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, having regard to Aleemuddin and the commercial zoning, and to pass necessary orders within 90 days of receiving the certified order.
pp. 21–22The petitioners may thereafter seek the necessary approvals from the Development Authority and Municipal Council.
pp. 21–22The consideration is subject to the outcome of R.A. No. 67/2019, and the petitioners must not use the building until they obtain the required permissions and comply with the authorities’ requirements.
pp. 21–22HESCOM was directed to provide power supply, subject to payment of applicable consumption charges, arrears and deposit.
pp. 21–22Original Court PDF
SHRINIVAS S/O. KRISHNAJI MANAGOLIvsTHE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
