01Facts
The respondent-plaintiff sued for damages, alleging that the petitioner-defendant used unparliamentary and defamatory expressions during a telephonic conversation with one H.R. Umesh.
¶ 4During the pending suit (O.S. No. 1907/2018), the plaintiff applied for permission to produce a Compact Disc (CD) containing the electronic record of the alleged conversation or WhatsApp communications received from Umesh.
¶ 4By order dated 06.02.2020 on I.A. No. 5, the LVIII Additional Civil Judge (CCH-59), Bengaluru, permitted production of the CD.
¶ 1The defendant challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution, contending that the CD is a computer output and that no certificate under Section 65B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 was produced.
¶ 1, 2, 5The respondent was served but did not appear.
¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court erred in permitting the plaintiff to produce a CD containing an electronic record without insisting on a certificate under Section 65B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
¶ 2 · ¶ 5ii.2. Whether an order permitting production of an electronic record amounts to a determination of its admissibility or evidentiary value, or dispenses with the requirements of Section 65B(4).
¶ 10 · ¶ 1303Law Applied
The court relied on Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1, which holds that Section 65B is a complete and self-contained code for admissibility of electronic records, and that a Section 65B(4) certificate is a mandatory condition precedent for admitting a computer output such as a CD, while Sections 63 and 65 cannot be invoked to prove such records.
¶ 6, 7The certificate may be produced at any stage before the conclusion of trial, and where a person refuses or is unable to furnish it, the party may seek directions from the Court.
¶ 8The original device (e.g., a mobile phone containing WhatsApp messages) proved through its owner or operator is an exception to the certificate requirement.
¶ 8Khotkar overruled Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2018) 2 SCC 801, declared Tomaso Bruno v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2015) 7 SCC 178 per incuriam, and restored Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, AIR 2015 SC 180.
¶ 9Permission to produce a record is distinct from a determination of its admissibility and evidentiary value.
¶ 10Provisions in the judgment · 3
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Section 65Section 63Section 65
04Reasoning
The court first held that Khotkar settles the law and that a Section 65B(4) certificate is mandatory for a computer output.
¶ 6The court distinguished the impugned order: the CD was not the original mobile phone or device but a computer output relied on by the plaintiff, so the Section 65B(4) requirements would have to be satisfied when the CD is tendered and its contents marked, unless the original electronic record is produced in a legally recognised manner.
¶ 11Applying the rule that the certificate may be filed later, the court held that the absence of a certificate at the permission stage does not mean the record can never be produced, although the record cannot be admitted without satisfying the statutory conditions.
¶ 12On that basis, the court concluded that permission to produce the CD is not a dispensation of Section 65B(4) and not a finding that the contents are proved.
¶ 10, 13The petitioner's objections were left open for the trial judge, who must not treat mere production as proof of contents.
¶ 1305Holding
The court held that the order permitting production of the CD cannot be construed as dispensing with Section 65B(4), and that permission to produce is not a determination of admissibility or proof of contents.
¶ 10, 13The writ petition is dismissed, and the impugned order is upheld subject to the clarifications.
¶ 15(i)The order permitting production of the CD is not a determination of its admissibility or evidentiary value; the plaintiff must satisfy Section 65B of the Evidence Act at the stage of tendering the electronic record; all of the petitioner's contentions on admissibility, authenticity and evidentiary value are kept open; and the trial judge shall proceed with the suit in accordance with law.
¶ 15(ii)–(v)Original Court PDF
DR.R.CHANNABASAVEGOWDAvsDR.CHAMEGOWDA T.C.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
