CAT - ['Delhi']Administrative and Public LawSocial Security and Pensions

CAT Quashes Charge Memo Against Retired CPWD Engineer: Presidential Sanction Did Not Name Inquiry Authority

SATYAJIT MANDALv.HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS

CAT Quashes Charge Memo Against Retired CPWD Engineer: Presidential Sanction Did Not Name Inquiry Authority. SATYAJIT MANDAL vs HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the sanction dated 27.08.2025 and the Memorandum of Charge dated 27.08.2025, which do not name the authority to conduct the departmental proceedings against a retired government servant, comply with Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021 and Formats 2 and 3.

The court held

The sanction and Memorandum dated 27.08.2025 are not in conformity with Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) and Formats 2 and 3 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, because they fail to name the authority conducting the inquiry, and are therefore unsustainable in law.

It also directed

The O.A. was allowed. The Tribunal set aside the impugned sanction and Memorandum, directed the respondents to grant the applicant consequential benefits per the rules within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy, and granted liberty to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with the relevant rules and law. No order as to costs was made, and M.A. No. 2498/2026 was disposed of.

01Facts

The applicant joined the office of respondent No. 2 (CPWD) as a Junior Engineer (Electrical) in 1984, later served as Executive Engineer (Electrical), and retired on 31.08.2021.

¶ 2

On 05.06.2025, the Vigilance Unit called upon the applicant to explain alleged lapses in executing work under Agreement No. 11/E/CBMB M-33/2020-2021. He replied on 24.06.2025 and filed a supplementary reply on 10.07.2025.

¶ 3

On 27.08.2025, the President sanctioned departmental proceedings, and a Memorandum of Charge of the same date was issued.

¶ 4 · ¶ 14

The sanction stated that the applicant, while serving as Executive Engineer (E), DHC&ND, PWD Delhi, committed irregularities in execution of work beyond the yardstick and proposed extra items. It directed that proceedings be conducted under CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, Rules 14 and 15, "at New Delhi," without naming any authority to conduct them.

¶ 15

The Memorandum likewise specified only the place of inquiry, New Delhi, and no inquiring authority.

¶ 14

The applicant challenged the Memorandum and sanction, seeking their quashing and consequential benefits.

¶ 5

The applicant contended that the sanction omitted the disciplinary authority and place of inquiry required by Rule 8(2)(c)(iii) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021.

¶ 7

The respondents argued that the sanction stated proceedings would follow Rule 14(5) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, which was sufficient compliance.

¶ 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the sanction dated 27.08.2025 and the Memorandum of Charge dated 27.08.2025, which do not name the authority to conduct the departmental proceedings against a retired government servant, comply with Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021 and Formats 2 and 3.

¶ 10–12 · ¶ 16

ii.2. Whether a reference in the sanction to the procedure under Rules 14 and 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 cures the omission of the authority's identity and whether non-compliance causes prejudice warranting interference.

¶ 21–22

03Law Applied

Rule 8(2)(c) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021 permits institution of proceedings against a retired servant only with the President's sanction in Format 2, and requires the proceedings to be conducted by the authority and place the President directs, with a memorandum in Format 3.

¶ 10–12

Formats 2 and 3 expressly require specification of the authority conducting the inquiry and the place of inquiry.

¶ 13

Statutory pension rules framed under Article 309 must be strictly followed, and non-compliance renders the action void, as held in Sunirmal Sarkar v. Union of India (2023 SCC OnLine Cal 3702).

¶ 17

Post-retirement proceedings are liable to be quashed for failure to follow the prescribed sanction format, and delegation not validly made cannot be relied upon, as held in Harish Chander Pal v. ESIC (O.A. No. 2465/2021, decided 05.12.2025).

¶ 18

Where a statute prescribes a manner of doing an act, it must be done in that manner or not at all, as held in A.R. Antulay v. Ramdas Sriniwas Nayak (1984) 2 SCC 500.

¶ 19

The applicant's cited authorities, Sunny Abraham v. Union of India (2021) 20 SCC 12 and Union of India v. Ritu Chaudhary (2019 SCC OnLine Del 12063), were recited in the parties' submissions.

¶ 7

04Reasoning

The Tribunal compared the impugned sanction and Memorandum with the prescribed Formats 2 and 3 and found that neither identified the authority conducting the inquiry, as required by Rule 8(2)(c)(iii).

¶ 14–16, 20

The sanction specified only the place, "New Delhi," and the Memorandum followed the same defect.

¶ 14–15

The respondents' reliance on the general reference to Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules was rejected because Rule 8 prescribes a specific procedure for retired servants, and the Presidential sanction invoked that provision and therefore had to comply with it.

¶ 21–22

The absence of prejudice to the applicant was not a sufficient answer, because the defect went to the validity of the statutory process itself, not to the merits.

¶ 21–22

Applying Sunirmal Sarkar, Harish Chander Pal, and Antulay, the Tribunal concluded that the sanction was not issued in the manner the statute mandates.

¶ 17–20

05Holding

The sanction and Memorandum dated 27.08.2025 are not in conformity with Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) and Formats 2 and 3 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, because they fail to name the authority conducting the inquiry, and are therefore unsustainable in law.

¶ 16, 20, 22

The O.A. was allowed. The Tribunal set aside the impugned sanction and Memorandum, directed the respondents to grant the applicant consequential benefits per the rules within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy, and granted liberty to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with the relevant rules and law. No order as to costs was made, and M.A. No. 2498/2026 was disposed of.

¶ 23(i)–(iv) · ¶ 24–25
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

SATYAJIT MANDALvsHOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS

CAT - ['Delhi'] · October 28, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment