01Facts
The applicant's father, a Beldar in the Executive Engineer's office, President's Estate Circle, CPWD, Rashtrapati Bhavan, died in harness on 4 January 2009 after about ten years of service.
¶ 1The applicant applied for compassionate appointment on 27 February 2009.
¶ 2The wife's application dated 21 May 2009 was also taken cognizance of, but the request was rejected in 2017 because the applicant did not secure the requisite weightage points.
¶ 2The applicant's challenge in O.A. No. 1002/2018 was dismissed by a Coordinate Bench on 24 September 2019, the Tribunal declining to interfere with the respondents' weightage assessment.
¶ 3, 8In 2023 the respondents notified vacancies for compassionate appointment. The applicant applied but was not selected, having secured lower weightage than selected candidates.
¶ 4An RTI reply dated 2 April 2024 stated that the respondents had applied the DoP&T O.M. dated 9 October 1998.
¶ 5The applicant contends that the respondents in fact applied the weightage criteria of the subsequent DoP&T O.M. dated 6 August 2018.
¶ 6The applicant also states that two later-deceased employees (Smt. Geeta Bharti and Smt. Indravati) were appointed as Beldars under the compassionate scheme.
¶ 22The applicant sought appointment with consequential benefits and compensation.
¶ 4The respondents contended that the earlier Coordinate Bench decision was final and that res judicata applies.
¶ 11–13The respondents relied on para. 8 of the 1998 O.M. regarding belated requests and on Smriti Verma v. State of Chhattisgarh (Chh. HC).
¶ 14, 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the respondents were required to assess the applicant's claim for compassionate appointment under the DoP&T O.M. dated 9 October 1998, the scheme in force on the date of the employee's death, and not under the subsequent DoP&T O.M. dated 6 August 2018.
¶ 5–7, 19–20ii.2. Whether the applicant's fresh claim, arising from the 2023 vacancies, is barred by res judicata or by the earlier dismissal of O.A. No. 1002/2018.
¶ 12–13, 22iii.3. Whether the belated nature of the request, under para. 8 of the 1998 O.M., precludes consideration of the applicant's claim.
¶ 14, 17–1803Law Applied
The settled principle, as reflected in the judgments cited by the applicant, is that the scheme in force on the date of the government servant's death governs compassionate appointment, and not a later scheme.
¶ 20Malaya Nanda Shetty v. State of Orissa, AIR 2022 SC 2836, as cited in the order.
¶ 10(i), 20Indian Bank v. Promila, (2020) 2 SCC 729, as cited in the order.
¶ 10(ii), 20State of M.P. v. Amit Shrivas, (2020) 10 SCC 496, as cited in the order.
¶ 10(iii), 20State of M.P. v. Ashish Awasthi, as cited in the order.
¶ 10(iv)Together these authorities establish that a claim must be decided under the relevant scheme prevalent on the date of demise and that subsequent schemes cannot be applied.
¶ 10(i)–(iv), 20Para. 8 of the DoP&T O.M. dated 9 October 1998 states that compassionate appointment is intended to give immediate succour to the bereaved family, and that belated requests require circumspection.
¶ 14, 17Judicial review of compassionate appointment is confined to whether the applicable rules were correctly applied, while the executive assesses the family's financial condition.
¶ 1904Reasoning
The Tribunal held that the respondents' own RTI reply admitted applying the 1998 O.M., whereas the rejection in fact rested on weightage yardsticks from the 2018 O.M.
¶ 19Applying Indian Bank v. Promila and Amit Shrivas, the Tribunal reasoned that the respondents could not rely on a later scheme that was not applicable at the relevant time, namely the employee's death in 2009.
¶ 20The Tribunal distinguished Smriti Verma, where the petitioner, a minor, had delayed for about 15 years. Here, the family applied immediately, in February 2009, and the delay was administrative.
¶ 18, 21On the belatedness objection, the Tribunal accepted the immediate-succour rationale of para. 8 but found that the applicant's prompt application negated any belatedness.
¶ 17–18On res judicata, the applicant argued that the 2023 vacancy gave rise to a fresh cause of action and that other similarly placed candidates had been appointed. The order records these submissions but does not expressly decide the res judicata plea.
¶ 22The Tribunal proceeded to remit the matter for fresh consideration under the correct scheme.
¶ 2305Holding
The Tribunal held that the respondents erred in assessing the applicant's claim under the subsequent DoP&T O.M. dated 6 August 2018, having admitted in the RTI reply that the 1998 O.M. applied.
¶ 19–20The Tribunal did not decide the res judicata issue expressly.
¶ 22The Tribunal disposed of the O.A. by directing the respondents to reconsider the applicant's case by applying the yardsticks of the DoP&T O.M. dated 9 October 1998, within twelve weeks of receipt of a certified copy of the order.
¶ 23The prayers for appointment from a later date, consequential benefits, and compensation were not granted. There was no order as to costs.
¶ 24Original Court PDF
DEVESH KUMARvsHOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![CAT Orders Fresh Look at Beldar's Son's Compassionate Job Plea, Finds Govt Applied 2018 Policy Not 1998 Rules. DEVESH KUMAR vs HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/cat-orders-fresh-look-at-beldar-s-son-s-compassionate-job-plea-finds-govt-applied-2018-pol-2f3a0a1cc6f74074b11a4d896301f9e4.webp)