01Facts
The applicant, a Track Maintainer with Northern Railway at Dehradun, was issued a warning letter dated 02.06.2025 for negligence in duty on 31.05.2025. He replied on 09.06.2025.
¶ 7A memorandum of charge dated 26.06.2025 was then issued under Rule 11 of the Railway Servants (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1968 ("Rules, 1968").
¶ 7The disciplinary authority, finding the reply unsatisfactory, imposed a minor penalty by order dated 19.07.2025 withholding privilege ticket orders for 2025.
¶ 7The applicant filed a departmental appeal dated 10.04.2026, which was dismissed by the appellate order dated 13.05.2026.
¶ 8Without filing a revision under Rule 25, the applicant approached the Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 ("AT Act"), seeking quashing of both orders and restoration of the privilege ticket orders.
¶ 6, 8The respondents raised a preliminary objection that the revision remedy had not been exhausted.
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the remedy of revision under Rule 25 of the Rules, 1968 is optional or mandatory, and whether non-exhaustion of it bars an application under Section 20 of the AT Act.
¶ 5 · ¶ 1203Law Applied
Section 20 of the AT Act bars admission of an application unless all remedies under the relevant service rules have been availed, and treats a final order on appeal as exhausting remedies, subject to the memorial exception in Section 20(3).
¶ 13Rule 18 of the Rules, 1968 provides for appeal against penalty orders.
¶ 14Rule 25 empowers specified authorities to revise orders at any time, bars revision until the appeal period expires or the appeal is disposed of, and sets limitation periods and condonation for delay.
¶ 14Arun Kumar Jain v. Union of India (1986) holds that the revision remedy must be exhausted within time.
¶ 15The Tribunal's decision in Raja Ram (OA No. 2113/2002) treats revision as mandatory.
¶ 16The Tribunal's decision in J.K. Kumawat (OA No. 1164/2005, Jabalpur) treats revision as mandatory.
¶ 17The Tribunal's decision in G.D. Sharma (OA No. 87/2010, Principal Bench) treats revision as mandatory.
¶ 18Sudama Prasad Kori (OA No. 285/2006, Jabalpur) is relied upon by the Tribunal.
¶ 23The harmonious construction principle from CIT v. Hindustan Bulk Carriers (2003) 3 SCC 57 requires that statutory provisions be read so as to give effect to each and none rendered otherwise nugatory.
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19Section 20
04Reasoning
The Tribunal read Section 20 of the AT Act together with Rules 18 and 25 of the Rules, 1968.
¶ 19–22The object of these provisions is to give lower-strata employees a further opportunity to have the penalty reconsidered by a higher authority on facts and law.
¶ 25Treating a final appellate order as sufficient would read down Rule 25 and render it nugatory, contrary to Hindustan Bulk Carriers. Section 20(3) is an exception only for memorials to the President or Governor, which the applicant had not filed.
¶ 26The Tribunal rejected the applicant's submission that revision is optional and accepted the respondents' objection.
¶ 27–2805Holding
The revision remedy under Rule 25 of the Rules, 1968 is mandatory, not optional, and non-exhaustion of it bars the applicant from approaching the Tribunal.
¶ 29The O.A. was dismissed in limine at the admission stage as not maintainable. The applicant was granted liberty to file a revision within thirty days of receiving a certified copy of the order. The competent authority is directed to decide that revision on merits, waiving limitation. No order as to costs.
¶ 30–31Original Court PDF
Sandeep KumarvsRAILWAY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Railway Track Maintainer's Privilege-Ticket Challenge Dismissed as CAT Holds Revision Mandatory Before Approaching Tribunal. Sandeep Kumar vs RAILWAY. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/railway-track-maintainer-s-privilege-ticket-challenge-dismissed-as-cat-holds-revision-mand-764a7cc11a8f4625a0e1133e067d1c8e.webp)