01Facts
This Court's judgment of 16 February 2018 in Karnataka v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2018) 4 SCC 1, modified the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal award of 5 February 2007 and directed the Union to frame a scheme for its implementation.
¶ 2, 13The Union notified the Cauvery Water Management Scheme on 1 June 2018, establishing the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC).
¶ 3Owing to a rainfall deficit in the current irrigation year, Tamil Nadu sought release of water from Karnataka's reservoirs by letter dated 14 July 2026.
¶ 4At its 54th meeting on 30 July 2026, the CWMA directed Karnataka to ensure flows of 3,500 cusecs at Biligundulu for 15 days from 29 July 2026.
¶ 5Tamil Nadu contended that a shortfall of 5.379 TMC would remain even after compliance, that the backlog could not be permitted to accumulate, and that Karnataka was wilfully non-compliant.
¶ 7Karnataka contended that the releases are not inflexible, that shortfalls may be carried forward to January, and that obligations may be proportionately reduced in a distress year.
¶ 8Karnataka admitted a two-day delay but stated the deficit was made good, with 86,797 cusecs recorded at Biligundulu against a stipulated 45,500 cusecs; Tamil Nadu fairly acknowledged this.
¶ 10The CWRC meets every fifteen days.
¶ 12At its 57th meeting on 8 September 2026, the CWMA directed flows of 6,000 cusecs from 9 September 2026 for 15 days.
¶ 18At its 58th meeting on 24 September 2026, the CWMA recorded that there was no backlog shortfall and directed Karnataka to maintain the stipulated daily average flows, subject to monitoring by the CWRC and CWMA.
¶ 24A separate application was filed by DMK, a non-party to the original proceedings.
¶ 2702Issues
i.1. Whether this Court should direct Karnataka to implement the CWMA's directions and ensure stipulated releases at Biligundulu, and direct the CWMA to monitor flows and enforce compliance, when the expert bodies are already seized of the matter.
¶ 1, 9, 13ii.2. Whether this Court should direct Karnataka to make good the alleged pro-rata shortfall of water at Biligundulu, given that its quantification is disputed.
¶ 16(b), 21iii.3. Whether the grievances of Tamil Nadu regarding the shortfall were inadequately addressed by the CWRC and CWMA, such that judicial intervention is warranted.
¶ 22–24iv.4. Whether a non-party to the original proceedings may raise claims or objections in the disposed-of civil appeal.
¶ 2803Law Applied
The Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal award of 5 February 2007, as modified by this Court's judgment of 16 February 2018 in Karnataka v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2018) 4 SCC 1, which determined the inter-State allocation and the governing principles for sharing Cauvery waters.
¶ 2, 13, 21The Cauvery Water Management Scheme of 1 June 2018, framed by the Union pursuant to this Court's direction, which vests the monitoring and regulation of releases in the CWMA and CWRC.
¶ 3, 13The principle that the Court should not assume the role of the expert authorities constituted to oversee implementation, and that disputed hydrological and distress calculations are to be left to those bodies.
¶ 13, 21The principle that the scope of an award should not be enlarged by entertaining claims of a person who was not a party to the original proceedings.
¶ 2804Reasoning
The applications sought to draw the Court into the day-to-day monitoring of release schedules, a function already entrusted to the CWMA and CWRC under the Scheme framed at this Court's direction.
¶ 13Because both bodies include representatives of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka and meet fortnightly to hear parties and issue directions, the Court found the apprehension of an annual allocation shortfall premature.
¶ 11, 12As to the first prayer, Karnataka's compliance was supported by the record, including its excess release of water beyond the 8 September 2026 stipulation.
¶ 10, 20As to the second prayer, the Court declined to adjudicate the disputed shortfall computations, holding that such quantification involves assessment of distress across the entire basin and must be left to the CWRC and CWMA.
¶ 21On Tamil Nadu's claim of inadequate redressal, the Court examined the minutes of the CWRC and CWMA meetings of 8 and 24 September 2026, found that the grievances had been specifically considered, and noted that the CWMA had recorded no backlog shortfall and issued further directions.
¶ 22–24On the DMK application, the Court held that Tamil Nadu adequately represented the concerns raised, and that the award should not be enlarged at the instance of a non-party.
¶ 2805Holding
The Court declined to direct Karnataka to implement the CWMA's decisions or to make good the alleged shortfall, and left the disputed quantification to the CWRC and CWMA "in accordance with law."
¶ 21The Court held that the grievances of Tamil Nadu had been addressed by the expert bodies, and that a non-party could not raise claims in the disposed-of appeal.
¶ 22–24, 28Misc. Application No. 2445 of 2026 (paras 1–15), Misc. Application No. 2843 of 2026 (paras 16–26), and Misc. Application D. No. 46291 of 2026 (paras 27–30) were all dismissed, and pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 14, 15, 25, 26, 29, 30The CWMA's directions of 24 September 2026, requiring Karnataka to maintain stipulated daily average flows under monitoring by the CWRC and CWMA, were left in place.
¶ 24Original Court PDF
State Of Tamil NaduvsState Of Karnataka
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
