01Facts
The respondents (plaintiffs) sued the appellants (defendants) in O.S. No. 26925/2007 for specific performance of an agreement of sale dated 23.11.2004, for a declaration that the sale deed dated 07.09.2007 was not binding on them, and for permanent injunction.
¶ 4The defendants did not appear when the suit was listed on 23.11.2007. The trial court recorded that they had refused to receive summons and placed them ex parte.
¶ 5 · ¶ 13The respondents' case is that the process server attempted service on 15.11.2007, 22.11.2007 and 23.07.2007, and, upon refusal, affixed the summons on the door of the residence shown in the cause title.
¶ 12The court decreed the suit on 23.04.2011, directing execution of the sale deed within one month.
¶ 5The defendants filed Misc. Petition No. 25188/2012 under Order IX Rule 13 CPC to set aside the ex parte decree, contending that summons was not validly served, was not refused, and was not affixed as required.
¶ 5, 13The Misc. Court dismissed the petition on 18.01.2020.
¶ 5The defendants' own later suit, O.S. No. 8754/2010 for possession, shows the same address, and in cross-examination in that suit, PW1 (Nagendra) stated that he had appeared in O.S. No. 26925/2007.
¶ 7, 14, 20The defendants did not examine the process server or mark his shara (report) in evidence.
¶ 14, 20, 2102Issues
i.1. Whether the impugned order dated 18.01.2020 in Misc. Petition No. 25188/2012, dismissing the Order IX Rule 13 CPC petition, calls for interference?
¶ 18(i)ii.2. Whether the summons in O.S. No. 26925/2007 was validly served in accordance with law, or was flawed for non-compliance with the procedure under Order V Rule 17 CPC?
¶ 1903Law Applied
Order IX Rule 13 CPC governs setting aside an ex parte decree and requires the defendant to establish a valid case for it.
¶ 5, 17Order V Rule 17 CPC governs service by affixing summons on the defendant's door where the summons is refused or cannot be served, and the process server's report is the primary evidence of such service.
¶ 10, 16, 19Order V Rule 19 CPC requires the process server to file an affidavit where summons is affixed under the rules.
¶ 10, 21No case law is cited in the judgment.
04Reasoning
The statutory question was limited to whether the summons was properly served under Order V Rule 17 CPC.
¶ 19The defendants did not examine the process server, did not produce or mark the shara, and did not show how service was effected or why the affixation was flawed.
¶ 20, 21The address of the defendants was undisputed and identical across the earlier suit, the later suit, and the cause title.
¶ 20The defendants' failure to lead evidence on the process server's conduct was treated as decisive, and a bare assertion of non-compliance with Order V Rule 19 was held not to displace the official return.
¶ 21PW1's cross-examination in O.S. No. 8754/2010, where he admitted appearing in O.S. No. 26925/2007, was relied upon to show knowledge of the suit.
¶ 14, 2205Holding
The defendants did not establish that summons was improperly served or that the ex parte proceedings were vitiated, and there was no good or cogent reason to interfere with the Misc. Court's reasoned order.
¶ 21, 22The appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(d) CPC is dismissed, and the order dated 18.01.2020 in Misc. Petition No. 25188/2012 is upheld, leaving the ex parte decree in O.S. No. 26925/2007 undisturbed.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
SRI M NAGENDRAvsSRI B S RAMAIAH
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
