CAT - ['Delhi']Administrative and Public LawHealth and Medical Law

Retired NBPGR Staff Lose CGHS Cover While Serving Colleagues Keep It; CAT Asks Ministries To Decide In 90 Days

ANIL KUMAR AGARWALv.HEALTH

Retired NBPGR Staff Lose CGHS Cover While Serving Colleagues Keep It; CAT Asks Ministries To Decide In 90 Days. ANIL KUMAR AGARWAL vs HEALTH. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the withdrawal of CGHS facilities from retired NBPGR employees, while serving NBPGR employees retain them, constitutes an artificial and unjustified distinction.

The court held

The Tribunal held prima facie that the distinction between serving and retired NBPGR employees, and between Delhi and non-Delhi ICAR institutions, appears artificial and is not supported by any rational justification.

It also directed

The Tribunal did not finally determine the merits or grant the applicants' specific reliefs (restoration, medical allowance reimbursement, or interim consultation).

The OA was disposed of with directions that the Secretaries of MoHFW and DARE hold a joint meeting, examine practice for ICAR institutions in other cities and the basis for it, and adopt a uniform policy consistent with the 2014 OM and non-arbitrariness, and that respondents take a final decision within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy of the order, in line with the observations at paras. 8.3–8.6.

No order as to costs was made, and pending MAs stand disposed of.

01Facts

The applicants are retired employees of the National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR), New Delhi, a constituent unit of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).

¶ 2

By OM dated 20.10.1982, the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (MoHFW) extended CGHS facilities to ICAR retirees, and NBPGR employees were covered.

¶ 3.1 · ¶ 5.2

Serving NBPGR employees continue to receive CGHS facilities.

¶ 8.3

By letter dated 22.04.2022, respondent No. 4 sought advance CGHS contributions for ICAR beneficiaries at NBPGR for 2022-23.

¶ 3.1

Respondent No. 5 then informed respondent No. 3 that NBPGR pensioners were not covered, and by letter dated 26.07.2022 respondent No. 4 confirmed that retired NBPGR employees were not extended CGHS facilities.

¶ 3.1

The applicants' representation to respondent No. 5 was unanswered.

¶ 3.1

The applicants seek restoration of CGHS facilities, reimbursement of the fixed monthly medical allowance from 01.04.2022, and interim consultation and reimbursement at CGHS rates.

¶ 2

Respondents 1, 4 and 5 rely on the MoHFW OM dated 10.06.2014.

¶ 6.1

Respondent No. 3 (ICAR) recommended on 26.09.2022 and 27.01.2023 that retirees of NBPGR and NBSS&LUP be granted CGHS facilities subject to the 2014 OM.

¶ 7.1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the withdrawal of CGHS facilities from retired NBPGR employees, while serving NBPGR employees retain them, constitutes an artificial and unjustified distinction.

¶ 8.3 · ¶ 8.4

ii.2. Whether the conditions in the MoHFW OM dated 10.06.2014 justify denying CGHS facilities to retired employees of ICAR constituent units in Delhi.

¶ 8.2 · ¶ 8.4

iii.3. Whether the matter requires coordinated, uniform policy-making between the MoHFW and DARE, and whether the applicants' reliefs can be granted in the present proceedings.

¶ 8.4 · ¶ 8.5 · ¶ 8.6 · ¶ 9.1

03Law Applied

The principle of non-arbitrariness was expressly invoked by the Tribunal as the touchstone for the respondents' policy decision.

¶ 8.6

The absence of any "rational or reasonable justification" for distinguishing serving from retired employees was treated as central to the Tribunal's prima facie view.

¶ 8.3

The MoHFW OM dated 20.10.1982 extended CGHS to ICAR retirees.

¶ 3.1

The MoHFW OM dated 10.06.2014 permits CGHS extension to retirees of statutory or autonomous bodies whose serving employees are already covered, subject to conditions: cost-to-cost basis, OPD facilities only at Delhi/NCR wellness centres, IPD costs borne by the body, and advance annual payment of service charges.

¶ 8.2 · OM paras. 2–4

The ICAR Rules, Rule 2(k), defining "Constituent Units" to include research institutions, were argued by the applicants but were not analysed by the Tribunal.

¶ 5.1

The Tribunal's jurisdiction is under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.

¶ 2

No case law is cited in the order.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The Tribunal observed that the 2014 OM makes CGHS extension to retirees of autonomous bodies conditional on acceptance of stipulated terms and an IFD-recommended proposal forwarded by the administrative ministry.

¶ 8.4

It found that the admitted position, namely CGHS for serving NBPGR staff but not for retirees since 2022, appeared prima facie artificial, and that no rational basis for the distinction had been shown.

¶ 8.3

The Tribunal noted a similar distinction between ICAR institutions in Delhi and those elsewhere.

¶ 8.4

Because the policy spans two Ministries (MoHFW and DARE), the Tribunal held that it required inter-departmental coordination rather than adjudication on the merits in this forum.

¶ 8.4

The Tribunal therefore did not decide the Article 14 challenge or the quantum of relief.

¶ 8.4 · ¶ 9.1

The ICAR's supportive recommendations and the MoHFW's reliance on the 2014 OM were treated as informing the policy process, not as determinative.

¶ 7.1 · ¶ 6.1

05Holding

The Tribunal held prima facie that the distinction between serving and retired NBPGR employees, and between Delhi and non-Delhi ICAR institutions, appears artificial and is not supported by any rational justification.

¶ 8.3 · ¶ 8.4

The Tribunal did not finally determine the merits or grant the applicants' specific reliefs (restoration, medical allowance reimbursement, or interim consultation).

¶ 2 · ¶ 9.1

The OA was disposed of with directions that the Secretaries of MoHFW and DARE hold a joint meeting, examine practice for ICAR institutions in other cities and the basis for it, and adopt a uniform policy consistent with the 2014 OM and non-arbitrariness, and that respondents take a final decision within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy of the order, in line with the observations at paras. 8.3–8.6.

¶ 8.5 · ¶ 8.6 · ¶ 9.1

No order as to costs was made, and pending MAs stand disposed of.

¶ 10 · ¶ 11
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

ANIL KUMAR AGARWALvsHEALTH

CAT - ['Delhi'] · October 27, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment